The Society Boys By Connor Matthews
Chapter 21 -- The Exchange
The next week began with flowers being delivered to my classroom. There was a knock on the door and when the teacher answered it, a delivery guy was standing there. The teacher called me forward, I was handed a big bunch of flowers. I felt like I'd just won a contest or something. Unfortunately they were delivered to the class I share with Alex. Walking back to my seat holding this big ass bunch of flowers, I was blushing brighter red than the roses that were in it. I looked at Alex, and he just shrugged.
There was no card with it, but I was pretty sure Colin was still continuing his crazy antics, although I had absolutely no idea why yet. Maybe he just had fun being unpredictable. So I had an extreme boyfriend and a crazy friend. I needed one that could just sit and watch a movie with me once in a while.
The next day, I got to my locker to find dozens of helium balloons tied to it. Just getting past them to open my locker was a challenge. They were all different with cute little sayings, most of them pretty funny. Alex asked me who they were from, and I told them I didn't know. Fortunately there was no note that that they were for me, so I said perhaps they were for him this time.
Day three and more world of crazy. Alex and I had just arrived at school and had just locked the car, when we heard, and then saw, a helicopter land in the parking lot across the street. A guy dressed in a black suit and white shirt, with black sunglasses got out. He looked like he was an international spy. I looked closely for an ear piece, and if he talked into his sleeve I was running. He came over to me and handed me and envelope before turning and heading back to the chopper and taking off.
"So, what's in the envelope?" asked Alex curiously. I opened it and there were tickets to a Justin Bieber concert in it. I burst out laughing.
"Well, there goes our cool points!" I said as I showed them to Alex. He grinned.
"I guess if we ever needed a favor from a girl, we'd have the perfect bribe, especially considering that they are VIP passes, too." said Alex, laughing. I looked carefully, and they were not only for the concert, but an event with Justin afterwards. Now, while I don't like Justin's music, except maybe the "somebody to love' long, I think he's really cute, especially since getting rid of that stupid haircut he had, bit there was no way I was going to jeopardize my reputation by going to his concert.
"Maybe that's Colin's idea of a joke. He gives us the car to use, then tries to embarrass us." Well, I know the perfect girls to give them to." I said.
"Who?" he asked.
"Kyle's sister. She did a nice thing for her little brother and I think we could reward her for helping him. Not too many sisters would do that." Alex agreed, so we would find her later nada give her the tickets.
I called Colin as Alex walked ahead of me into school. "Hey, crazy boy!" I said when he answered. "Really? Tickets to Justin Bieber?"
"What are you talking about?" he said, obviously grinning at the other end of the phone.
"Oh please, you're the only guy I know that would have VIP tickets delivered by helicopter."
"If you say so. I gotta run dude. Have fun at School. I'll drop over later this week, maybe we can go hang out.
On day four of the week, both Alex and I hoped that nothing weird would happen to draw attention to us again. No such luck. The next day, a herd of drag queens, (is it a herd or a pride...when more than one drag queen is grouped together? Hmmm), anyway, they appeared after school, as we were going toward our car. They looked like they had been caught in a fruit and feather factory explosion, and came across the parking lot in a wave of color. The high heels they had on, made them look 7 feet tall, and the hats (?) added another foot and a half. They came up, gave us hugs and kisses and gave me a four foot teddy bear. I had trouble stuffing the stupid thing in the car with us.
On Friday morning, I almost wanted to stay in bed to avoid any other embarrassment, but at the same time I was curious as to what he could possibly come up with today. Alex and I went to school together, and once again did our best to be cool as we walked into school hand in hand. With all the things that were happening, we were rapidly becoming well known. People were either looking at us, talking to us or about us. I just wanted to go to class and be invisible.
My phone rang just before the first bell. The caller ID said it was Colin, so my heart skipped a beat and I answered it. "hey buddy, what's up?"
"Just calling to find out if you're free tonight."
"Sure I can probably get away for a few hours" I said quickly.
"I was thinking more like you come over around seven, I'll take you out to the theater, and then maybe you spend the night." The thought excited me, but I wondered how I would explain that to Alex. I can just see it now, `Oh, Alex I can't spend the night here, I'm going to have wild passionate sex with Colin. Hope you don't mind spending the night by yourself.'
