The Society Boys By Connor Matthews
Chapter 29 - Switching it Up
Alex had been acting weird all day, and considering it was a Friday, I hoped it wasn't going to affect our weekend. I mean he'd been acting strange ever since the incident at the `Q' house a month ago. Our relationship has been strained and sex had almost been non-existent. I got home and both Jason and Alex were in the kitchen having a drink. They offered me one, which I accepted hoping that things would start to get back to normal. At least Jason seemed happier now that the cock cage had been removed. The first night it came off I am sure he had sex with everyone he came near. Just not me.
"Justin, can I talk to you in the living room for a minute." Alex said. We moved to the other room with Alex and me on the couch and Jason on the chair. I hoped that he was finally going to tell me how he felt about what happened and maybe tell me he had gotten over it.
"Justin, you're my best friend and an amazing boyfriend. I hope that we will have many more crazy adventures together and that we can be there for each other for the rest of our lives."
"Me too" I said smiling. I noticed he glanced over at Jason a couple of times, and I wondered if maybe it was awkward having him there.
"I don't know how to say this, except to just say it. I love you and always will." He said and I took a deep breath. "I never thought that I could love anyone more than you, but lately I've fallen in love with someone else as well." I stared at him, wondering where this was going.
"Something tells me that you've started having feeling for someone too." He continued. My emotions got the best of me, and tears started streaming down my face. Alex moved closer to me and put his arm around my shoulder. I wiped my tears on my sleeve.
"We've been friends for almost 7 years and there is no way that it should ever end, but I think we both need to explore these other people and give ourselves a true chance to be happy."
"You're breaking up with me, aren't you?" I said looking directly into his eyes, waiting for the bomb to drop.
"Yeah, I think it's for the best. I love you and always will, but as much as I hate to say it, I'm not in love with you anymore. As tough as that was to say, the next thing may be even tougher to tell you." I braced myself for whatever could be worse. I hoped he wasn't going to end our friendship too. "I want you to be okay with the person I've fallen in love with, so that we can all still hang out as a group and do the things we used to do."
I said as I moved away from him a little bit to give us more space. "It's Jason, isn't it?" He nodded and Jason looked as if he'd rather be anywhere than in the room with us.
"Justin, look at me." He said as he looked at me. "I knew I loved him from the first time you and he switched places." I felt like an idiot. He knew I'd been lying to him the whole time.
"Sweetie, I know I can't tell you apart to look at you, but do really think that I wouldn't be able to tell the difference in bed. You two are very different in that respect. Not better or worse than each other, just different. I knew every time you switched, although I must say that when it went on for a whole month, I wondered if you were ever coming back."
"I am so sorry; I don't even know how to apologize for doing that. I guess I deserve what's coming. I never ever ever wanted to hurt you. I guess I was having feeling for Colin and just needed to know if it was real. I didn't want to lose what we had over an infatuation, if that's what it was, but then I fell in love with him." I tried to move away from Alex, but he held my hand to keep me close. "I am sorry, Alex. I'm so stupid for trying to trick you.
"Justin. It's alright, it really is. You tricked me and I guess I could be pissed at you for that, but by doing it, you sent your brother to replace you. Well, ironically, he has replaced you. I'm totally in love with Jason. While you've been off with Colin, Jason and I spent a lot of time together becoming good friends and, as much as it may be hard to hear, great lovers too. Each time you switched, we couldn't wait for the next time. We've even been hanging out and going places. He's been to every one of my swim meets in the past six months, and things like that.
I looked at Jason and he gave me a weak smile. Alex really did deserve better than me and Jason was a great guy. It was like he was swapping the inside and keeping the outside of me. It was a bit funny, if you look at it from an outsider's point of view.
"Strange as it is, we have a lot in common and we've had a chance to really talk. I found out he's been in love with me since he was 12, but he would never have done anything about it, as long as you and I were together. Justin, I love you. I will always love you, and I hope our adventures will continue as they always have. Even the sex we had with our friends at parties and when they came over, I wouldn't want that to stop. I just want to be a bit more monogamous, and not do every guy that blows in like tumbleweeds. That's maybe where we are really the most different. You're the happiest when you conquer another guy that you've never had before and can add a notch to you belt. There's nothing wrong with that, but I need something different. I'm not saying that Jason and I will stop fooling around with our friends, but we would do it together, and only together. You love going around the room and making sure you've tapped every guy at least once. Are you okay with me being with your brother?"
My mind was working overtime. He was right of course, and I shouldn't be upset. I had a feeling that if he hadn't broken up with me. I looked at Alex and I thought of all the great times we have had over the past 7 years, the amazing sex, and the wild things that we had gone through, including all the trips to the hospital, not to mention the initiation into the `Q'.
"I'm thrilled that you and Jason are in love. I realize that he doesn't have my good looks, but you can probably get past that soon enough." I said trying to be more cheerful.
"Or your devious nature" said Jason, speaking up for the first time. Ouch!
"Touché" I said quietly. "Strange night though. I worried about losing you completely as a result of what happened at the punishment thing, but it looks like we both knew we were drifting apart anyway. I'm just glad that we can still be friends."
Jason said as he came over and gave me a hug and a kiss. Then Alex and I kissed, and then the three of us kissed together. I cheered up a lot. We all still had someone and could still be friends and friends with benefits too!
I guess I'll move out tonight if you want. I can just go back home." I offered.
"Really Justin, you're such a drama queen. Let's all stay here and spend the night together as we've done before. Just this time as friends, not boyfriends.
I debated it for a while and thought it might be the best way to heal any feelings we had from the past few weeks. We started in the hot tub and had a few drinks before we went up to bed together. It felt different this time though. I was the third wheel in the threesome.
