Pridefest threesome
The following is a true account of an experience I had in the past. Names have been changed but the events are true. There is man on man sec described so if that offends you please read no farther.
I had posted another true story about an encounter I had which really changed my whole attitude toward sex. Read this first if you want to get a better idea of what I'm about. The story title is wedding-weekend-surprise and it was posted under gay interracial in March 2023. Here's the link.
https://www.nifty.org/nifty/gay/interracial/wedding-weekend-surprise
I heard from several readers who liked that story which was really cool. I even managed to meet up with one guy who was traveling to my city. So feel free to contact me. I love knowing that guys are reading my story.
justingay00@yahoo.com
So here's my story. I tried to include as much detail as I can remember.
I had been seeing this guy named Tony for a couple months. We had met on grindr (our first time was pretty hot, and might make a good nifty story by itself) and it developed into a regular thing, although realistically it wasn't going to be an LTR due to the age difference... I'm in my early 20's and he's mid 40's. But we have a great time together, so it was good for both of us. He's a latino dude, about 5'10" 200#. Stocky, muscular build, and hairy. Ex-military, with a sort of tough-guy handsomeness. Neatly trimmed beard and shaved head. Pretty much the opposite of my look... blond, smooth, lean body. I'd say I'm somewhere between twink and muscle boy. Tony is very masculine, and a total top with a pretty big dick. He's dominant, but not in a rough or disrespectful way. He just likes to take control and call the shots in bed.
There was a time after I first came out that I would never have imagined myself in this kind of relationship, taking the role of a submissive bottom. I liked to think of myself as more of a confident, alpha male type and kinda looked down on guys that were too gay acting, and I felt like bottoming would make me too gay. But the experience I described in my previous nifty story (which I hope you've already read to add more context to this story) really changed me. I've always been a people-pleaser, but I discovered that trait translated directly to sex. Pleasing a man, giving him what he wants and making him feel good is just a complete turn on for me. And the dynamic of being with an older, experienced man is very hot.
Tony and I would get together at least once a week, or more often depending on his work schedule. He's a sheriff's deputy, working weird hours and I was in school, so it was not always easy to find times to meet up. But I would always do my best to be available for him when he would text and want to fuck. He always fucks me bareback and loves the idea that I take his seed with me and hold it inside. In fact, our very first time was bareback even though I had talked about and planned on condoms. But he was intent on fucking me bare and did a pretty amazing job of convincing me to let him do it. And I have to be honest I loved it.
So that's Tony.
Somewhere along the line he brought up the idea of doing a 3 way with another top dude, and I could tell he was pretty into it, in particular watching me get fucked by another guy. I was definitely open to idea right away and I found it really hot. I was excited to do it and it just added another dimension that Tony seemed to really want. Like I could give him something new and different.
We initially tried to find a guy on grindr but it wasn't that easy to find a guy that was into it and that Tony liked. He took the lead which I was cool with but tbh I was a bit relieved when it didn't work out with a Grindr rando. We kinda dropped it for a couple weeks then Tony mentioned he had a friend coming to visit for gay pride in Denver who might be perfect... no sketchy online hookup.
This is where the story gets interesting... I came up with an idea to pretend we didn't know each other, and just meet up casually at the pride celebration and have things happen spontaneously. They would basically seduce me and I would sorta play reluctant and hard to get, but eventually give in and have sex with both of them together.
So our 3 way partner was a friend of Tony's from his military days who was visiting for gay pride. He showed me a group picture from many years prior... all these guys in their fatigues His name is Solomon... big, muscular/stocky, black dude about the same age as Tony.
We worked it out where Tony and Solomon would go to pride together.
Apparently Solomon lives in a fairly rural area and complains about not getting enough sex so Tony would vow to help get him laid. There's always a stage with bands and people sit on the grass and listen, so they bring a big blanket with snacks. They sit down, and of course I'm nearby watching. 5 minutes later I come and sit on the grass right next to them and act casual.
Tony initiates polite conversation and after a few minutes invites me to join them on their blanket and offers snacks. I accept of course. Convo is lively and when Tony makes any suggestive comments I appear oblivious.
Solomon is surprisingly soft spoken for such a big guy. Almost shy in a way but very warm and friendly.
