Eric pulled out of me as his girlfriend stood in shock. She had just witnessed the final moments of her boyfriend cumming into my ass. My face was red and still pressed against the tile of the shower stall, which Kelly had just opened hoping to surprise her boyfriend. My back was still arched. Kelly's jaw was on the floor, and Eric was still rock hard and dripping wet from a combination of the shower water and his seminal fluid.
Tears filled Kelly's blue eyes as she ran out of the men's cabin bathroom at the summer camp where we were all staff members. Eric grabbed a towel in an attempt to cover his junk while chasing after Kelly. I peeled my face from the stall but stayed to wash Eric's sex off of me. After a quick shower, I put on my clothes and headed back to my cabin. Eric wasn't in his bed, so he must have been talking things out with Kelly. I could still smell him on me.
Things were strange the next day. I expected Kelly to be angry at both Eric and myself. He had cheated on her, and it was with a man. What girlfriend wouldn't be enraged? To my surprise, Kelly wasn't mad. In fact, she gave me a big smile when I saw her at breakfast. How did Eric explain last night? After we ate, I ran to the athletics field where Eric was working.
"What happened last night?" I asked, out of breath from the jog.
"Oh, I told her everything." Eric smiled.
"Everything?"
"Yeah, I told her about that last night at camp when we were 17, that night that you and I boned when she wouldn't let me fuck her. I told her I wasn't gay but you and I had a physical connection that I wanted to explore before I settled down."
"What did she say?"
"She was silent for a while, and then she asked if she could watch."
"What does she want to watch?"
"She said she wants to watch... us... fuck." Eric's lips moved in slow motion when he said those last two words. "She said she thinks it's hot."
"What do you think?" I asked, not knowing if I should sound disgusted or excited.
"I care about you both. Physically, I like knowing what makes you feel good and giving it to you relentlessly, and I think it would be hot to have her be there when I do it. I am going to marry her after all. I don't want to keep secrets from her."
Stunned, I wasn't sure how to proceed. I had never been with a woman before, but as long as I didn't have to fuck her, a threesome couldn't be that bad. After thinking about the dynamics of the situation, I told Eric about my sexual encounter with Terry and Patrick at the pool the other day. From there, we decided to invite them and Kelly to the lake that night after everyone else had gone to sleep. The shower stall wouldn't be big enough for all of us to fit.
The rest of the day flew by quickly. Patrick and Terry were excited when I told them about our private party at the lake. They wanted to see Eric fuck me and Kelly. Who knew what would happen? Maybe they would get a chance to fuck her too.
When night fell, each of us snuck out of our cabins and headed for the lake. Kelly and the guys were already there when I arrived. They had began having some fun by skinny dipping in the lake. I quickly took off my clothes and ran into the water and into the arms of Eric, his erection meeting me midway into our embrace. He was ready, and so were the guys who were making out. Kelly jokingly splashed us for leaving her out until Eric turned his head to kiss her. Things were getting hot as we played with one another as if it were foreplay to foreplay.
When we were comfortable with being naked in front of each other, the group moved out of the water to dry land. A picnic area was located next to the lake. The tables and benches would serve as a great place for us to play.
Eric told Kelly and me to sit on top of the wooden table. He kissed me first and then moved on to Kelly. Patrick and Terry moved to kiss me while Eric made out with his girlfriend who sat naked next to me. As Eric moved down Kelly's body, he sucked on each of her breasts then moved south. The guys followed suit. Each took one of my nipples into their mouths, sucking and teasing me with their tongues. When Eric reached Kelly's cunt with his tongue, Patrick and Terry shared my dick with their tongues meeting as the licked and kissed it from the head down the shaft. Patrick took one of my balls into his mouth, when Terry decided to deep throat me.
I could hear Kelly moaning next to me. She watched me get blown by Patrick and Terry while Eric continued his tongue assault on her clit. Eric started fingering her when he stood up and motioned for me to lean over to suck him off. By doing so, I exposed my pink asshole for Patrick to take advantage of with his tongue. Terry continued to suck on my meat.
After Patrick got my ass wet with his saliva, it was time for Eric to take me just as Kelly requested. Eric had me lay my back on the picnic table. Terry climbed on top to hold my legs. In doing so, his asshole hovered over my mouth. I kissed it as Eric inserted his rod into me on the end of the table. The deeper he went into me, my tongue explored Terry's hole with more intensity. On the other end of the table, Kelly sat with her legs spread. Patrick had taken over eating her out for Eric who was now pumping me deep. Kelly's eyes were focused on her boyfriend as she watched him fuck another man. She was turned on by his intensity. Eric had never been that forceful with her.
Terry was the first to cum. He squirted all over my chest and stomach as I jerked him off and probed his hole with my tongue. Terry handed my legs over to Eric. Patrick moved to feed me his cock after Kelly stood up on the table and positioned herself for her boyfriend to eat her out while he continued to fuck me. She came on his face. He came in my ass, and Patrick came in my mouth. The three other guys took turns licking and sucking Patrick and Terry's cum off my body, and then we watched Eric fuck Kelly.
It was a good night for all of us. We had just finished "round three" and were getting dressed when a figure emerged from the woods with a flash light. We had been caught, but luckily it turned out to be Daniel, another new staff member. He didn't tell the co-directors of the camp. In fact, the only thing he said about the scene was, "Why didn't anyone invite me to the orgy?"
Life went back to normal after that. True to his word, Eric proposed to Kelly on the last night of camp. She accepted with joyful tears in her eyes. That same night, Daniel gave me his phone number and told me that he had been thinking about me since we met at staff training, but he didn't know if I liked guys. Having witnessed three men suck their own semen off my body, he thought it was a pretty good assumption to say that I was gay. We laughed a bit after that, and now I'm meeting him for our first date. Wish me luck.