We had heard about them from friends at other schools, but one weekend we went to a party at another school and we saw in person our first "Gay Off." As the name in implies it's a competition. It's like playing chicken, where you bet who can be more gay acting and one up the guy your betting. From what we understood it always starts with a kiss and usually ends with a french kiss crotch grab combo, when the party and the competitors usually declare a winner. In the midwest suburbs it was scarier to me than playing chicken in cars. The point was to "out gay" your opponent while somehow maintaining your hetero status.
At the time I was dating Heather. She has been known to french kiss girls when she gets drunk. But she always came back to me. We had just been exploring blow jobs and oral sex, and it was awesome, but I never got to fuck her. Lately she was threatening to bring her friend Katie in who owned a vibrator, I was excited but also scared Heather might use it on me and not Katie. Heather was originally from California and a little more sexually liberated when we first heard about the gay-offs she was like finally, a game the boys can play.
She and I with Mike and his girl Jen were at the party we first saw our first "Gay Off". We were on the swim team and we got invited to the party. John Hughes went to my school, he based those epic parties off of what happened in our area. What we saw at that party was way more than what we had heard about though. We saw these guys going at it. There weren't naked but they were shirtless and there were people cheering them on with money changing hands like a back alley cock fight.
It was out of control. I think it would have gotten more explicit except the cops busted the party. We filed out with everyone else.
As we drove home Mike finally brought up what we all had seen. I was driving and Heather had her feet across my lap. He started to recount what we had seen, and said he thought those guys had to be gay to do what we saw. I was added that I knew both of the guys had hot girlfriends, but who knows. Jen remarked that a lot of Gay porn guys were actually straight. Heather just said yummy. But then she pulled her foot across my lap and she saw how hard I was. She sat up and smiled at me. I must have been beet red. She slid over and put her hand on my cock and rubbed it softly.
A few minutes later Mike said what I had been thinking "What if we have to play it someday. I don't know how I'd do."
I countered "It's no big deal, just don't play" But I knew how the peer pressure game worked better than anything and we were the poor kids in a rich school. These kids would all go to Ivy Leagues and have a blast. We were all destined to State Universities because even with financial aid we couldn't afford Ivy Leagues even though we could get in. The scholarships were few and far between for a school our size. And that being said backing out of a challenge would be expensive. I got $10 bucks a lawn and most of these challenges started the ante at $100 so quick math is I better win the challenge, or I'd be doing lawns for years to come. Besides I was a little intrigued by the idea and I think Heather knew it.
"Yeah right. As if not playing was an option" said Mike.
Heather sighed "Oh come on you guys like it when girls kiss. What's the big deal?" She smiled at me and rubbed my boner. We were headed back to Heather's house since her folks are in Cancun.
No one said anything. Until we got to Heather's house.
"I can admit that that scene made me horny and now I need my man here," Heather continued, "Why don't you guys watch some TV."
We all agreed. But I was suspicious of my grinning girl.
We barely got in her room and she pulled down my pants. I tripped on them and she pounced like a cat.
"Give me your cock!" She pushed my underwear down and pulled out my cock. It had the most pre-cum I have ever seen on it. She rubbed it to get it even harder and she inhaled it. As she sucked me, I used my legs to get my pants off and she used her free hand to pull my underwear off, but then she did something with her had I wasn't expecting. She slid her hand up my leg and then placed it in my butt crack. It felt great. I opened my legs to spread my cheeks. Then she forced her finger into my ass hole. It felt amazing I came not long after that. She swallowed my load and we laid on the floor.
"That was intense!" I finally said.
I got up and went over to the bathroom. She came in and turned on the shower. We washed each other while making out and I used my expert fingers to get her off. As we toweled off I realized Mike and Jen could be doing what we were doing. I asked Heather what we should do.
She said we should "walk down and join them" and she smiled as she flashed me her pussy in her robe.
Heather put on a big t-shirt and took my boxers. I got dressed, going comando. We went down to the TV room. Heather's house was amazing but she wasn't about to mess it up with a party filled with a bunch of drunk people. In the TV room Jenn and Mike were kissing but they were both dressed. Mike flashed me the 3rd base hand signal. We sat down and they were watching "Caddyshack" but they had edited for TV.
Heather got up and picked up a pipe and frisbee with some weed on it. We each smoked a bit and laughed at how stupid the movie was on TV.
Jen asked to to use the bathroom. Heather offered to show her where it was and they left. While they were gone for a while Mike said "what a night!"
"No Kidding! Heather got so horny so fast before" I repsonded.
"Yeah Jen is a virgin and she let me finger fuck her." Mike said looking bewildered. "You think you could do it?"
"Sure she is hot and I got 10 fingers" I jokingly replied.
"Yeah right" He lamely came back "No I meant the gay-off. I can't afford to lose any more cash. I had to sell my moped, to cover that bet with Tommy"
"Oh yeah, I forgot about that"
"Why don't you two just practice" Heather said coming back with Jen. They were holding hands. Heather was holding a silk bag and smiling.
"What!?!?!" we both exclaimed and then laughed.
Heather looked at Jen and then said. "We'll do what ever you do."
There was dead silence. I swear I could hear Mike's heart beat.
"If you kiss Mike, I'll kiss Heather and so on" Jen said meekly.
"This is for your benefit. You guys need to know how far you can go. Otherwise you're going to lose when you have to play for real." Heather rationally explained.
