The Buddy Party - Twelve
See the beginning of part one for the history of this story. Comments welcome to Cgard43@hotmail.com
Todd was very curious about how the pairing off would go that night. There was now an even number of guys. He wondered if Jim wanted him to help him try the dildos but was hesitant to bring it up until Jim volunteered to load up the dishwasher. Todd quickly offered to help and the two of them were alone in the kitchen.
"I've gotta ask you something, Jim," Todd whispered. "Just so I know. Do you want me to help you with your toys?"
"Well, if you don't mind," Jim answered with a grin. "Don't know how far we'll get, but I'd be glad to spend some time with you. Something's bound to come up." Both men laughed at that.
In the main room, nobody was doing much talking at all. Everyone seemed a little lethargic after dinner.
"How about a walk, Coach?" Tony said finally. "Let's walk off some of that pasta."
"Sounds great," Coach said with a laugh, "But I couldn't walk far enough to burn up all those carbs." The two men set out and Al sat looking quizzically at the door.
"How about some poker?" Al suggested. Soon they had a table set up with five players: Mickey, Al, Frank, Mitch and Tom. Joey walked to the kitchen to offer his help.
"You guys want to play poker?" Joey asked. "I'll take over if you do." Todd and Jim declined and they were soon finished with the job.
"Joey," Jim said rather tentatively, "You want to come and play with Todd and me?" Joey looked surprised.
"We thought we'd check and see how Jim's new toys work," Todd said.
"Hey, yeah, if you want me too," Joey said. "That sounds more fun than cards."
Once they'd finished the kitchen work, the three of them sauntered casually down the hall to one of the bedrooms. Once they had undressed and jumped on the bed, Jim admitted to his own nervousness.
"Listen, buddy," Todd said. "If you don't want to do this, we won't...simple as that."
"No, no," Jim said anxiously, "I do want to try it, but I feel kind of stupid about these things."
"Just lie down," Todd said, "Joey, why don't you get up there and give Jim something to play with."
Joey jumped up and positioned himself at the head of the bed, sitting with his back resting against the headboard. Jim stretched out on his belly and took Joey's still soft cock into his mouth. He hadn't had that pleasure this weekend and quickly got his mouth stuffed full.
Todd didn't reach for the dildos. He got between Jim's legs and started giving Jim some tongue action on his ass. Jim groaned every time Todd's tongue came near his hole, which made for a lot of moaning. Then Todd started with some lubed finger work, doing much as he'd done that afternoon with Mickey when Jim was in the sling.
"Oh God, that feels wild," Jim said, letting Joey's cock slip from his mouth. He laid his head on Joey's lap and Joey stroked his head as Todd continued to finger him.
Todd knew Jim was doing a great job of keeping his ass relaxed, and Todd was able, rather quickly, to slip three fingers into Jim's tight hole, using quite a bit of lube in the process. Then Todd reached for thinner of the two dildos.
He applied more lube to the dildo and positioned it at the opening.
"Now, just keep yourself relaxed, Jim. You're gonna feel it go into you, but it's not going to hurt. It's thinner than my fingers were."
Todd remembered how David had very slowly started inserting the dildo into him and tried to do exactly the same thing. In a few minutes, he'd managed to get about three inches inside. Jim was still petty relaxed.
"Doesn't hurt," Jim mumbled. "Feels a little bit funny to tell the truth."
"Funny good or funny bad?" Joey asked. Jim didn't answer.
"Now a little bit more," Todd said. He was remarkably patient, because he wanted Jim to learn just how great ass action could feel.
Jim kept taking the thin dildo up his ass and finally asked Todd how much he had taken.
"How much do you think?" Todd asked patiently.
"I don't know, maybe four inches."
"More like eight," Todd answered. Jim was amazed.
"Wow, man," he said, "It doesn't hurt. It doesn't hurt." Todd chuckled.
"There," he said as he slid another couple of inches of the dildo into Jim's ass, "How's that."
"It's fine, actually, I can feel it but it doesn't hurt," Jim answered.
"Now, I'll show you exactly what you had up your ass. I'll hold my finger here and then slide it out. Okay?" He well remembered how surprising yet calming an effect that technique had on him when David did the same.
