Sometimes Fantasies Come True – Part 6
Bikerider1022@yahoo.com
The next morning, after Matt left, I was thinking about James. I decided I would call or text him. I grabbed my phone and to my surprise I had a text from James. "Good morning. I know you are busy this weekend, but I would love to see you again soon. Text me." Because of my sex date with Matt on the scheduled I had told James I would be busy this weekend.
I decided to call James so I could hear his sexy voice. We chatted for awhile and then made plans for Sunday brunch. What could be a better gay date than Sunday brunch? So, our third date was arranged. I couldn't help wondering if we would honor the "third date rule" and have sex.
Brunch was at Club Café which is a well known gay bar and restaurant in town. The atmosphere, food and company were all great. When our meal was coming to an end, James reached across the table and took hold of my hand. It was a small, simple gesture but I was really moved by it. I felt comfortable and relaxed. Could I be falling for this man?
After brunch we walked the neighborhood and continued to talk. By coincidence or design we ended up on James' street. "Hey, my place is right across the street. I would love to show it to you."
His condo was on the top floor of an 19th century brownstone. It was small but had lots of charming details and it was beautifully decorated. James had great taste. He made us coffee and we sat on the sofa to continue our date.
We chatted and casually held each other hand. There was a lot of staring into each other's eyes and the conversation slowed down. I wanted to make a move but wasn't sure how. I thought he would be open to it but I held back. Then I said, "What are you thinking?"
There was a slight pause then James said with a sly smile, "I was thinking, how can I get you into my bed."
"Well", I said, "I've always found the direct approach to work best."
"Fair enough. Chris, would you like to come into my bedroom with me?"
"James, I would like that very much."
We stood up and holding my hand he led me into his bedroom. We both kicked off our shoes and started helping each other undress. I unbuttoned his shirt and he unbuckled my belt.
I absolutely love it when you get to see a man naked for the very first time. Checking out all his assets and what he keeps private from most of the world. His legs, chest, ass and cock are right there for me to discover. It was still only 2 in the afternoon so there was plenty of natural light to get a good look. As I thought, his chest was moderately hairy, as were his arms and legs. His ass was firm and kind of beefy. I couldn't wait to get my mouth on it.
He was wearing white cotton briefs. They were not unsimilar to what Matt would wear. What was it about me that was attracted to guys who wear white cotton briefs? Is that my type?
When James dropped his pants I was caught by surprise. On his upper thigh, just below the leg hole of his briefs, was a tattoo. James didn't seem like the type that would have a tattoo, but there it was. A small, red cartoon devil just inches from his crotch. It was as if it was standing guard, protecting his cock and balls. Although I was surprised, I found the tattoo sexy as hell.
"What is this, a tattoo?"
James seemed a little embarrassed. "Oh, that's the result of a drunken college night. I've had it so long; I never really think about it anymore."
"Did it hurt when you got it?"
"Hurt like hell. I regretted it as soon as I got it."
"Well I kind of like it. It's sexy." I kneeled down in front of him and put my hand on his tattoo. My hand was so close to this crotch, I could feel the heat generating from his balls. His cock was definitely growing in his briefs and I had an eye-level view of it. I rubbed the devil tattoo a few times then with two hands pulled his briefs down to the floor.
That's when I got my second surprise of the day. Once free from its constraints James' cock continued to grow, and grow. When fully erect his cock was a bit over 8" and extremely thick. His cut cock also had a nice mushroom head. I'm not a size queen and I've seen plenty of cocks in my day, but what James was sporting was a real beauty. He was a good two inches bigger than me. I couldn't wait to get my mouth on that prized cock.
While I love seeing a man naked for the first time, it is ever better when two naked men embrace for the first time. Cocks pressed against each other. There is something magical about it. When James and I embraced, naked, it was like fireworks went off. We were kissing passionately when we fell on his bed and started love making.
I knew I would love sucking James' cock. It was just so much fun. My hand barely reached around the base. I spent so much time sucking on his mushroom head and licking his long shaft. With my left hand wrapped around his cock, my right hand instinctively moved to his ass. After about 15 minutes of sucking pleasure, James pulled me up off his cock so we could kiss some more. We kissed and rolled around on his bed. I was on top on James, then he was on top of me. Eventually we found ourselves in a 69 position and I returned to sucking his huge cock. James skillfully deep-throated my six-inch cock. There is nothing quite like the feeling of sucking on a nice cock while someone is sucking yours. Being in the 69 position gave me better access to explore James' ass. My hands roamed and explored his gorgeous ass while my mouth worshipped his large cock.
It wasn't much longer before we both exploded in each other's mouth. His cum tasted great. He also swallowed my load. James had his arm wrapped around me with my head on his shoulder as we recovered from our love making. Neither of us were in any rush to get up and leave his bed. We were both in ecstasy. I was very present in the moment. My focus was only on the two of us. I wasn't thinking about work, my house or even Matt. I was in the only place I wanted to be.
We stayed in bed until the sun started going down. Reluctantly getting out of bed I took a shower while James made us a quick pasta dinner. We were both famished from our hours of love making.
