Welcome to the new Nifty!Learn what's new →|Switch back to classic
Nifty
AuthorsNew storiesSearchPublish your storyDonate to the Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2026 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

Made with love byCoyote

Story Collections

Gay Male StoriesLesbian StoriesBisexual StoriesTransgender StoriesStory listsAll LGBTQ+ StoriesNew and Updated Stories

Popular Categories

College StoriesGay Incest StoriesAuthoritarian StoriesSci-Fi & FantasyAthletics

The Archive

Switch back to classic NiftyAbout NiftyExplore the new NiftySearch StoriesBrowse AuthorsAuthor InterviewsWhat's New❤️ Donate

The Organization

Mission StatementSubmit a StoryTerms and ConditionsPrivacy PolicyUseful LinksContact

Special Collections

LGBTQ+ InformationJournal EntriesKovzlandVince WaterIan Duncan

Follow Us

BlueskyRedditXNifty Shop
Log in
← Back to Gay Stories

Gay Butt Plug Stories

Browse 5 free butt plug gay stories. Read online with no subscription required.

Discover butt plug gay erotic stories on Nifty Archive. Sort by newest, top rated, most read, or longest, explore related gay tags and themes, or search the full archive. Every story is free to read with no subscription required, and new butt plug stories are added daily by authors worldwide.

Related Gay Tags

Other gay story tags that readers of butt plug stories also browse.

  • Age Gap
  • Anal Sex
  • Anonymous
  • Bareback
  • BDSM
  • Blackmail / Coercion
  • Body Modification
  • Bondage
  • Brother / Brother
  • Business / Office
  • Captivity
  • Casual Sex
  • CBT
  • Character Driven
  • Chastity
  • Cheating
  • Coming of Age
  • Coming Out / Awakening

Related Butt Plug Themes

Themes that frequently appear in butt plug gay stories. Search the archive by theme.

  • BDSM
  • Dom/sub
  • Humiliation
  • Bondage
  • Leather
  • Cock Ring
  • Slave
  • Spanking
  • Cuckold
  • Cum Play
  • Medical Fetish
  • Non Consensual
  • Club
  • Group Sex

Sort Stories

Dec 5, 2024
  • Encounters

Virtual whispers to hidden desires: the secret rooms of a business man

By Rishaad Khan
Dec 5, 2024
  • Encounters

5.1K words

900+ views

A chance interview reignites a long-lost virtual connection, unleashing a torrent of pent-up lust and domination.

Apr 22, 2010
  • Authoritarian
  • Urination

Gym Jocks Bitch

By Mr Stretch
Apr 22, 2010
  • Authoritarian
  • Urination

7 chapters

18K words

2K+ views

A submissive twink is totally owned and humiliated by his dominant master at a Chicago bath house every night.

Nov 29, 2003
  • Authoritarian

Hot Man for You to Use

By Garth Wells
Nov 29, 2003
  • Authoritarian

2 chapters

7.4K words

700+ views

A male stripper is taken to a decadent mansion party where he's bound, whipped, and forced to perform for a crowd of lecherous guests.

Mar 26, 1995
  • Encounters

Steam Supreme

By John Dawson
Mar 26, 1995
  • Encounters

3.7K words

100+ views

A man hits the steam room for anonymous sex and gets more than he bargained for.

Sep 26, 1993
  • Authoritarian

KIDNAPPED

By moc.elppa.proc.sbb-cigam@yeliR_.B_treboR
Sep 26, 1993
  • Authoritarian

1.8K words

2.3K+ views

5.0(3)

A submissive is kidnapped, blindfolded, and subjected to intense BDSM at the hands of multiple captors, culminating in a night with his Master.

  • Dec 5, 2024Virtual whispers to hidden desires: the secret rooms of a business man
    5.1K words900+ views
  • Apr 22, 2010Gym Jocks Bitch
    7 chapters18K words2,000+ views
  • Nov 29, 2003Hot Man for You to Use
    2 chapters7.4K words700+ views
  • Mar 26, 1995Steam Supreme
    3.7K words100+ views
  • Sep 26, 1993KIDNAPPED
    1.8K words2,300+ views

Top rated Butt Plug stories

  • Gym Jocks Bitch

    By Mr Stretch
    • Authoritarian
    • Urination
    • +1

    Apr 22

  • KIDNAPPED

    By moc.elppa.proc.sbb-cigam@yeliR_.B_treboR
    • Authoritarian
    5.0(3)

    Sep 26

Most read Butt Plug stories

  • KIDNAPPED

    By moc.elppa.proc.sbb-cigam@yeliR_.B_treboR
    • Authoritarian
    5.0(3)

    Sep 26

  • Gym Jocks Bitch

    By Mr Stretch
    • Authoritarian
    • Urination
    • +1

    Apr 22

  • Virtual whispers to hidden desires: the secret rooms of a business man

    By Rishaad Khan
    • Encounters

    Dec 5

  • Hot Man for You to Use

    By Garth Wells
    • Authoritarian

    Nov 29

Longest Butt Plug stories

  • Gym Jocks Bitch

    By Mr Stretch
    • Authoritarian
    • Urination
    • +1

    Apr 22

  • Hot Man for You to Use

    By Garth Wells
    • Authoritarian

    Nov 29

  • Virtual whispers to hidden desires: the secret rooms of a business man

    By Rishaad Khan
    • Encounters

    Dec 5

  • Steam Supreme

    By John Dawson
    • Encounters

    Mar 26