Three Is Never a Crowd

By Ray Cleist

Published on May 31, 2014

Encounters

THREE IS NEVER A CROWD – COSTUME PARTY

My name is Ray. I am a (relatively) happily married male in Central Illinois. I just turned 60, but anyone will tell you I easily pass for mid 40's. When I say relatively, I mean that I have a good marriage. I also acknowledge that I have an attraction for women, especially those with great bodies that dress to flaunt it. Furthermore on that "relatively" comment; even though my marriage is good and I find women attractive, my real attraction is to the bodily part that women do not possess. Plain and simple, I like cock especially, the hard version. Over the past 20 years I have sucked a number of those phallic symbols of malehood and have had mine sucked on numerous occasions. I have also had a handful (no pun intended) of male on male one night stands. Even though my ass has been frequented by my anal plugs and dildos, my ass is still virgin to a real cock; something I really want to change. Although the following story is fictional, I have incorporated some of my past real life "experiences" into it. This is the tenth part of my THREE IS NEVER A CROWD story.

I hadn't heard from my friends Tom and Bob for a while so I assumed they were back together as a couple. Then all of a sudden I get an email inviting me to a Halloween Costume party. As I read through the invitation I began to realize the invitation was to a Gay Halloween Costume party in the town that Tom and Bob live in. Only at the end of the invite did it state that it was in fact at their house. The invitation stated that the invite list was limited to 10. The sexual tone of just the invitation had me rock hard as I read it. If you RSVP'ed the invite you had to state that you would not reveal what your costume was and you body had to be costumed completely with the exception of your mouth & eyes and if you chose, your cock and asshole. I was so hot I RSVP'ed without a second thought.

I immediately informed my wife that I had an out of town business trip that day/night. Since the party was only 2 weeks away, I began to think about a good and hopefully very sexy/seductive costume. I began googling "gay costumes" and discovered that there were a number of superhero type costumes available that covered every inch of the body. I saw a Spiderman outfit that even had easily accessible Velcro openings for the cock and asshole. When I discovered that I could get this locally, I made my plans to get it the next day at a nearby gay bookstore/novelty shop.

When I got to the store they had a large variety of sexy outfits. A French Maid outfit looked very hot, but it definitely did not cover the entire body. I figured since I was there, I would go back in the video booth section and see if there were any other horny guys looking to get off. After about 4 booths of nothing, a cock soon appeared in the gloryhole of the next booth. Nothing special in size, but nicely shaped so I got down and gave it a lick. Hearing a moan on the other side, he must have liked my initial touch. A few more teasing licks and I soon had his knob in my mouth. His groaning grew as did the size of his cock. Soon he was fucking my mouth in earnest. Time to unzip my pants and give my own cock some relief. He then announced those most sexual words "I'm cumming" as he shot down my throat as I deep throated him. He must have been a young stud because he kept cumming. I gagged slightly and his cum was soon running out of my lips. Not being one to let tasty cum go to waste, licked it off my lips and then the last drops off his knob. One last yank and my cock shot its load all over the floor. I heard him zip up his pants, but he whispered "that was great". I smiled and said "thanks, maybe we can try this again sometime, but you would have to fuck me then". He responded "that sounds yummy".

I zipped up, grabbed the costume and was ready to pay when a 20ish stud winked at me and walked out the door with a great ass bouncing along. The cashier knowingly smiled at me, gave me my change and put my costume in a bag. Geez, if the costume party is half as sexy as getting the costume, I will be in store for a lot of fun.

Finally the day of the part arrived. I packed for my "business trip", with the costume being the only thing in the suitcase other than some lube and rubbers. I took an extra long shower and neatly shaved everything, especially around my asshole.

When I got within a mile of Bob and Tom's, I found a gas station with a restroom on the side. I changed from my work clothes into my costume. The material felt so good, tight and sexy, especially with no underwear. As I drove that last mile my cock felt like it was going to burst right through the thin tight fabric.

I parked a few blocks away since no one was supposed to know who anyone was. I got some mean looks as I walked down the street in my spiderman costume and with a very visible hardon. I saw one woman grab her husband and pull him towards their house. Hmmh, maybe he liked what he saw and she didn't want any competition for his attention.

I knocked on the door of Bob and Tom's house and was greeted by a very well build superman. Not a word was spoken (to reveal sources), but I was waved in and pointed to a bar. I poured myself a seven and seven and walked down the stairs to Bob and Tom's play(sex)room. What a sight to behold, 6 or 7 hot men, all in varying but very sexy costumes. It was obvious that there were 3 couples in various forms of affection or maybe foreplay was a better word. One couple was just sitting very close together, the second kissing and the third fondling each others bodies. The large tv was showing a very hot gay orgy movie, perhaps setting the theme for what was to cum (I mean come) in this room.