"I'm not sure I'd be able to explain that to the boyfriend" I said reluctantly.
"Well, see what you can do. The theater doesn't get out until 11, then there's a reception afterwards. Plus I'd really like to spend one night together alone." He said almost seductively. The thought of spending time just with Colin, sent blood rushing to my dick. I wanted to race over and have incredible sex with him all day and night, but school was first and I had to figure out an excuse not to spend the night at home tonight, without disappointing my boyfriend.
"Okay let me work on it. Can I call you after school, say around 4:00 PM?" I asked hopefully.
"Sure no problem. I promise if you can spend the night, I'll make it worth your time." He said trying to entice me even further. As if I needed any more convincing. I was ready to run over there now, rip all his clothes off, and jump all over him. I hung up, and tried to figure out what I was going to do. It was shortly after lunch that I came up with my master plan. I thought it was the best one I've ever had, I was just going to need some help to pull it off. After school, Alex and I headed home, and once there, I told him I needed to run over to see Jason for a bit. I took a quick shower, gave Alex a kiss, and said I'd be back shortly.
I drove to my parents' house and rushed up to my brothers room. "Jason, I need a big favor from you tonight, if you're free."
"Like what?" he asked spinning around to greet me.
"I need you to pretend to be me for the night, and stay at my house with Alex."
"Why? Where are you going to be?" he asked with a curious smile on his face.
"Colin ask me to go to a live theater show, and then spend the night at his place." I explained.
"Dude, are you sure that's a good idea?" he said looking a bit concerned. "What's with you and Colin anyway? Are you like, seeing him?"
"I just like hanging out with him, and I'm not sure Alex would understand if I spend the night, so would you mind pretending to be me for one night?"
"Does that mean I get to have sex with your boyfriend all night?" he said grinning, as he rubbed his hands together.
"While it's not like you haven't done it before. At least this time you have my full permission. Just don't be better at it than me, or he'll expect it all the time." I laughed, as I went over to give him a kiss.
"What time would you be back in the morning?"
"Let's say 9:00 AM. Just tell him that you have to grab something from the house, and we'll switch back. That way, even if he decides to come with you, we can change clothes quickly and act like nothing is different."
"Okay, when do you want to switch?"
"Now would be good, if you're free" I said with a grin.
"Damn dude, nothing like short notice. Sure, let me just grab some things, and I'll head to your place, I mean MY place. Guess I should take your car too huh?" he suggested wisely.
"We should also switch clothes too." I said, as I knew Alex was aware of how I was dressed. We changed everything including underwear, and even swapped licenses. I told him about the secret word and finger pinch that Alex and I had, just in case he needed it. So far we had been lucky and never used it, but I can just see him making a slip on something small, and creating suspicion.
"Have fun tonight" he said, as he gave me a hug "and good luck. "
"You too" I said. "Try not to wear out my boyfriend will ya. I need him able to walk tomorrow as we're going hiking after lunch."
"No promises, but I'm definitely going to use every bit of him. I love fucking that hot ass of his. I just hope he can last several hours. " He giggled.
"Thanks bro, I owe you big time."
"No shit. Don't worry I'll be collecting that debt for sure!" he said, as we headed downstairs together. He jumped into my car, and I went back in the house to call Colin. My night of deception had begun, and so had my erection.
Call suggested that since I was free, I should come over and we could have dinner first. He met me in the underground parking, and took me up to his penthouse suite. The place was huge, but nothing like his California mansion. I liked the fact that he had a large balcony that overlooked the city, and off his main room, he had a pool table.
"So how did you convince Alex to let you spend the night with me?" he asked curiously.
I looked at him with a mischievous look on my face and decided to tell him the truth, as I figured it might slip out otherwise. "Well, he kind of won't know I'm gone." I said looking a bit sheepish.
"Huh? How?" he asked, thinking that perhaps I wasn't going to spend the night after all.
"Well, he'll actually be having a wonderful night with his boyfriend, who is going to screw his brains out, almost as if it's their first night together." I grinned.