I wanted to stay but needed to be at work early the next day so I left after dinner. We kissed goodbye and both said what a great time we had. As I was going out the door, James stopped me. "Chris, can you come over for dinner tomorrow? I am taking a cooking class and we are making garlic butter baked salmon. The class get out at 7:15. I'll be back here by 7:30. I can't eat all that food myself. You'll be doing me a favor."
"Of course, that sounds great. I'll bring the wine." I went back inside and gave him another kiss goodbye.
On the drive home, I thought about my weekend. What is wrong with me? Never have I ever had sex with two different guys in one weekend. I sucked and fucked Matt on Friday night and sucked James on Sunday afternoon. Am I a slut? This can't continue. On the one hand, I am single and I'm not committed to either man. On the other hand, I don't want two men and I don't want anyone to get hurt. I must figure this out.
The next night I was back at James' condo eating a fabulous meal. He has been taking classes at the Learning Annex for a while and has really become a great chef. He said he never cooked when he was married and had always wanted to learn. Well, he succeeded.
After dinner, James said, "Chris, we've only known each other for a short time but I like you and I like spending time with you. I hope this can continue."
"Thanks James, I feel the same way. Things have been going great. I want this to continue too. However, there is something I need to tell. I feel I need to be honest with you."
"Okay, of course. You can tell me anything."
"Well, the thing is, I've also been seeing someone else. It's more of a casual thing. I've know this guy for a long time but we've only been seeing each other for the past sever months. It's complicated and I will tell you all the details if you want to know."
I couldn't read James' expression. His face was kind of blank. Was he upset or mad? I don't know.
James finally spoke, "Well, you're single and free to date whoever you like. We're not exclusive and I have no claim on you. As long as we're all safe, I can't tell you who to be with. If things change in the future, then I might have an opinion. I certainly don't want to hear any details. That's your business." Then he added, "I hope we will continue to see each other."
That's just what I wanted and needed to hear. I got up off my chair, walked over to James and kissed him on the lips. "I hope we will continue to see each other too. Thank you for being so understanding.
We didn't sleep together that night. On the drive home I thought about the choice I had to make and the two men in my life. One was my seven year obsession who through some weird twist I get to sleep with once a month. The other guy was a decent, upstanding guy who seems to like me and is not already committed to a family. I know what my head says but my heart was feeling something different.
My next date with Matt was three weeks away. I would have to come to some conclusion before then. Is there any way I can keep both men in my life without it becoming a complete disaster? I don't know.
I got together with James the following weekend. We went for a 5 mile hike. It was a beautiful late winter day. The weather was clear and bright with the temperature in the high 50's. James was a better hiker than I was but I managed to keep up. He wore shorts and I spent all afternoon staring at his sexy legs and well defined calf muscles. On the ride home we stopped by a local market, got food for dinner and heading back to his place.
Dinner had to wait. As soon as we got back to his condo we were all over each other. We left a trail of clothes from the front door to his bedroom. By the time we landing on his bed we were only wearing our underwear. I could feel his large 8" cock protruding, waiting to be pleasured. I couldn't wait to get my hands, and mouth on that monster. Yanking down his briefs I tossed them aside. Grabbing the base of his cock, I slowly sucked its mushroom head. It was amazing how thick and hard it was. I only wanted to give him pleasure. As I was sucking him I began to think about what it would feel like to have this cock in my ass. What would it be like to be fucked by James? I haven't had a cock this big or thick in a long time. Would I be able to handle it? I don't know, but I was so turned on I was more than willing to find out.
While I was sucking James, he was working on getting my underwear off. They were down around my ankles and he was starting to play with my ass. At this point I couldn't be more turned on. Thinking the direct approach is always best I said, "would you like to fuck me."
"I would love to fuck you." James got up and retrieved a condom and some lube. I laid on my stomach with my legs apart waiting for the pleasure and the pain that was about to come.
Before applying the lube, James spent some time rimming my hole. For me that always feels so amazing. There is no better way to prepare for receiving a cock then to get a good rim job first. After a few minutes James mouth was replaced with his fingers and a good amount of lube. He made sure I was nice and open before putting the condom on his cock and getting into position. I took a deep breath when I felt his big mushroom head at the entrance of my hole.
I admit it did hurt and it hurt a lot when James started entering me. Once he got passed my ring my body relaxed, pleasure replaced the pain. It wasn't long before he was all the way inside me and I could feel his heavy balls slap against my ass.
While his cock slowly entered and exited my hole, his hands roamed my entire body. He felt my thighs, my arms, my chest, my cock. He explored as much of my body as he could reach while his cock explored the inside of me. I was feeling very connected and safe with James suddenly I could feel him explode inside of me and fill the condom with his cum. He bucked and groaned several times before he finally finished and collapsed on my back. He slowly pulled his cock from my ass and for a short time I missed the feeling of him inside of me.
Once his cock was out of me, he flipped me over onto my back and started to suck on my fully erect cock. Being so turned on by James' mouth on my cock and just getting a fucked royally, it didn't take long for me to erupt in his mouth. James was very receptive of my cum and swallowed every drop.