When he held up the dildo for Jim to see that he'd had at least nine inches inside him, Jim was amazed.
"That's the point of using a thin one like this," Todd said, "It's to show you how much more depth you can take than you thought." Jim was indeed surprised.
"Now, before we use the other one, why don't you pay some attention to Joey's cock again." Todd kept his own cock in check as he watched Jim take Joey's cock deep in his mouth and start sucking on it. When Jim had been sucking for a few minutes, Todd again used his fingers and more lube on Jim's hole.
In minutes, he was stroking his two fingers all the way into Jim's ass. Jim was taking them easily and obviously without any pain.
"Man, that feels hot," Jim murmured before sucking Joey's cock again.
Todd then started with the other dildo. The dildo had a normal sized head and so the first couple of inches slipped into Jim's ass without causing pain. Todd knew that the next part was the tricky part...getting the thicker dildo past what he always thought of as the 'pain point' in his own ass. If Todd could work this rubber toy past that point, Jim would be doing great.
Very slowly, he began stroking the dildo in and out, in tiny little measures. When he'd gotten about three inches up Jim's ass, Jim started to moan, but it wasn't a moan of pain, only of recognizing something was entering his hole.
At about five inches, Jim tightened up his ass muscles.
"Relax, Jim," Todd said. "I'm not gonna move it again for a while, so you can just relax and get used to it." Todd kept his hand on the end of the dildo, but was careful not to push on it. He could actually see Jim relax his ass muscles, with the dildo midway inside him.
"God, it's so hot feeling that up there while I've got this cock in my mouth," Jim said, stroking Joey's cock.
"You bet it's hot, man," Joey said, "It's hot having my dick in your mouth and seeing that thing up your ass." That did not help Jim relax, but he didn't tighten up too much either.
After five or six minutes, Todd moved the dildo out a little bit and then pushed back in, moving just slightly deeper with each stroke. When he had about seven inches in Jim's ass, he instructed Jim to turn on his side.
"It doesn't hurt," Jim said, "I just feel very full back there."
"Right," said Todd, knowing the feeling well. Then he spoke to Joey.
"Come on, Joey," Todd said, "Trade cock with him while I play with his butt." Joey quickly moved into position and the guys were 69-ing, as Todd resumed stroking the dildo into Jim's ass.
Jim started moaning again, not in pain but as the rigid dildo in his ass stroked past his prostate. Suddenly it felt good to him. He had something up his ass and it felt good. Jim couldn't believe it.
Meanwhile, Jim and Joey were doing great work on the other's cock and Joey knew he was getting very close. He glanced up and met Todd's glance, and Todd nodded at him, understanding what he meant.
Todd started stroking a little faster, then after another minute, a little faster and soon he was fucking Jim's ass with almost the same length of dildo as the cock Jim was getting down his throat.
Suddenly, Joey started to moan loudly and Todd knew he was going to come.
"That's okay," Todd thought to himself. "Joey's not gonna quit on Jim's cock until he finishes."
After he'd taken Joey's load of hot cum and swallowed it, Jim moved his mouth off Joey's cock.
"Oh guys, that's so fucking hot. I can't believe how that feels with that thing up my ass and Joey sucking me.
"Feeling good now, buddy?" Todd asked, stroking a little faster. He was, at that point, giving Jim about what a normal, gentle fucking stroke would be like, and Jim was taking it fine.
"Oh God yes," Jim said, just as he reached the point of no return.
"Oh yeah, I'm gonna cum," Jim cried, "I'm gonna shoot my load." Todd continued gently stroking the dildo in and out of Jim's ass, and Joey kept sucking hard and fast.
Soon Joey felt Jim's cock start to erupt down his throat. Joey couldn't believe how Jim was shooting, but kept up sucking to the last.
"Oh," Jim cried, "I did it. I took that thing up my ass!"
"Yes you did," Todd answered, "And Jim, you've got more up here than most guys can give you. You can take a man's cock up your ass...and without heavy pain, right?"
"Yeah, man," Jim answered, "I did it. Wow!"
