Please do not reprint this story without permission. Comments welcomed.
This is a 100% true story about the first time I got fucked by a man. I am 40 years old and it happened last week.
I've been closeted my entire life. I got married and lived a straight life, but I never lost my interest in men. The last few years I've been slowly experimenting and finally I have a regular buddy to have some fun with. We are both in excellent shape and pretty muscular. I love when we get together right after we work out and our muscles are all pumped and firm. We both trim our body hair and shave our cocks and balls and we've been having a lot of hot fun with mutual J.O., oral and hot body contact.
I've know for a while I was a bottom at heart, but have not been ready to try it until recently.
The first time we tried to do it, I was too tight and he barely got inside me before the pain was too much to handle. He's very thick and at least 8 inches long, which seemed like a lot for a first-timer, but we gave it a good try anyway. He was very patient and we both knew I was new at this, so it actually did not feel like sex as much as two guys working on a household project. ("ok, give me your cock, now put it there, ok, a little to the right, etc...) lol. We tried a couple times that day, but it was just not happening.
So last week we had a plan to meet again and I was determined that this was going to be "the day". He was getting home from work at the same time I arrived so he greeted me on the porch still in his suit. As soon as we were in the door we started making out and hands were everywhere. We are grinding up against each other and both of our cocks are getting hard already. We undressed each other barely stopping the kissing and groping until we are both just in underwear. We tumble on the bed and roll in each others arms. I love feeling our muscular bodies against each other. He starts nibbling on my nipple and I'm pulling on his nipples which we both love.
After that it's a blur for a while. Underwear is ripped off, nipples are being sucked, tongues and hands everywhere. I face fuck him while he is on his back. I run my tongue the length of his body down to his cock and go to town on him. I'm new at cock sucking but getting better every time. I love the feeling of his huge cock in my mouth and sometimes I think I could go on all day like that. Not today though. There is more to be done.
I want him to fuck me. He's on his back and I sit on him with his hard cock flat against his stomach and my ass cheeks on it. "I'm ready if you are" I announce and he grabs a condom, puts it on and lubes up his cock while I load lube into my ass. I try to mount him there but we still can not get him inside me. That giant cock of his seems like it's even bigger now and I wonder if I'll ever get it inside me.
He flips me over on my back, puts a pillow under my ass and lifts my legs up so they are against his shoulders and my ass is in the air. "Just relax" he tells me "this position is your most relaxed." I reach down and spread my ass cheeks with my hands and he starts to penetrate. I can feel the head working its way in. It hurts, but we are not taking "no" for an answer. The heads slides in eventually and the rest follows slowly. He tells me he is all the way in and I am shocked that it was so easy once the head got in and it no longer hurts. He makes sure I am ok and we sit there for a moment, knowing I am no longer a virgin.
The intense pleasure is like nothing I have ever experienced before. He starts to move slowly in and out and I start ordering him to fuck me. He slides in and out a few more times slowly to make sure and I am not in too much pain and then starts pounding my ass.
I'm screaming with joy and he's going at me like I only could have dreamed. I'm watching his hot body pound me and I can not believe I've waited so long to experience this amazing pleasure.
When it is done we rest there a while with his cock still in my ass and just enjoy the moment. We head to the shower and jerk each other off in the shower. We give each other a long kiss and then say good bye and like two buddies who had been just watching a game or hanging out at the bar.
I know millions of guys have been fucked this way before me and to many of you this was probably not much of a story, but for me it's an experience I'll never forget. I'm a cock sucker and a bottom and content to be so.