We had some fun with the situation... Tony asked if I was single and I replied, oh I'm sorta seeing someone but it's pretty casual. Tony's like, where is he??? Oh he's hanging out with friends I think. Tony says, oh man he's a fool to let you come here alone, if I were him I wouldn't let you outta my sight. I just said don't worry I can keep myself out of trouble. It was hard to keep from busting out laughing at that exchange.
After I while they mentioned they were planning to go to a popular bar for a big pride party and asked if I wanted to come along. I agreed. We left and spent maybe 2 hours at the bar dancing and hanging out. It was really fun and not forced at all. By then it's like mid afternoon and the next logical step is a late lunch since we were all hungry. The downtown area is full of people from pride so we are thinking it'll be hard to get into a restaurant so tony suggests we go to a pizza place near his house (away from downtown). Sounds perfect. We talk logistics... I had parked and ridden then train into town, they had taken an Uber. We decided to all take the train back to my car and I'd drive from there.
Ideal since I'd have to drop them off after pizza.
So we execute the plan. Pizza is delicious. Next stop Tony's house.
It's early, maybe 4pm so they invite me in to discuss what to do with the evening. We sit outside on his back patio... Tony sits next to me and puts his arm around me and says something like, we thought we might have some fun right here just the three of us. I'm like, whoa dude what's happening here, and generally act surprised and caught off guard. Tony kisses my neck and Solomon comes over and sits next to me. They both start feeling me up and kissing me. I kiss back and Tony's like OK we're doing this.
They lead me inside and we head to the bedroom. Shirts come off and I get a look at Solomon... he's got a great body. Big muscular smooth chest.
Beautiful dark skin. I am really attracted to black men so I'm really excited about this.
We get in bed and we get naked. It's really bright in the bedroom with the afternoon sun so I see everything. I finally check out Solomon's dick. It's big... thicker and longer than Tony but not crazy big so I'm hopeful I can take it. I take turns sucking them off, increasingly getting more into it and less "reluctant ".
I move up between then and start kissing Solomon with my back to Tony and he starts playing with my ass. He says, you like that? You like to get fucked? I'm like, I don't know bro you're really big. He doesn't say anything and keeps playing with my ass then pulls out some lube. I was acting like I was not totally down but Tony was getting me in the mood. It wasn't totally an act since he really knew how to push my buttons. I was on my side facing Solomon with Tony behind me. Both of them are playing with my ass and I'm moaning with pleasure.
Tony moves into position starts rubbing his dick on my asshole. I pull away and say wait aren't you going to use a condom? He's like, no dude we want to fuck you bare. I spring out of bed and start pick up my clothes, nervously stammering and saying this was all a big mistake.
Tony gets up and gives me a bear hug from behind. He's like, relax Justin we're cool. It was the plan all along for me to object to bareback and I did my best to keep up the act.
He holds me from behind, strokes my dick and kisses my neck and caresses my body. After a minute or two I'm swooning with pleasure and let my clothes drop to the floor. He moves me over to the bed and drops down on his knees and spreads my ass cheeks and starts licking my asshole. I'm like, oh fuck that feels good and I bend over. Solomon is still laying on the bed with his legs spread, stroking himself so I move in and start sucking him while Tony eats my ass. Tony moves me onto the bed, on my hands and knees between Solomon's legs and my face in his crotch. I'm playing the part of a gradually but relentlessly seduced bottom boy but even if it wasn't preplanned it would totally be working on me. Tony had never eaten my ass like that before and it was driving me crazy... whenever a guy eats my ass I'm pretty much defenseless. Tony is more verbal than usual... playing it up for Solomon I guess. He's like, how's that feel Justin? You like that? I register my approval.
I keep sucking Solomon with increasing enthusiasm while Tony plays with my ass, alternating tongue and fingers and I'm moaning with pleasure. Tony lubes my ass and moves into position, teasing my hole with his fingers then his dick head. He's says, you like my fingers in your hole? I say, oh yeah bro. He says, great cuz here comes my dick.
I feel his dick head on my hole and I flinch and pull away a bit but he holds my hips and grinds into me, sliding his dick up and down my ass crack. He slaps my ass with his dick a couple times then rubs the head up and down over my asshole. Once again, he's very verbal, kinda like a play by play of what he's doing so that Solomon is fully aware of what's happening. He says, you feel that Justin, that's my dick on your hole. You want my bare dick inside you, don't you? I don't say anything, I just freeze in that position.