In the morning, I called Colin and asked if I could go over. As usual, he couldn't wait for me to arrive. I got up to his door and he flung the door open to greet me. Perhaps he thought this was a booty call, so who was I to turn him down. We flung our clothes off and made out on the couch for a while. I stopped him before he decided to fuck me and asked if we could talk. He looked a bit surprised considering I'd stopped in the middle and we were both sporting raging boners.
"Sorry, but I just wanted to tell you this first, then we can get back to it." I said bluntly. He sat sideways on the couch, cross legged, and listened. It was very difficult to concentrate with his penis staring at me pissed at being stopped in the middle of things. "Alex broke up with me last night."
His reaction was like he was strapped to a lie detector. He said he was sorry and his face showed genuine concern, but his penis pulsed, throbbed and twitched like it had won the lottery. "I'm sorry babe. Are you alright?"
"Yeah, I am actually. He's already fallen in love with someone else." I said.
"Wow, no shit, eh? Who is it?" He asked a bit surprised.
"Jason!" I grinned.
"Really? Jason?" He laughed. "Sorry buddy but that's hilarious. That's like trading in a new Black Cadillac for another new Black Cadillac."
"Apparently he doesn't want his new Cadillac to park in as many unknown garages as his old Cadillac." I giggled.
"Well, I'm sorry that he dumped you, but I guess that means that you and I can spend more time together now, if you want to." He grinned.
"Yeah, I really would like that. First I gotta move out though. I promised I'd get my stuff back to my parent's house this weekend. You wanna help me if you have some time?" I asked.
"No. I don't think that would be a good idea." He said as he looked at me flipping his hair slightly.
"Oh, okay." I said a little disappointed. Maybe it was just about sex between us after all.
"He laughed. No, that's not what I meant babe. I don't think it would be a good idea for you to move back to your parent's house. Move in here with me. Be MY boyfriend."
My heart raced and my cock went back to being fully hard, giving me away. "Really?" I asked as my voice cracked like a schoolgirl with a crush.
"Really. I love you Justin, and I love the fact that you park you Cadillac in lots of Garages. I hope that we fool around with tons of guys, but I love you and want to be with you. Sex is just sex, but what we have been sharing has been pretty special to me."
He got down on the floor on one knee and looked up at me as he took my hand. Justin Masters will you be my boyfriend, and make love to me for the rest of our lives?"
I looked at him, naked on his knees with a hardon asking me to be his boyfriend. This must be one of the weirdest proposals ever. So my answer needed to match.
"Colin Worthington, the first" I giggled as I added a designation "I, Justin Masters, will be your boyfriend for harder or softer, in anal or oral, for richer or poorer, till lack of sex do us part. I DO!" I giggled. We kissed and went to the bedroom to consummate the boyfriendship.
I consummated him and he consummated me, then we napped and consummated each other again. I don't think I've ever said consummated so many times in my entire life.
We drove back to the house to get my stuff, and found Alex and Jason, along with Randy and Brandon in the hot tub. We joined them.
"So should we tell them?" Asked Colin. I nodded and we made our big announcement.
Everyone was happy for us, and Alex looked relieved as well. Guess we had both found someone, so it all worked out. I still had my best friend. Jason had the person he'd been in love with since we were kids, Alex had both of us in the right roles, and Colin and I had each other. If I hadn't been so spent from the, what's the word?, consummations!, I figure we would have all headed down stairs for a wild fuck session. Colin and I grabbed my stuff, and since I really didn't have any furniture, it didn't take long to throw it in his car. I was surprised at how little I actually owned, and even at Colin's place I wouldn't need stuff. We said goodbye to the guys, and headed to the penthouse to start our lives together. What a strange feeling. But nowhere near as strange as Monday, which was more than a bit surreal.
I drove to school, and watched Alex and Jason pulled up in the Lamborghini, get out and walk into school together holding hands. To everyone else, they wouldn't know anything had changed, to me it felt like Jason and I had switched places again, only this time it wasn't a game. It was permanent and real. I sat there for a second, wondering if I had made the right decision, but only for a second. I got out and headed for the doors. I had a few people say hi to me, although, more correctly, they said hi Jason', since they had already seen Justin' with Alex. I went to my locker and they were both there.
"Morning guys." I said "How was your first official weekend together?"
"Great and yours?" They asked.
"Awesome. Felt weird being with Colin as myself and not as Jason." I laughed. They both grinned. We talked for a bit and it felt as if nothing was different, except that Alex was holding hands with Jason instead of me. Kyle came down the hall on his way to class.
"Hi guys." He said to us, then looking at Jason he said. "Justin, can I come talk to you after school?"
Jason pointed at me and smiled. "Wrong twin." Kyle looked at the two of them holding hands and then at me. I think he was just trying to figure out if we were messing with him.
"I'm no longer with Alex. Jason is his boyfriend now." I explained.
"That's a serious brain blower, dude" he said. "So anyway, whichever one of you is Justin; can I talk to you after school?"
"Yeah, of course. Meet me in the parking lot and we can talk in the car."
"Can we go back to your place?" he asked.
"I don't live there anymore. I moved in with Colin and he's downtown." I explained. "You're still welcome to come over, but it's like a 45 minute drive each way."
"I don't gotta be home till later, so no prob. As long as it's okay with you and Colin."
"Shouldn't be a problem. I'll let you know after school." He headed off to class and I said goodbye to the guys. I felt like a little like I was still Jason as I watched them walk away hand in hand. Maybe that would work to my advantage.
Next chapter soon as Justin settles into his new life. Comments welcome and lots more to come. Feel free to jump ahead on my website at www.pridecanadabc.com and click on the stories link. Email me at outinwest@gmail.com