"We all go through it" Chad said as he pulled on his jockstrap. "And we both know you can do it" he smiled.
The cock he placed in the pouch had been in Jimmy's mouth as his own mouth had savored Jimmy's. They were roommates this year and quickly found out they could have fun together.
"Yea, I guess" Jimmy said
"But you never know who's you know....."
"I'll know when it's you" he said.
Chad chuckled, "ok but other then me. Besides we never uh did the other thing. Good thing we're both bi"
Jimmy smiled. "Quite a coincidence, of course lots of guys in college are bisexual or experimenting I guess" he said.
The group met weekly. Chad said he had been a member since freshman year. "It helps with dating you know, none of these girls want full on sex, they just want to flirt, fumble and fantasize about getting married" he had said that night Jimmy came into their dorm room, finding him sitting at the computer naked, jacking his cock.
"Come on give a guy a hand" he said. Jimmy didn't know if the guy was joking or not that night.
"Seriously dude, we can you know take the edge off each other" Chad turned as Jimmy was undressing to go shower.
Jimmy, wrapped a towel around his hips and tempted wasn't sure if he should do what he had thought about doing since meeting Chad.
"Hell man the computer says we're compatible enough to match up as roomies" Chad reached and Jimmy didn't move away.
"I still don't know" Jimmy said.
"Yes you do, let's go"
The walk across the chilly campus made Jimmy shiver or perhaps he worried about what was going to happen that night.
He stripped to his underwear in the basement of the house they had entered. "How uh many?"
Chad also stripped to his jockstrap assured him "Whoever gets the slips of paper. We never know" he said
He blindfolded his roommate and led him into the next room which was crowded with their underwear clad schoolmates.
"Kneel" Chad said to him and Jimmy knelt as another voice read the rules to him.
"We promise to meet weekly, we all take slips from the bowl that says whose turn it is and who gets to use him" the voice said. "Those that do not must leave"
Chad whispered to him "yea and they go somewhere to fuck each other probably" he laughed. "Here" he said pulling Jimmy's underwear off.
"Presenting" Chad said "a new member who voluntarily take the turn tonight as a pledge of secrecy and willingness"
"So be it" the other voice said
Jimmy heard a shuffling of movement around him and whispers as those in the room took slips of paper from the bowl.
"What's written on them?" he had asked Chad after they had drained each other one night.
"Oh just whether they get to stay or go, sometimes it's everyone sometimes only a few. But I suspect everyone will stay for a new member" he said wiping his dripping cock on Jimmy's lips.
"Just relax" Chad whispered "it's not everyone but..."
Jimmy nodded and felt a hand moving between his buttocks across his butthole. He'd be fucked in the ass and mouth, he'd be cum on, he'd have to give handjobs too and maybe pissed on by the group when everyone was done. Chad had recounted stories of past meetings.
"hey whatever we talk about or do the rest of the time is cool, but what we do during the meetings is totally secret, understand?" Chad had said "So you're cool with that?"
Jimmy knew that Chad had probably broken whatever oath he took in the private club as he called it.
"Sure sure, roomies promise" Jimmy said. Indeed they had their own secrets. And Jimmy had one or two of his own including the hope that sometime Chad would climb on top of him while he slept and push the cock he knew well, deep inside him
The first cock wasn't Chad's. In fact Jimmy wasn't sure that night if Chad's cock had used him or not. There were whispers, moaning and groans, we plops as sperm landed on his body.
He savored strange cocks in his mouth and discovered the joy of being buttfucked at the same time. Again and again he pleasured the unseen members of this new club he had decided to join.
Hands then moved him to the floor where he lay as even more sounds of masturbation could be heard and the fruits of the handmilked cocks landed on his face, belly, chest, legs..everywhere.
He'd see the picture later of himself covered with cum. "Don't worry, there's only one copy" Chad said showing him the one of him taken years ago. "Disgusting huh?" he was smiling.
The washing came as the final step. All members were there, he knew, since he was a new member. The warm water washed the cum from his face and body. The aroma filled the room.
And he belonged. Jimmy was already looking forward to the next meeting.
"Man you smell awful" Chad said as they put on their clothes after the group had shaken his hand, patted his ass and shoulders welcoming him.
He recognized some of them, others were new faces. But all were now special brethern now. Nobody would tell. It was their secret.
"Come on, I didn't get to do what I wanted to" Chad said as he patted Jimmy's clothed butt "But I will tonight, you owe me".
Jimmy's jaw was sore, his asshole was sore too, his muscles ached. But Chads words and ass pat envigorated him. He wanted to say "finally" but instead Jimmy agreed "Yea after tonight I owe you what you want"
Chad patted again "about time" he said and they left the basement laughing.