"You OK with this Jen?" Mike asked. She nodded. I didn't have to ask. Heather loved kissing girls.
"OK!" Said Heather. "Lets begin."
I was stoned but I was also horny. So I moved over to Mike and I decided to try some mind fucking. "What ever we do you guys do the equivalent, right?"
"Exactly" Said Heather. She was beaming.
I pecked Mike on the lips and Heather did the same. We all giggled. Then I took off my shirt. And rubbed my breast. Mike smiled and he started to rub my breast too. Sure enough Heather removed the t-shirt she was wearing and started playing with her nice sized breast and Jen came up and did rubbed it too. I think my boner could have torn my jeans. Mike's jaw was slack. The girls just sat patiently for us to do something.
I leaned over and kissed Mike on the lips. He pushed me off of him laughing. But when we saw Heather kiss Jen, he kissed me.
Next, I pulled his shirt off. Heather took Jen's shirt off. But she was still wearing a bra.
"No fair Mike is topless!" Jen shrugged showing she didn't care. as she unhooked her bra, that although she didn't really need she had some amazing petite tits.
Mike hadn't seen them like that yet. And he took a minute to take in his girlfriends hot body. I took that opportunity to push him back and kiss his neck and unbutton his pants. I felt his hesitation but as Heather mimicked me and he saw his girlfriends hot pink panties he raised his hips to let me pull his pants off. His boner was plain as day but I left it alone, I didn't want to look to eager but I rubbed his chest to get Heather to do the same to Jen. Then we started to make out. I felt Mike's hand rub my back and slide down to push my pants off. I helped unbuckle my belt and had my pants off but since Heather was wearing my boxers I was completely naked except for socks. Since Heather wasn't wearing socks I took those off too. While I did that I noticed Jen motioning to Mike to take off his underwear. Mike seemed reluctant but Jen's playful pouting won and we were all naked.
I decided to french kiss Mike and he definitely was a little shocked by that but I rubbed his chest and when he saw the girls doing the same he got into it. He relaxed and laid back. I kept making out with him and I felt his cock rub my hip as I moved in. His cock was beautiful. It was 6 inches at least and he was circumcised, but it was his balls that were amazing. His sack was big and really wanted to touch it. I kept rubbing his chest as we kissed. Mike was watching the girls. I kissed his chest and put my hand on his stomach. I looked over and Heather was doing the same to little Jen who moaned in pleasure. I slowly moved my hand down and my wrist touched the base of his cock. But Heather couldn't hold back her hand went for it. Mike looked at me and I shrugged and grabbed the base of his cock and stated to massage it. He relaxed and put his head back. Heather had her pinky and ring finger in Jen's pussy and I felt something I didn't expect. Mike had put his hand on my cock. It felt amazing. His hand was a little cold but he started to rub it. I kissed him again and he even reciprocated. I looked over and Jen and Heather were rubbing each other's pussy as they were making out. I looked at that cock and I cupped those amazing balls as I moved off the couch and in between Mike's legs. I knelt down and spread Mike's legs and with one hand around the base of that monster I engulfed it.
I felt Heathers feet touch mine as I heard Jen moan in delight. I started to suck his cock while massaging the base as I had seen in countless pornos. He started to buck his hips and fucked my mouth. I used my free hand to jerk off. I then spread his legs wider. I slid my hand under his ass with my thumb on his taint. My chin was covered in his balls and I slid my thumb towards his asshole. His balls began to tighten up as I did this. I kept massaging his cock as I looked over at the girls who were in another world. Mike looked pained and I resumed sucking him and rubbing his asshole. I even licked under those massive balls. I felt his hand on my head as I was sucking him and he started to cum. I wasn't planning to swallow but I had no choice. He jetted cum down my throat. I swallowed every drop. I cleaned his cock off and I kissed his balls.
I then started to lick his taint again. I told him to flip over. He stood up and knelt on the couch cushions. His rapidly hardening cock told he he liked having his ass played with. I spread his ass cheeks and stuck my tongue hard up his asshole. I used my fingers to hungrily get more ass. Mike was clutching the back of the sofa. I looked back at Heather who reached into the silk bag for a dildo. I noticed lube in there. I gabbed the lube and coated my fingers. I touched Mike's asshole and it reacted to the cold lube. I massaged his crack to warm it up, but I rubbed the excess on my cock. I inserted my index finger and Mike groaned loudly. I stood up and rubbed the head of my cock up and down his crack. He was shaking but he breathed out "fuck me, please"
I used my fingers to steady my cock into his ass but it was harder than I thought. I told Mike to relax. He breathed out and I pushed in. He yelped. And I grabbed his hips to pull his ass on to my cock. I saw his hands clutching the sofa and I pulled out, but as I did he relaxed his grip so I pushed back in. He pushed back on me as well. I kept fucking him and he got more comfortable. I put my hands on his shoulders and fucked harder. He straightened up and I reached around to his hard cock. I felt his hands on my ass pulling me in. Then he bent down. I felt him shuddering,and his ass clenched my cock. I felt the cum on my hands. I began to cum hard. I filled his ass with hot cum and his ass. I never came so hard. He and I collapsed on the couch.
We looked at the girls who had been watching.
"Who won?" asked Mike. And we all laughed.
I am new to writing relatively. I am also new to San Diego. I welcome any critiques, compliments, flirts etc.