Suddenly he pushes inside and I flinch and gasp. I'm like, easy bro easy. Relax Justin, don't pull away, let me fuck you.
I've got Solomon's dick in my hand but I'm not sucking him any more due to what's going on behind me. I lock eyes with Solomon. He's just laying back, smiling and watching. My mouth is hanging open and I'm taking little gasping breaths as Tony works his dick into my hole.
Oh yeah that's right Justin, take it. Does my bare cock feel good in your ass?
Fuck dude it feels great.
You want me to keep going?
Yeah stud. Fuck me.
Before long he's all the way in and starts fucking me, slow at first then a little harder.
I climb over Solomon's legs so that I'm straddling his torso and our bodies touch. My face is buried in Solomon's muscular smooth chest and I suck on his nipples. Tony is slamming into me, not rough at all but just hard enough that my whole body is bouncing forward and back as I'm trying to suck on Solomon's nipples. I'm loving the fact that Solomon is watching this whole thing happen and there's something about my body lurching forward with Tony's fucking that I find so hot. I remember this feeling so vividly ... face to face with Solomon trying to kiss him while getting pounded forward and having to brace myself against the headboard.
Such a feeling of being owned with Tony in total control and Solomon taking it all in. But I couldn't help but wonder what Solomon was thinking about me in that moment... letting a total stranger (or so he thought) bareback me without so much as a discussion. And Tony had to play it up...he's like, you like my bare dick in your ass Justin.
Then Tony pulls out and says to Solomon, your turn. He'd been somewhat passive up to this point, which kinda made sense based on what I had gotten to know about his personality...much more reserved and quieter than Tony. I guess I was expecting two dom aggressive tops but this was pretty great. I'm still straddling Solomon and Tony tells me to sit on his dick. I look at Solomon and I ask do you want me to? He nods yes.
He's really big but I really wanted it so put a bunch of lube on it. I was nervous about taking such a big dick but at the same time I really wanted to please solomon and give him a great fuck. My ass was already pretty loose from Tony and Solomon was rock hard. I moved over and guided his dick into my hole. It was a relief when his head slid in without too much pain but he was definitely stretching me. I froze with him just inside and tried to relax... he was like oh fuck yeah and started pumping with these little jabs. I pulled up and he stopped. Are you ok? Yeah just take it easy you're so big. I start to bounce on it really lightly .... I'm not used to taking this kind of initiative but I really wanted him inside me. Took some time and more lube but I managed to sit down almost all the way but not quite there. He was maybe 2" longer than Tony and definitely the biggest dick I've ever had, and I was a little embarrassed I had to work so hard at it. It seemed like he was as deep as he would go, hitting the limit of what I could take. But I relaxed and let the weight of my body push down and his dick head suddenly popped past the last obstacle inside me and just plunged all the way in. I involuntarily let out this huge gasp... it was such a crazy feeling to have him so far up my ass. Solomon was like oh fuck yeah and started to grind his hips into me. I loved the feel of his abrasive pubes on my balls. I raised up my ass to give him space and took the hint and started fucking with short thrusts.
After a few minutes he moved me to my hands and knees and got behind me doggie style. He was in complete control, holding my shoulders while he fucked me. He took it slow at first, pulling nearly all the way out and back in then grinding into me. I felt every inch of him with each thrust. Then after a few minutes he started getting into a rhythm, fucking with increasing urgency until I could feel him start to cum. He didn't hold back and slammed his dick into me with a couple final thrusts as he came, then held it deep inside me. I could feel the throbbing and I swear I could feel the cum streaming out. There's just nothing hotter to me than a top guy climaxing, a little out of control fucking like a mad man.
He collapsed on to the bed, then Tony took over, flipping me on my back and lifting my legs to his shoulders. He didn't last long... couple minutes and he added his cum to my hole. I didn't touch myself so Solomon stroked me and I came in seconds with Tony still inside me.
I stretched out on the bed, sweaty and spent and I dozed off. Woke up who knows how much later and find myself alone in the bed. I came out into the living room and they are chilling on the sofa drinking beers. They have their clothes on and I'm totally naked and I love feeling exposed. They're like, hey sleepy. We laugh. I say, you guys thank you that was unbelievable. (Maybe laying it on a little too thick to thank them for bare backing me lol).