He looked at me and it took a second, but I saw the light bulb go on. "You didn't!" he exclaimed.
"Yes, `fraid so. Jason is now Justin for the night, and in case anyone asks...I'm Jason."
"Holy shit, a pinch hitter for a boyfriend. That has got to be an all-time first. What if you get caught?"
"Easy, we'll pretend we were just playing a game with him. Jason will text me if things go wrong, and we can recover from there.
"Fucking awesome, Jason!" he said, calling me by my nom de plume.
We had a good night at the theatre, although I was totally unprepared for how formal it was. Colin and I dressed up in tuxedos. It's a good thing he had several to choose from. Of course he had to help me with the bow tie, since I'd never worn one before. He took a few pictures of us all dressed up, and we actually looked pretty hot. The limo took us to the performing arts centre, and we had a glass of champagne on the way. I should have known that we wouldn't sit in the seats with regular people, although I would have enjoyed sitting anywhere, as long as it was with Colin. He had a box seat that made me feel like royalty. He introduced me to some of the other theatre goers, a few of whom, asked if we were boyfriends and said we made cute couple. I had no doubt who was the cutest. ME! As if, hehe. Colin was so hot, he made me look like something that had escaped from the morgue, after the autopsy. Okay, maybe not that bad, but I was beginning to get Kyle's blushing syndrome by the end of the night, with all the compliments. He did introduce me as Jason, in case we ran into anyone who might accidentally say something.
We had some hors d'oeuvres and champagne after the show, and the limo took us back to his penthouse.
"Thanks for the amazing night! I've never actually been to a live theater show before, and it was a lot of fun." I said giving him a big smile.
"I'm glad you liked it, but the night's not over yet" he grinned as he came up and kissed me on the lips. I kissed him back, as we pressed tight against each other, and began what I could only hope was a long night of passionate sex. We took off each other's jackets, then he untied my bow tie, before slowly unbuttoning my shirt. I felt his hands go inside the open shirt and down my chest, before wrapping around my back, and hugging me tight against again. I pulled his shirt out of his pants, and slid my hands up his back. We stayed like that for a while, as we stood kissing in his living room. There was no hurry tonight, and no one to interrupt. We inched our way towards the couch, and fell on it together. I moved my hands and untied his bow tie and undid his shirt, so we were now pressing our bare chests against each other.
I could feel he was just as excited as I was, but for the moment we were ignoring that part of our body, and concentrating on kissing. We moved over each other's lips necks and chests as we explored each other passionately. After what seemed like an eternity, he suggested we move to the bedroom, where we removed our pants, leaving us in our short boxer briefs. I felt his hands cup my cock and balls, as we lay on the bed together. I put my hands on his ass, and squeezed gently. He slowly kissed and licked down my chest to my stomach, tickling my belly button with his tongue, before putting his mouth over the top of my hard cock protected by the thin fabric of my shorts. He explored every inch of it, and my balls, and I could feel his warm breath. Colin's hands slid inside the leg of my shorts, and pushed up until he could feel my cock. He stroked it gently, causing an electric tingle to shoot through my body. He removed one hand and pulled the top of my shorts, freeing my cock. He licked the tip of it as he slowly removed my shorts, then explored every inch of my super hard pole with his tongue before finally engulfing it and slowly giving me a blowjob. Like everything with Colin, he was an expert. He stroked my balls gently as he sucked my dick. I knew that if I just lay there, I wouldn't last long, so I pulled him back up my body to kiss me again. I pushed my hand inside his shorts to lower them and free him. He kicked them off and we were now pressed tight against each other our cocks side by side. I rolled him over so that I could lie on top and do exactly what he had done to me. And licked down his body and groped his cock in readiness for my mouth. I licked his balls first as I slowly stroked his shaft. I could have laid there all night looking at the beautiful piece of meat in front of me, but I knew I wanted to take it into my mouth more. I swallowed his cock making sure I used lots of tongue as I went down as deep as I could. He pivoted around so that he could get to my cock at the same time, and we 69'd with me on top. Again we were not in a hurry, so took our time licking