Welcome to the new Nifty!Learn what's new →|Switch back to classic
Nifty
AuthorsNew storiesSearchPublish your storyDonate to the Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2026 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

Made with love byCoyote

Story Collections

Gay Male StoriesLesbian StoriesBisexual StoriesTransgender StoriesStory listsAll LGBTQ+ StoriesNew and Updated Stories

Popular Categories

College StoriesGay Incest StoriesAuthoritarian StoriesSci-Fi & FantasyAthletics

The Archive

Switch back to classic NiftyAbout NiftyExplore the new NiftySearch StoriesBrowse AuthorsAuthor InterviewsWhat's New❤️ Donate

The Organization

Mission StatementSubmit a StoryTerms and ConditionsPrivacy PolicyUseful LinksContact

Special Collections

LGBTQ+ InformationJournal EntriesKovzlandVince WaterIan Duncan

Follow Us

BlueskyRedditXNifty Shop
Log in
← Back to Lesbian Stories

Lesbian Butt Plug Stories

Browse 2 free butt plug lesbian stories. Read online with no subscription required.

Discover butt plug lesbian erotic stories on Nifty Archive. Sort by newest, top rated, most read, or longest, explore related lesbian tags and themes, or search the full archive. Every story is free to read with no subscription required, and new butt plug stories are added daily by authors worldwide.

Related Lesbian Tags

Other lesbian story tags that readers of butt plug stories also browse.

  • Age Gap
  • Anal Sex
  • Anonymous
  • BDSM
  • Blackmail / Coercion
  • Body Modification
  • Bondage
  • Business / Office
  • Captivity
  • Casual Sex
  • Character Driven
  • Chastity
  • Cheating
  • Coming of Age
  • Coming Out / Awakening
  • Creampie
  • Cuckold
  • Cum Play

Related Butt Plug Themes

Themes that frequently appear in butt plug lesbian stories. Search the archive by theme.

  • Consent
  • Dom/sub
  • F/F
  • Sex Toys
  • Bisexual
  • Bondage
  • Nipple Play
  • Older Woman
  • Pegging
  • Spanking
  • Sybian
  • Threesome
  • BDSM
  • Dominant

Sort Stories

Dec 12, 2018
  • Authoritarian

Love Thy Neighbor

By Marie Taylor
Dec 12, 2018
  • Authoritarian

14K words

2.5K+ views

A distressed neighbor's visit sparks a sizzling lesbian affair that unfolds into a night of unbridled passion and multiple climaxes with not one, but two seductive women.

Jul 14, 2004
  • Authoritarian

Doctors Orders

By Petra Rose
Jul 14, 2004
  • Authoritarian

3 chapters

3.9K words

1.4K+ views

A doctor-patient encounter turns into a series of intense erotic examinations and passionate encounters between Doctor Rose and Mary Smith.

  • Dec 12, 2018Love Thy Neighbor
    14K words2,500+ views
  • Jul 14, 2004Doctors Orders
    3 chapters3.9K words1,400+ views

Most read Butt Plug stories

  • Love Thy Neighbor

    By Marie Taylor
    • Authoritarian

    Dec 12

  • Doctors Orders

    By Petra Rose
    • Authoritarian

    Jul 14

Longest Butt Plug stories

  • Love Thy Neighbor

    By Marie Taylor
    • Authoritarian

    Dec 12

  • Doctors Orders

    By Petra Rose
    • Authoritarian

    Jul 14