Todd was tempted to continue, but he didn't. He slowly, carefully slid the dildo from Jim's ass, marking how far it had been inside him. When he pulled it out, he showed it to Jim.
"My God, that's as big as a lot of cocks," Jim said.
Todd smiled at him and then leaned down and kissed him hard. Jim answered in kind.
"Thank you, man, thank you," Jim said, hugging Todd. "You don't know what this means to me."
"Too bad we don't have another day to test it out further," Joey said with a grin.
Todd looked at Joey and Joey winked at him. He realized that both he and Jim had learned a few things this weekend.
Back at the poker table, Mickey and Tom were a bit ahead, though the game was running pretty even. Jim, Joey and Todd kibitzed and watched the game for a while, and every so often, they'd reach down and grope one of the players.
"Cut it out, guys," Mitch said, "I'm having a hard enough time." Then, the trio grew bored and popped a video in the machine and plopped down on the couch.
Like most porn videos, this one was in segments. As the first one ended, after a typical round of sucking and then fucking, Joey voiced his opinion.
"The thing I can't figure out about these videos," he said, "Is if the guys are so hot, why don't they stay really hard?" Jim laughed.
"Maybe it has to do with doing in front of a bunch of people," he answered.
"The thing I don't get," Todd said, "Is that they always stop and pull out of mouth or ass just at the end."
"That's to let the audience know for sure that the guy comes." Joey said. Todd shrugged.
"That means the guys are missing half the fun." Todd replied, laughing.
Tony and the Coach returned from their walk just as the card game broke up. Nobody had heard the conversation during the walk.
"I've been thinking," Tony said as they strode along, "You never get much fuck action during these things, do you?" Coach laughed, remembering that he'd gotten fucked twice the night before, but assumed that wasn't what Tony had meant.
"I never get a lot of top action ever," Coach replied. "As I've said, having a really big cock isn't always an advantage."
"How about we change that tonight, Coach?" Tony asked. Coach looked surprised and somewhat puzzled.
"You really mean that? You want to take my cock that way?" he asked. Tony nodded.
"Yeah, I do, " he said. "I really want it in my butt."
"Well, let's partner up tonight and see what we can make happen," Coach said, grasping Tony's arm in a friendly gesture. Tony nodded again.
When the poker game broke up and all the stuff was being put away, Tom walked over and sat down next to Todd.
"How about you and me....tonight?" he whispered. Todd smiled and grinned.
"Sounds great to me, man." He said. "I really think I'd like that."
Todd was absolutely thrilled when Tom asked him to be his partner for the night; not only did Todd think Tom incredibly handsome, there was a strong masculinity that appealed to Todd. Well, that and the great looking package Tom seemed to have in his pants.
At the other end of the sofa, Joey whispered to Jim.
"If you were to decide you want to try getting fucked by one of the guys tonight, I'd recommend Frank. His cock isn't as big as some of the others, and I can promise you that he knows how to fuck very nicely and not rough." Jim looked at him in surprise.
"I know, I know," Joey whispered, "But it's true. He fucks me and he's very good. He also thinks you're very sexy. He's told me that before."
This was a surprise to Jim, although as he reflected on it, Frank had always been one of the quietest in the group and the least prepossessing. An interesting prospect for the evening, he thought. Jim had a second reason for choosing Frank. In size...yes, cock size...Frank matched up pretty well with a guy Jim had been dating. It was really for him that Jim wanted to learn to take a cock up his ass, but that was his secret.
Frank was surprised when Jim asked him a little later to join him for the night; actually, he'd been a little embarrassed when Jim caught him beating off while watching the video earlier. But Frank had always thought Jim a very hot guy, and was more than willing to join him.
"How about you and me tonight, Mitch?" Joey said a few minutes later.
"Sure, man," Mitch said. He felt quite flattered as he considered Joey very cute.
By process of elimination, that looked like pairing up Mickey and Al again...a prospect that suited both of them just fine. Mickey was in the mood to get fucked again, and Al had the biggest cock in the group other than Coach.
And so, nightfall came to the Buddy Party and the guys paired off.
To be continued.