What A Surprise

By Dan B

Published on Nov 25, 2009

Gay

I had been quite surprised about a week earlier when one of my youngest brother's friends stayed over at my house after a party and we ended up having sex. I was 25 and Eddie had just turned 18. He was actually my brother's buddy but we'd talked at the party and I invited him to stay over since he'd had a fight with his dad.

Eddie was a cute kid. He was 6 feet tall, very thin and had black curly hair that he wore quite long. He had a very handsome face and a nicely packed thin body. I'd have never expected that in his shorts he was carrying a cock that was, up until that time, the largest I'd ever seen. In fact I'd been very surprised that first night when I saw the thing, let alone when I sucked it and he sucked me.

The next morning we woke up and he looked uncomfortable being naked in the same bed with me and said he had to get home early. He got up and I saw that big cock soft and it was still very impressive. It hung down, and was probably about six inches long when it was soft. He found his underwear under the bed, put them on and said goodbye and thanks for letting him stay. He never said a word about us sucking each other so I figured that was it. He'd had enough to drink the night before and now that he was sober he was embarrassed about it. I decided I'd probably seen the last of him in my bed.

About a week later I heard a loud vehicle go past my bedroom window and then a short while I heard it come past again. When it came down the street a third time, I got up and looked out the window. It was Eddie in his old pickup. I switched the bedroom light on and then back off and he slowed down and turned into the alley that led to my back yard.

I slipped my flip flops on my feet and a tee shirt on and went to the back door to see Eddie sitting in his truck, the engine off. I walked over to the truck. "Hey, what's up?" "Oh, I was just in the neighborhood and thought you might be up yet." "Well I was in bed until I heard this truck. You need a muffler." He laughed. "Yeah, I know, sorry I woke you."

I motioned for the lawn chairs. "Well, I'm up now, want to sit and have a beer?" "Sure," he said. I went into the house and when I got back Eddie was sitting in one of the chairs. He was wearing cutoffs, a tank top and sandals. He looked positively gorgeous in the moonlight. I walked to him and handed him a beer. When he took it his hand wrapped around mine for a second and then he gripped the beer and took it from me. "Thanks, for the beer," he said. "No problem, you're welcome here any time," I said. He nodded, opened his beer and took a drink. "So what've you been doing since I saw you last?" I asked. "Oh, I've been working with that guy who roofs houses," he said. "It's kind of hard work but I get a lot of sun, so my tan is getting dang good." "Yeah, you look nice," I said. "Here, look at this," he said as he stripped off his tank top showing dark skin and his lovely frame. He pulled down the edge of his cutoffs and showed me his tan line. It really showed how dark he was. "Wow, that's great," I said. "I wish I could get tan like that." I could see the top of his pubes and they showed dark against his white skin.

He sat back down and I knew he was looking for more than a beer. "So what else is up?" I said giving him an opening. "Well, um I was thinking about the last time I was here and um, well..." I looked at him but didn't give him a way out. I wanted him to say if for himself. "Well what?" I said quietly. "Remember that `experience' we had?" "Yeah, I do and it was great," I said. "Well, um, I was wondering if we could do that again maybe." I smiled and stepped up to him. I reached down and took his beer and set it down and then motioned for him to stand up. I put my arms around him and hugged him to me. His arms went around me and he sighed as he nuzzled my neck. I dropped my hands to his little butt and squeezed his butt cheeks. Then I kissed him on the cheek.

He looked at me and kissed me back on my cheek. Then we stared at each other for a few seconds, getting closer and closer and soon our lips met and we shared a deep tongue mingling kiss. When we came up for air, he was humping into me and I could feel that huge cock of his pushing against mine. "Let's go in the house," I whispered.

I took Eddie's hand and we went in and walked down the hall to the bedroom. I didn't turn on the light but there was plenty of light from the stars and moon shining in through the windows. We stood facing each other and Eddie reached out and lifted my tee shirt up over my head. He was still bare from the waist up, so I undid the top button of his cutoffs and dropped them to the floor. Now we both were in our underwear and both had raging hardons. I rubbed my hand up and down the shaft of his big cock and he leaned his head back and moaned. Then I pulled his underwear down and there was that big hard cock that I'd enjoyed two weeks earlier. Eddie pulled down my underwear and took hold of my 5.5 inch cock and began to stroke me. "Let's get in bed," I said quietly.

We lay down facing each other and both of us played with the other's cock while we kissed. Soon our legs and feet were entwined and we were getting very hot. "I want to suck you," I said. Eddie got up and then lay down head to foot and there it was right in my face. His cock was about 8 inches, had a large plum shaped head and a nice thick shaft. He had a nice trimmed bush and hairless nutsack. His balls weren't huge, but that didn't matter to me. I felt his mouth close over my cock and he swallowed it all the way. While mine is only 5.5 inches, it's very thick and not a lot of guys can take it all the way at first. Eddie was sucking on mine so I put as much of his as I could get in my mouth and began to suck him. His precum was leaking like crazy and I licked it off with my tongue.

We'd been sucking each other for a couple of minutes when I felt Eddie rubbing his finger up and down over my butt hole. That turned me on so I raised my leg to give him a better access to it. He took the hint and soon was sticking his finger up my butt. It felt great to have my cock in his mouth and his finger in my butt.

"Would you let me fuck you?" he said. "What?" Wow, I'm not sure Eddie, that cock of yours is really huge." "Oh, ok sorry." Shit, now I felt bad. I'm sure he had been nervous about asking that and then I shot him down. "Put another finger in my butt and we'll see if you can get me loosened up," I said. "Really? Ok," he said. Soon he had three fingers up my ass and was reaming me hard. It felt really good so I decided to let him put his cock in there in place of his fingers.