All of a sudden someone had come up behind me and put their arms around me and I felt a nice cock up against my asshole. Naturally I leaned back. Soon he, whoever he was, was massaging my nipples. They were soon as hard as my cock. He then started grinding his cock into my ass. Damn, I wished there wasn't the fabric of our costumes between his cock and my eager asshole. As my stranger's seduction of me continued, one of the other couples was fucking on a chair and another guy was getting a blowjob. The sexual energy in the room was accelerating.

I reached behind me and grabbed my friends cock. As soon as I found a zipper I lowered it and soon had a hard fully exposed cock in my hand. I quickly turned around and dropped to my knees in one motion. Only then did I realize that I had superman's cock in front of me. I began to lick my superhero's throbbing cock. Apparently I wasn't moving fast enough for this horny hunk because he put both hands on my head and forced his cock down my throat. I gagged for a second, but my throat quickly adopted to being fucked. What an erotic sound filling the room, my slurping blending in with other couples fucking and sucking.

Superman pulled me off his cock, made me stand up and grabbed my hand. He led me back up the stairs and we were soon alone and in seconds on a bed. We fell into an embrace and began passionately kissing. I wanted his cock and soon found it and began to fondle it again. He moved and soon his cock was back where it belonged, in my mouth. I assumed we were about to engage in a loving 69 position worshipping each other's cock's. However, apparently had no interest in my cock and was instead found my asshole through the costume. I heard him giggle as he found the velcro opening that made for easy access to my bunghole. I heard that velcro open and soon felt bare fingers on my now vulberable hole. I heard him lick his fingers and soon that saliva was serving as a temporary lubricant so that his fingers could enter my asshole. I continued to focus my attention on pleasing his cock with my mouth while he was seemingly getting my asshole ready to take that cock.

The room smelled of sex and the sounds of us groaning. By this time he had 3 or 4 fingers stretching my asshole open for his planned invasion. In keeping with the anonymous theme of the evening, no words were spoken between us and it was hot not knowing who I was having sex with. He have been ready for a change of position because he got up and pushed me face down on the bed. I heard him reach for something whish was soon apparent to me that was a rubber. I heard that snap on and then I heard grab something else. In a second I felt his hand rubbing that familiar lube all over and then into my asshole. I then heard him seemingly outing it all over his cock. He then reached under man and pulled me up to the infamous doggie position. He was good, he then teased me for what seemed like forever, by rubbing the knob of his cock against the outside of my asshole. I couldn't take it and reached behind me and grabbed his cock and guided it to my opening. I slowly pushed him in. His know soon got through my splincter muscle and he was entering my love canal. Whoever he was, he was a gentle lover. Slowly he entered me unto I could feel his balls up against my asshole. My anonymous lover was completely in me. After a few seconds of letting my asshole muscles get used to his cock he slowly began that wonderful in and out motion. Finally he was fucking me and it didn't take long for the pace to quicken. He was a perfect fit, not too small or to big. What a loving fuck it was. He knew just what to do as he reached under and started to jerk my cock off. I didn't last a minute and started shooting on the bed sheets. The contracting of my asshole muscled sent him over the edge as he fucked me hard. He continued to fuck me even as his cock finally began to shrink.

He rolled off me and we fell into a loving embrace and kissed for what seemed to be hours, but was probably no more than 10 minutes. I heard him get up, get dressed and leave. I did the same a few minutes later, but savored what was probably the most erotic sex I had ever had. As I wondered back down to the playroom I passed another bedroom where another couple was fucking like I had been just minutes before. When I got back to the playroom, there were only 3 guys there. The others must have been engaging in sex privately throughout the house. However, I was a little surprised to see "my" superman between the legs of the green lantern sucking away at his cock. Being a little jealous, I went right over to batman who was by himself watching the gay flick on tv. Without any invitation I got on my hands and knees between his legs and started to rub his cock. He was very soft, probably had just finished cumming with some other partier, but I did not give up. I leaned up and kissed him passionately on the lips while massaging his cock. Success, his cock sprung to life. Back down on my knees, I soon found and unzipped the opening to get to his cock. A few licks of his cock and balls and he was ready. Soon I was deep throating my second cock of the night. This time, I took my time, slowly sucking off my second superhero of the night. I began to intensify my sucking and I was rewarded with a tasty mouthful of man spunk. I swallowed every drop and licked him dry.

I got up and went to have another drink when I noticed it was 2 AM and a couple partiers were leaving. I couldn't believe I had had sex for the better part of 6 hours straight, but it was time to go. I don't know if any of you have ever had anonymous sex, but I the thought of not knowing the 2 men I had sex with was very hot. Can't wait for next Halloween!

To be continued... :)

If you like this story let me know at RayInIl@yahoo.com


Rate this story

Liked this story?

Nifty is entirely volunteer-run and relies on people like you to keep the site running. Please support the Nifty Archive and keep this content available to all!

Donate to The Nifty Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2024 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

The Archive

About NiftyLinks❤️Donate