and sucking each other. I felt his hands move to my ass and stroke my cheeks as he swallowed my cock deep into his throat. Then his tongue licked down my shaft to my balls and then at the entrance to my hole. I lowered myself slightly so that he could get a better angle and rim me deeper. I pulled his legs back so that I could get to his ass as well. I wasn't sure if I want to get fucked first or fuck him first. Not that it mattered , as we would get to it all eventually . We enjoyed the taste and feel of each other's bodies for a while before turning around and kissing each other one more time . You roll me onto my back and got on top. He reached over to get the lube from his night table and pushed by the legs back to expose my hole . Guess I was first . I felt the cool liquid against my crack and watched as he lubed up his cock and aimed it towards me . He approached slowly and pressed his tip against my waiting entrance . He slowly applied pressure and I willingly accepted him into me . As each inch slid in deeper and deeper I could not imagine anything more perfect than this moment in time . Once he was fully inside me he leaned down to kiss me again and I put my hand on the back of his head to press us firmly together . He then began to fuck me . Or perhaps more correctly he began to make love to me. He moved slowly and gently and used the entire length of his cock to stimulate every part that he was touching . I could've stayed like that all night and would have been happy to fall asleep with him kissing and sucking me they use my other hand to stroke his back and rub his ass as he continued make love to me .
I stopped kissing him for just a second " go slow Colin , I don't want you to come anytime soon . They just want to enjoy the feeling of your cock inside me ." I whispered into his ear before I pressed my lips against his again and began to explore his mouth with my tongue once more. He didn't say anything and just slowly used his entire length back and forth for what seemed like an eternity . I didn't want him to come because I wanted to make love to him next dare it be plenty of time later for him to fuck be hard and let his jizz flown deep inside . I moved so that his cock slipped out of my ass and push him onto his back slow and I could get inside him. I put lube on my finger and pushed into him two prepare him for my big dick. I added a second finger and more lube as I explored inside his warm cavity making a point of flicking his prostate but couple of times just to get him more excited. He pushed his legs back towards his head, and gently entered past his tight ring inch into his waiting hole . Then I leaned down and kissed him as he had done to me . We continued to make love as I slowly moved in and out of his nice warm hole. It was at that moment, while I was deep inside him, kissing and stroking his soft hair, that I knew I was in love with Colin. I did plan for it to happen, but nothing had felt this right before, and ever part of my body was lost in the motion of what we were doing. We were not two guys having sex. We were one, connected through the most intimate action that we could share. I did not see me with Colin, I saw us as one entity that was never meant to be apart. There was truly no way to explain it properly. It was as if I was fused inside him and every part of me, was now touching every part of him. I pushed in one final time and released everything I had into my lover. I had shot lots of loads into guys, but for this one time, this one moment, I was giving him a part of myself that I wanted him to have forever. There was a sense that I was not only sharing my sperm with him, but part of my soul too. I had never felt like that before and as I shot wave after wave into him, I began to cry. My lips were becoming wet with tears and I knew that Colin must be able to taste the saltiness of them as we continued to kiss. He pulled my body tight against his using all his strength to hold my head and pull my back to his chest. I had finished emptying myself into his ass, but there was no reason to take my dick out. It belonged in there, it belonged it that moment, and I never wanted it to end. Colin did not appear to want to let me go either. I wondered if maybe he knew how I was feeling as he just kept holding me and kissing my salty lips.
He slowly lowered his legs and my softening dick slid out of his ass. He moved from under me and lay me on the bed as he climbed on top, spread my legs slightly and entered me again. He pushed inside quickly and buried himself deep. He lay down on me and began to nipple my ears, as he used his hands to hold mine and gripped me tight as he began to make love to me one more time. His pace quickened and his thrusts we powerful and deep and he moved towards him own climax.