"I'll get some lube from the bathroom," I said. I got up and got some hand lotion and a towel and came back to the bed. Eddie was lying on his back playing with that big cock of his and smiling. "I really appreciate this," he said. "This is all I've thought about since that last time."

I lubed up his cock and then really lubed my asshole and lay down on my stomach. Eddie lay on top of me and I could feel his big cock pressing at my crack. I lifted my ass a little and he was groping around trying to find my hole with his dickhead. I reached back and took hold of his cock and put it at my hole. "Now, go slow," I said. "That thing is really big. I have to get used to it." "Ok, I promise," he said.

Well, he pushed and my ass felt like it was about to split open. I moaned and he let up. "Ok try again," I said breathlessly. He pushed again and although it hurt like hell I gritted my teeth and suddenly the head popped in. `Stop! Hold it there for a second," I said. Eddie didn't move a muscle. I let my ass relax as much as possible. It felt like someone had shoved a ball bat up my ass, but I wanted to let him do this so I told him to keep pushing but to go slow.

Eddie was really gentle and patient and in a couple of minutes it felt like my ass was full and felt like it would explode, but the pain had subsided and it was feeling pretty ok. "How far are you in?" I asked. "Right to the hilt," he said. Damn! When I thought of how big that cock was I couldn't imagine it was all in my ass but apparently I'd managed to take it all. "Ok, start to fuck me but not too fast," I said. Eddie pulled his cock nearly out and then slid back in. When he pulled out my ass felt empty and then felt great to be filled up again. Soon I was arching up to meet him when he rammed me. He increased his thrusts and I was panting as he fucked me harder and faster. Soon he began to grunt and I knew he was getting close. I felt his dick jump and knew he was having an orgasm. He collapsed on me with his dick buried as far as it could go and held it there as he spewed his cum into my ass. We lay like that for three or four minutes and then I could feel his dick shrinking and sliding out of my ass. When it slipped out I hated the empty feeling I was left with.

Eddie rolled off me and lay on the bed on his back. I rolled over on my side and put my arms around him and snuggled up to him. "So did that make you feel good?" I asked. "Holy shit, that was fantastic. I hope I didn't hurt you." "No at first it was kind of painful but that goes away after a while." "Then it feels good?" "Yeah then it feels great, you've got a dandy cock it made me feel wonderful." He smiled and hugged me. We kissed a few times and then he reached down and felt my hard cock. "You need to cum," he said. "I can jerk if off or whatever. I'm sure you're out of the mood now that you've cum." "That's not fair," he said. "I want you to cum too."

He played with my cock and then seemed to be sizing it up. "Do you think I could take it up my butt?" "Are you sure Eddie? I mean, I'd love to fuck you but you don't have to." "I want to. I'm not sure about this stuff. I know I loved doing what we did last week and I loved fucking you. I've fucked girls too so I'm kind of confused as to if I'm gay or straight. I want to have the experience of being fucked to see what that's like." "If you're sure," I said. "I'm sure, let's do it."

We lubed up his butt and I stretched him out with two then three fingers. Soon his hole seemed fairly loose and I lubed up my cock. "Why don't you sit on it, so you can control how much you take?" I said. He thought that was a good idea, so I lay on my back and he squatted over my crotch. His big cock was still limp but even limp it was about 5 inches, the same as mine is hard. But mine is thick and I wasn't sure if he could take it. He positioned my cock head at his ass and began to impale himself on it. He closed his eyes and pushed harder and soon my dickhead slid in his ass. He stopped and took a deep breath and looked down at me. "Hurts a bit," he said. "That'll pass," I said.

He pushed again and slid down farther. A few more pushes and he was sitting on my crotch. My cock was buried in his ass. I closed my eyes and marveled at the great feeling of his ass clenching my hard cock. He began to move up and down and soon he began to smile. "It's feeling amazing," he said. I knew he liked it because his cock was getting hard. He humped up and down on my cock and I took hold of his and began to slowly jack him off. He started moving faster and faster and I could feel my cum rising. "I'm about to blow Eddie," I said. He increased his speed and suddenly my cock began to shoot cum into him. I kept pulling on his dick and a few seconds later he shot cum clear up on my face. He squatted down on my cock as it shriveled and only got up when it slid out of his ass. I reached over and got the towel I'd brought from the bathroom and wiped up his cum from my face and stomach. Then I wiped off my dick and his ass.

We lay down again and put our arms around each other. "Well, how was it for you?" I asked. "I think I know now which team I'm on." We grinned at each other.

"Can you stay all night?" I asked. "Sure, I'd love to." I pulled the covers up over us and we fell asleep naked in each other's arms. I felt pretty lucky to have found this young guy who made me feel so great. I was glad I'd taken the chance of letting him fuck me. It proved to be a great move.

My other stories:

Young Friends: Oct. 14, A Kid's Game

Oct 15, Staying Warm High School: Nov. 2, Deerhunting Sleepover

Nov. 5 Lifeguarding Bonus

Nov. 6 Fun with Casey

Nov. 13, More Fun with Casey

Nov. 15 Camping with Terry

Nov. 21 Casey and the Horsecock Beginnings: Oct. 15, What a Surprise

Nov. 17, Seduced by Mike Adult/Youth: Oct. 19, Running Naked

Oct. 26, Antique Store Experience

Nov.19, Paperboy Delivery DIR

Thanks for the nice emails. I'm glad that you enjoy the stories. I sure enjoy writing them.


Rate this story

Liked this story?

Nifty is entirely volunteer-run and relies on people like you to keep the site running. Please support the Nifty Archive and keep this content available to all!

Donate to The Nifty Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2024 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

The Archive

About NiftyLinks❤️Donate