"please stay the night with me. I would love to wake up with you in my bed. I'm seeing my kids tomorrow but not until 2:00. We can spend the morning together."
I agreed to stay. We got up, showered and made dinner together.
The next morning while I was making us pancakes for breakfast, James mentioned, "Chris, there is something I've been meaning to ask you. I know it's late notice but my school's annual fundraiser is in two weeks, on Friday. There's a dinner and silent auction as well as a talent showcase featuring the students. In fact, my daughter Sarah is singing. Would you like to go with me?"
"That sounds like fun." I lied. Of course, I want to spend time with James but am I ready to meet his co-workers and especially his kids.
"So, your kids are going to be there."
"yes, and so will my ex-wife and her husband. I know it's a big step so if you are at all uncomfortable please you don't need to come. I almost didn't invite you. We've only know each other for a little over a month but I wanted you to come and I took a chance. By the way, Beth and her husband are going and will be at our table. At least you'll know them."
"Can I give you my answer tomorrow?"
"Sure thing. The tickets already purchased. Just let me know."
The next day at work, I talked to Beth about the whole situation. Beth had been great about not asking me about how things were going with her brother. She was thrilled when I told her that everything was going great. I mentioned the school fundraiser and she said how much fun it is and she hoped I would consider going. She also assured me that James' ex-wife and kids would be fine. They had met boyfriends in the past and there would be no issue. Then she said something that stopped me in my tracks.
"What about your once a month "friend"? Is he still in the picture?"
Oh shit! I completely forgot about Matt. That Friday was our next scheduled date. How could that slip my mind? It was discission time. Do I stick with Matt who I can only see once a month and have no future with or do I take a chance with James who I have only known for a month and don't know if there is a future?
Maybe it's time to give up my obsession and try reality for a change.
I texted Matt and asked if I could see he right away. I know it's breaking our rules but something came up and it's really important.
We agreed to meet for coffee the next day. I was already there when he walked in looking as handsome and sexy as usual. When he approached me, he reached out to shake my hand. I thought shaking hands was a little odd considering all we'd be through the past seven or eight months. I've had your cock in my mouth and my dick up your ass and we are shaking hands.
"What's up Chris?"
"I have something to tell you. I've met someone. His name is James and he is really special. We've been dating for the past month or so. I really like him and I would like to see where this might go. I think we might have a future together."
Matt could obviously see how nervous I was, and my voice was shaking.
He quickly jumped in. "Chris, it's fine. I always knew that someday you would meet someone. I said from the beginning that whenever you wanted to end our arrangement we would. You are a great guy and I only want you to be happy. You deserve it."
"You have giving me such a gift and have taught me so much about myself. I will always be grateful to you for that. This is something to be happy about, not sad".
Matt saying what he did calmed me down a lot. We chatted a little longer and when it was time to leave Matt surprised me. We both stood up, then Matt came over to me and gave me a big hug. I was a little taken back by him hugging me in public but I really appreciated the gesture and how far Matt has come in the past several months. "I wish you all the luck in the world. James is a very lucky man. I truly hope everything works out for the two of you."
With that, Matt was gone. I sat down again to think about all that had happened with Matt and what my feeling were. Of course, I was sad that my time with Matt had come to an end but surprisingly not that sad. I was thinking more about the possibility of what will be with James. At that moment, Matt was my past and James was my future, or possible future. I started thinking about meeting his kids and his ex-wife and co-workers. I had no time to think about Matt.
I phoned James right away. He was teaching a class so I left him a message. "James, this is Chris. I would love to go with you to your school fundraiser. I am looking forward to it and looking forward to meeting you kids as well. I'll call you tonight".
The fundraiser was a big success. Beth was right, there was no issues meeting his kids and ex-wife. I didn't spend much time with them that night but there will be plenty of time to get to know them better in the future. Sarah sang beautifully and I was almost as proud of her as James obviously was.
Things have been going great with James. We spent almost all our spare time together. He never asked me about the other guy I was seeing but since we spent every weekend together there was no need. When we did have the "exclusive" conversation a few months later we agreed to not see other people.
It's now been about a year since James and I started dated. We celebrated our first anniversary with a weekend get-a-way and have even began talking about moving in together. We are very much in love.
Interestingly, I ran into Nicole around this same time. We talked for a long time and I told her all about James. She seemed incredibly happy for me. I appreciated it. She had some news about Matt to share as well. It turns out that he has a new situation just like we had. Their son's soccer coach is married and also bisexual. Matt and the coach get together and have sex once a month. Nicole helped facilitate the situation. If it works for them, then I'm happy for them.
Sometimes fantasies do come true, but it turns out that reality is always better.
The end.
bikerider1022@yahoo.com
Authors note: I wanted to thank everyone for all the positive feedback and comments. This was my first story posted on Nifty so I really appreciate it.
If you enjoyed this story, please consider making a donation to Nifty Erotic Stories.
http://donate.nifty.org/