"Cum inside me baby" I whispered in a hoarse tone. "Please share it with me." I begged him. He quickened his pace, and I felt his juice blast into me. We were one again as there was now part of each of us inside the other. I was sure no two human beings could feel what I was experiencing right now. I was absolutely and unconditionally in love with Colin, and felt a sense of euphoria, combined with a terrible sense of confusion and guilt, because of Alex. I love Alex, I really do, and all the times we had made love were special, but nothing hit me like this during our love making, not ever, not even close. This was a feeling that I didn't know existed. It was the purest understanding of the meaning of love, and I had no idea about what to do about it. Do I tell Colin? Do I tell Alex? Do I try to keep them both? I was so confused and overwhelmed, I felt like I was going to cry again.
As I came down from my high, we turned and lay together, kissing and cuddling with each other all night. I slept, curled in the arms of the man I now knew I was meant to be with, while my brother, pretending to be me, was curled up in the arms of my boyfriend. Every few hours, we seemed to be waking up to do something with the other one again. I felt him enter me and fuck me slowly, then go back to sleep. Then next time, I woke up and gave him a blow job. The we woke up together and kissed and hugged for half an hour before falling back to sleep again. Morning came way to early, so we had a shower together and made sure we washed each other from head to toe. Then kissed for a few more minutes, before I raced over to my parent's house to meet Jason. I was time to go back to being Justin again.
He arrived shortly before 9 and we changed clothes and ID again. "So how did your night go?" I asked him. "Anything I should know before I head home?"
"Nope. We went and played pool, and had a few drinks, before we spent the night having sex. He's pretty good at billiards, but don't worry, I protected your honor and kicked his ass."
"Seriously? You beat him at pool?" Well, there was the first problem. In all the times we'd played, I'd never even come close to beating him. I guess I could just blame it on the alcohol, or say he must have just been having a shitty night. I laughed and thanks Jason for being such a great brother to do this for me.
"No problem bro. Anytime you want to do that again, I'd be up for it. I really like Alex. Like I told you before, I have always wanted him, so this was kind of fun to pretend to be you. I didn't even get to learn any dirty little secrets about you guys. I even quizzed him about what he thought of `Jason'. Turns out he likes me too."
"You're so evil." I grinned realizing what a hypocrite I was.
"So, how did your date go with Colin? You look like you've been awake all night." he said smiling.
"We pretty much were" I said "But I think I have a problem."
"Crabs, huh?" Yep they can be a bitch!" he giggled.
"Not crabs asshole. I think I'm in love with him." I knew I was, but no point in stating it definitively, just yet.
"Really? Wow, that's huge dude. What are you going to do?" he asked looking a bit shocked as he realized what I was saying.
"I'm not doing anything yet. It was only one night. I'm hardly going to throw away my relationship with Alex for something uncertain. If I keep being drawn towards Colin, then I'll decide what to do when, and IF, the time comes. Maybe I could start my own Polygamy sect and have them both, then add Kyle, Aaron, Randy, Brandon and when he grows up, Cory." I laughed trying to ease the tension.
"And who do I get?" he said folding his arms across his chest, looking hurt.
"We'd share them all, together." I said grinning. "After all, only Colin can tell us apart."
I was trying to make a joke out of it, but I was seriously worried about my feelings for Colin. There was no doubt that I was in love with him, and wanted to be with him, but I also didn't want to let Alex go. I loved him too. Is that possible? Can you TRULY love two people at once? I'm going to have a breakdown. Life can be harsh sometimes.
I raced home to Alex and we grabbed the things we needed for our hike. Alex suggested we take a shower together, so I assume I mustn't have had one yet. Well, more correctly, Jason hadn't had one. We made out together in the water and its was still as exciting as ever to have him inside me, and kiss his soft lips. I'm keeping them both. Plain and simple. I just had to figure out a way to do it. We hiked up to the top of the canyon, and stopped for snacks and drinks frequently. We walked hand in hand a lot of the way, and came across quite a few other hikers. It was too cold out to be going naked, but warm enough that we didn't feel a chill at all. We even stood at the top of the canyon, looking over the valley, which never ceases to impress me, and I leaned against my boyfriend to hug him.
I wonder how Alex would take it, if I suggested a three-way boyfriend relationship. I could test the water carefully to find out.
This is always the tough part in a story, do we break them up, let them stay together, form a three way alliance, or is there another option. Stay tuned! Many more adventures on the way. I look forward to your comments.