The Confession
I thought the only purpose of this exercise was to use Mike to amuse themselves, but I was wrong. Ben had something else in mind. The next night, Mike waited at our door like a loyal puppy.
"Back for more, huh?" Ben smirked as we came back from dinner with Josh. Josh was very happy to see Mike. Mike was a bit embarrassed.
"Come on in." Ben opened the door to our room and we all entered. "Mike, if you want to stay, you got to do as I say, like last time."
"Ok." Mike said softly. He'd do anything now.
"Now strip naked. Take everything off." Mike didn't hesitate. Soon he was stark naked with a hard cock. It was already leaking.
"Our majesty is not very happy with your performance last night, is that right?" Ben asked and Josh nodded. "You came within five minutes. It was not entertaining enough. Tonight you have to last at least thirty minutes. If you cum within that time you have to do it all over again until you can last that long."
Mike squirmed. I remembered Mike's record was around twenty minutes; he never quite reached thirty. It would be a challenge for him. This was actually very good practice for Mike. I smiled.
"But before you can fuck Josh, you must return the favor. Last night Josh sucked you off; tonight you will suck him back. It's only fair." Josh took his cock out. Mike wasn't resisting at all, he just kneeled down and started sucking, and he looked like he enjoyed it. I definitely thought Mike was bi.
"Do you like to suck cock, Mike?" Ben asked. Mike didn't answer.
"I asked you a question!" Ben demanded.
"Yes!" Mike said weakly.
"Come on, be a man! Say it like you mean it. Say `I like to suck cock' loudly!"
"I like to suck cock!"
"That's more like it." Ben winked at me. I didn't know what he was doing, except he was humiliating Mike.
"Now put your heart into it! Give pleasure to Josh! He deserves it!" Mike started really getting into it. By then he has let go of all inhibitions. He started sucking Josh like crazy.
Ben raised his eyebrow. Mike was on autopilot now. Josh was writhing on the bed, moaning. Clearly Mike was doing a good job. In about ten minutes Josh came. "Swallow his cum, Mike!"
Mike did as he was told. He didn't look like he was being forced at all. In fact he seemed quite happy with himself. "You liked it, didn't you?" Ben asked. Mike nodded.
"Are you happy with his performance, your majesty?" Josh nodded.
"Good job, Mike. You sucked very well. Now... as a reward you will get to fuck Josh." Mike's cock throbbed on hearing that and he was visibly excited. We could all see how much he was enjoying it.
"Now, remember what I taught you last night. You have to last at least thirty minutes." Mike lubed up Josh and himself. He stood there shaking as he inserted his cock. The look on his face was priceless. He was in heaven.
He resisted the urge to thrust hard, and he was breathing rapidly. "You need to control your breathing, Mike." Ben instructed. "Deep breaths."
Mike calmed down a bit and started thrusting slowly. Josh was moaning loudly. "Oh he's big! He's touching me so deep inside!" Josh clearly loved Mike's huge cock.
Ben looked a bit hurt. "He has, what, half an inch over me?"
"Three-quarters, at least!" Josh corrected. "He's close to eight inches!"
Ben looked crestfallen, and may I say, even a bit jealous. That was the first time I've seen him like that. Ben jealous of Mike? Not in a million years, I thought. Mike looked very proud of himself to have something Ben didn't have. He thrust harder.
"Careful, Mike. You need to last thirty minutes, remember?" Mike doubled his effort to control himself and fucked at a steady pace.
"Now give your partner pleasure, as I showed you last night!" Mike started to caress Josh and stroked his cock. Josh looked very excited.
"Fuck me, giant! Fuck me with that big cock!" Josh's dirty talk was having an effect on Mike. He smiled, and for the first time in years, I saw confidence in his eyes. He finally had something over Ben! Ben frowned, clearly he didn't like it.
"Oh yes, you are hitting the spot! Yes, right there!" Josh moaned and yelled. Mike was even more excited now. It seemed he was about to cum.
"You still have twenty minutes left, Mike. If you cum now you have to start over." Ben said coldly, but neither Mike nor Josh paid attention.
"Yes, fuck me, Mike! Shove your big cock all the way in! Yes!" Josh was so excited, and Mike lost all control. He started fucking like a mad man and his whole body tightened up. He roared like an animal as he loaded into Josh. Josh was practically screaming as he came with Mike. It was earth shattering.
Ben looked hurt. "Mike, that's too quick. You didn't last long enough."
But Mike didn't hear him. He bent down and kissed Josh! "Oh, Mikey, that was awesome!" Josh said tenderly. Mikey? Josh was calling him Mikey?
"Ok, you failed the test. Now the punishment." Ben quickly got in between the two, trying to separate them, but they were inseparable. They were in their own world!
Ben looked at me and gave me a "can you believe this" look, which I found amusing. The problem with hooking up with a player is that you can lose him at anytime, when he finds something more interesting, or when he gets tired of you.
"I thought that was very good, Ben." Josh said. "It didn't last long but it was intense. I liked it. Proceed to the last part."
"Yes, your majesty." Ben said, crestfallen. "Mike, you have given and received blowjobs, you have fucked a guy, now it's time for the last act." Mike looked up, horrified. He didn't want to be fucked in front of three guys!
"It's give and take, Mike. It's only fair."
"But..." It's the first time Mike objected to anything tonight.
"What's wrong? Rick has fucked you before, right?" Mike's face was so red!
"Ben, you can't make someone do that. Isn't that against your own principle?"
