The Surprise Threesome
I love hearing from readers and appreciate any comments or critiques. Send an email to ethansummers800@gmail.com Find more of my work at https://summersdreams.substack.com/ Follow me at twitter.com/EthanSummer99
I had just ended a year long relationship and to be totally honest, I was back on my Grindr bullshit. I'd had a few unremarkable hookups in my neighborhood but nothing to write home (or all of you) about. That changed last weekend. I was working from home, killing time scrolling the grid when i noticed an old hookup buddy. We had hung out a few times, grabbed drinks and made out a bit, but it had never progressed to anything more than that. We'd lost touch during the year or so that I'd been in a relationship but I thought it might be fun to reconnect.
I tapped out a message and after a little bit of banter we decided to meet up after work for a drink. His name is Barry, we're roughly the same age (29) and live in the same part of Brooklyn. He's skinny and twinky with a penchant for dying his hair unconvetional colours (pink at the moment) but he's cute and funny. We grabbed a drink at a local outdoor spot and worked our way through the perfunctory catch up talk. After a few drinks I was fairly certain this was going to be another low key outting until he asked if i wanted to head back to his place.
Of course I said yes and off we went. His hous is just down the block from the bar so it was a quick trip. Pretty soon we were on his couch making it and it felt like this time we were going all the way. That's when i heard the door open. I vaguely recalled that he had a partner, a husband actually, they were open but we'd always met up when he was out of town. I stopped what i was doing and glanced at the living room door a little unsure what the reaction would be but Barry indicated it was fine and walked me into the bedroom.
Pretty soon I'd forgotten all about the mysterious husband, wherever he might be. Instead of was on my back in their bed with Barry's tight pink hole in my face. I love eating ass and I'd always wanted to taste his so i was not complaining when he i felt his mouth slide over my hard cock, sucking me off while I tongued his hole.
That's when I felt something else. With Barry's mouth still wrapped around my cock I felt hands on my ankles gently spreading my legs. It took me a moment to realize that those angles didn't add and that someone else had entered the room. I made a quizzical noise but Barry just leaned back and whispered "Just go with it" before slamming his hole back onto my face.
I don't know if it was the cocktails, or that addictive ass of his, but go with it I did. Pretty soon i feel someone a finger running up and down my crack before slowly fingering my hole. I basically never bottom but I don't mind having it played with a little bit and i was so focused on what i was doing i must have just moaned. Apparently he took that as approval because a second later i felt a second finger pushing against my tight ring. Barry leaned in stroking my achingly hard cock while keeping his ass smashed against my face.
A moment later I felt something cold and realized that the second person was spreading lube onto my hole. I didn't even have time to react before i felt something bigger than a finger pushing up against and then slowly inside me.
It was like nothing I've ever felt before. I've only bottomed a few times but this was different. Not hugely thick but long, pressing inside of me making me squirm. I tried to object but it just came out as another moan straight into Barry's firm cheeks. Soon he picked up the pace, stroke after stroke until i was being railed within an inch of my life. That was when Barry rolled off of me and repositioned himself, mouth on my cock giving me my first look at his husband. He was lean and blonde with piercing blue eyes. He didnt' look angry exactly, just seriously intense. Staring directly into my eyes as he pounded my formerly tight but rapidly submitting hole.
Soon he picked up the pace, i could feel him heading toward climax. That's when he spoke for the first time, saying matter of factly "In, or out?"
I've never let anyone cum in me and I didn't plan to start but all I could do was whimper "In"
He didn't waste any time. Three more strokes and I felt his hot load filing my ass. Without another word he just walked out of the room. A second later I heard the shower turn on as I filled Barry's mouth with my own cum.
It took me a moment to pull myself together during which Barry wrapped himself around me, kissing me with the taste of my load still on his tongue. Dazed for a moment I accepted the kiss before pulling away to ask breathlessly "What...the fuck?"
"It's kind of our thing" he explained while fondling my now deflating dick.
"We're open and he doesn't mind me playing with other guys but he loves to see if he can dominate the guys I bring home. He likes to prove he's the alpha" Barry said smiling as if this was totally normal.
"I've never really been dommed" I replied, trying to hold on to a little of my remaining top dignity. "Not sure that's really my thing."
"Why don't you go in the bathroom and find out" he said, still smiling a little too knowingly.
Curiosity got the better of me and I walked slowly into the hall, still naked and after pausing for a second outside the door. Stepped inside. The water was still running and the shower was steamy. He didn't say a word just glanced down to indicate that I should step in. I figured i needed to get cleaned off any way so I may as well go with it.
Stepping into the shower i felt his hand on my shoulder, pressing firmly downward. Taking the queue I dropped to my knees on the wet shower floor, water streaming down my face. It was then I noticed that he was already hard again. Shifting his hand to the back of my head he pushed my mouth onto his cock, first slowly then more rapidly until he was pistoning into my face just like he had my ass a few moments before. A few minutes later he abruptly pulls out of my mouth, rapidly stroking his cock before splashing another load of cum all over my shower soaked face.
He then stepped out of the shower grabbing a towel, leaving me to wash up. As he reached the door he glanced back at me saying "Stay over." not a request or an invitation, a command.
When i finished showering and returned to the bedroom he was gone. Possibly to his office where i had clocked there was a second bed. I climbed into bed with Barry and we cuddled a bit before passing out.
The following morning I woke up early. I hadn't meant to sleep out nor to have such a wild night so i wanted to get home and get myself together. I quietly gathered my clothes and slipped out of the bedroom heading toward the door. On the way I passed the kitchen and there he was, casually sipping some coffee. I awkwardly muttered something about "thanks for the fun night" still making my way to the door. His only reply "Come over here."
Hesitantly i stepped into the kitchen. I could feel those yes sizing me up again in the daylight. He must have ultimately approve because he pulled me toward him and turned me around, sliding his hand into the waistband of my shorts and forcing them to the ground. I felt one hand wrap around my half hard dick as the other found it's way once again to my hole proceeding to both jerk me off and finger bang me so expertly that when he leaned in five minutes later and whispered into my ear "Cum" that's exaclty what i did shooting a load onto the tiled floor. Without even being asked i grabbed a paper towel and wiped up the mess before finally being allowed to go.
I've been thinking about the whole experience for three days since. This morning i finally texted Barry and asked if he'd be down to hang out again. His reply came quickly. He'd be glad to play again, but I have to text his husband and ask for permission. He sent me a number, I opened up imessage, but I'm still not sure if i'm ready to submit.
I love hearing from readers and appreciate any comments or critiques. Send an email to ethansummers800@gmail.com Find more of my work at https://summersdreams.substack.com/ Follow me at twitter.com/EthanSummer99