I went to the bathroom to clean up and take a shower. I felt like there was so much cum and I really wanted to just hold it inside me for as long as possible... I loved the feeling. But I was afraid I might not be able to hold it in so I sat on the toilet and let it just flow out of me. Omg there was so much cum. I got a hard on sitting there feeling it come out.
After I showered we all sat and talked. I asked what they had planned for the rest of his visit and they mentioned going to Black Hawk (a town in the mountains where there are casinos and gambling) the next day (Sunday). They invited me to join them which sounded like fun so I agreed. I went home and returned the next morning. Turns out Tony had to work in the afternoon at 3 so he suggested we take two cars so he could leave and Solomon and I could stay longer if we felt like it.
So we drove about 45 min up to BH, walked around, had lunch and played blackjack and slot machines. It was fun and we had great energy. Tony left about 2 and Solomon and I hung out until about 5 and headed back, grabbed a bite to eat then I drive back to Tony's to drop Solomon off.
I stopped the car and we looked at each other and kiss goodbye but it's a little too long. Then kiss again. Wanna come in? Sure.
We go inside and immediately make out and move into the guest bedroom where Solomon had been staying. Although it's still light outside, with the blinds drawn it's pretty dark in the room... sultry and maybe more romantic for lack of a better word. We got naked and Solomon's dark skin was so sexy... he's like a shadow in the low light. And he was very different one on one. Very sensual, touching and kissing, not in a dom way but more just enjoying my body.
I was on my back with him on top and he says, can I fuck you again? Yeah I'd love it. Do you want me to wear a condom? I'm like, um after what we did yesterday I'm not sure the point? He says, I know I'm sorry I shouldn't have seeded you like that, I want you to know I'm not usually like that, I respect you. This caught me off guard... kinda cliche to say he respected me, but it was actually really sweet. TBH, I wasn't sure he'd respect me after I let two guys I just met bareback me.
I said, bro you didn't do anything wrong. I had my chance to leave but I stayed knowing what was going to happen. That was my choice. TBH, seeing you naked on the bed I would have agreed to anything... you're such a hot guy. He said, ok cool but I'll still wear a condom if you want. I said, what do YOU want. He laughed and said, I wanna fuck you bare.
With that we kissed and there was some real passion, a different connection than before. We kissed for a while then he got up to find the lube. I was on my back in the bed, and I can still picture him coming back into the room... climbing slowly on to the bed, a shadow crawling up between my legs, and I'm excited for what's coming. There was no hesitancy this time as I spread my legs and he lifted them up to his shoulders. I felt his smooth muscular chest while he lubed his dick and my hole. I relaxed and let him start to slide his bare dick inside me.
This time I didn't have Tony's familiar dick to get me stretched out so Solomon felt like twice the size trying to get inside me.
Once he was all the way in and I was comfortable he started pulling his dick completely out of my ass and pushing back in. I said wow dude that feels amazing, keep doing that. Tony had taught me to tense up my sphincter to increase his pleasure so I started doing that, clamping down on the head of his dick as he pulled it out, then keeping it tensed up while he pushed back inside. Solomon was like, fuck dude that feels so good. It's like you're milking my dick.
That really got him going and he started fucking harder. I continued to clamp down on his dick and he's like, fuck you're going to make me cum.
I said, don't cum too fast let's make this last. So he slowed down and we took a slight break, still fucking, just really slow and sensual.
Damn boy, you are just so fuckable. How did I get so lucky?
I think I'm the lucky one here. I've never been fucked like this.
He fucked me missionary on my back with my legs wrapped around his torso, at times kissing my neck or nibbling my earlobe. Then he flipped me flat on my stomach and continued fucking, grinding his whole body into me.
His dick was fully buried in my ass and I could feel his thick pubes around my asshole.
He gradually got more and more frantic, eventually pulling me up on all 4s and fucking doggy style. I was literally biting the pillow with my ass in the air as he came inside me with a couple massive thrusts.
With his dick still inside me I jerked myself and shot my own load almost instantly.
I drove home and went to bed holding his cum inside me.