"True, Rick. But I'm not forcing him, it's still his choice." As Mike stood up, I could see his ass twitching. He rubbed his ass and considered it for a moment. I could see he actually was tempted to do it!
"Don't worry, Mike. What happens here, stays here. No one will know." Ben smiled. "And as an added bonus, you can ask any of the three here to fuck you." Mike looked at Josh.
Josh smiled. "I'm flattered, Mike, but I'm a bottom. Why don't you ask someone else?" Mike immediately looked at me. I can tell he has thought about this before!
This was a total surprise. I never thought I'd have another chance to fuck Mike, but I certainly wouldn't give it up. I stripped and lubed us up. Mike moaned when I inserted a finger into his hole. He clearly enjoyed it. He was kneeling on the floor, against the side of the bed. His head was down and his ass was up. That huge, round ass that I fucked years ago was available again! I soaked in the sight and took a deep breath. Ben winked at me and I suddenly realized he had a video camera in his hand. I frowned at him but he put a finger on his lips. I shook my head.
It was true that Mike got pictures and videos of Ben having sex and tried to threaten him with them. I could understand why Ben was doing this, but it still seemed a dirty trick. But then at that time I was too engrossed in the prospect of fucking Mike to care. I slowly pushed my rock hard cock into that familiar hole. All the memories came back. Ben started recording. Mike was moaning loudly. He clearly loved it. I wanted him to enjoy it too, so I used a gentle stroke. I caressed his whole body. I missed having sex with this giant.
"Mike, do you like being fucked?" Ben asked. Mike moaned in reply. "Say it out loud, Mike. Do you like being fucked?"
"I like it!" Mike said softly, his voice muffled. He had his arms folded in front of him and his head was down. He had no idea he was being recorded.
"Tell Rick how you like to be fucked!"
"Fuck me... harder!" Mike's voice trembled. I doubled my efforts. Mike was really moaning as I hit his prostate. His body was shaking.
"Tell him how much you are enjoying it! How much you want it!"
"I want your cock, Rick! Fuck me harder!" Mike sounded ashamed, but his body was telling me he totally loved it. I started really going at it. Mike gave out a loud moan.
"I've been wanting this again for years, Rick! I'm so ashamed, but I fantasize about this all the time! I don't know why I want it so much!" He was mumbling incoherently, but we were all surprised to hear this. "Oh, fuck! Fuck me, Rick!"
He got me so worked up that I started fucking him like crazy. I always had a soft spot for Mike. The fact that he wanted it so much made me all the more into it. I wanted to give him what he yearned for!
"Oh, yes! Fuck me! Cum in me, Rick!" I could hold it no longer. I gave a few quick strokes and unloaded into him. It was so intense. I collapsed onto him, hugging him from behind.
"Oh, Mikey." I kissed his neck. I reached down and grabbed his cock. That's when I felt it throbbing and spewing his own cum. He climaxed with me.
"You liked that, Mike?" Ben asked.
"Yes."
"Ok. Now stand up." Mike stood up and saw Ben's camera. He was shaking.
"You... you recorded that?" His voice was trembling.
"Yes, Mike, much the same as I was recorded. You tried to use my sex pics and videos against me, didn't you?"
"You can't... you can't show this to anyone! You promised to keep it between us!" He was shaking so badly and he looked like he was about to cry.
"I did. I'm not going to release this video, Mike. It will be for our enjoyment only."
"No, you can't keep this, you got to destroy it! Someone will find out!" He was going hysterical.
"Ben," I added, "Please. This is going too far."
"All right, do this one last thing for me, and I will give you back the tape." Mike looked so helpless standing there I wanted to give him a hug.
"Tell everyone here your sexuality, who you really are. Be proud."
"I am... I am a..." He was having a lot of difficulty. He just couldn't say it.
Ben sighed. "Ok, I'll break it down for you, big guy. Do you like to have sex with women?"
"Yes!" He didn't hesitate.
"Do you like to have sex with men?"
"Y... Yes!" That was a bit more difficult.
"So, by definition, you are...?"
"B... bi?" He was so unsure.
"Yes! One more time. Say it to the camera. What is your sexuality, Mike?" Ben held up the camera, as if doing an interview.
"I'm... bi. I'm bisexual." He seemed more certain now.
"That's not so bad, wasn't it? Here," He gave the camera to me, which I held up. He went over to Mike and put an arm around his shoulder. "I'm Ben, and I'm bisexual. I'm proud of it." He gave Mike a really warm smile. Mike seemed more comfortable.
"Can you say the same?"
"I'm... Mike, and I'm bisexual." He was getting a bit more comfortable. "I'm... proud?"
"Come on, you have to be sure. Do it again!" Mike took a few tries to perfect it, but at the end he looked really pleased and relieved, as though a huge burden lifted.
"That's my bro!" Ben hugged Mike tightly. "Now would you consider letting me fuck that ass?" Mike was embarrassed and Ben laughed heartily. "I'm just kidding."
"What about you, Ben? Do you let people fuck your ass?" Mike asked.
"That will come in time." Ben winked at me.
"All right, Mike, you have had an intense night. Go back and think about it. Be proud of who you are, ok?"
Mike wiped the tears off his eyes and said, "Thanks Ben! Thanks everyone." He gathered his clothes and left.
I was impressed. "You've done a good thing, Ben."
"It was good, wasn't it? And we still get to keep the tape!" Ben gave me an evil grin.