His Sisters Boyfriend

By Mason Hatfield

Published on Feb 4, 2023

Gay

The next morning, Mason woke up more sure than before that he needed to keep testing the limits with Hunter, regardless of his relationship with his sister. He felt guilty about it, but after last night, Hunter clearly was on board with some fooling around. Mason smiled as he entered the kitchen, seeing his whole family and Hunter. His heart pounded as his gaze met Hunter's for the first time since last night. He took a seat at the table across from him and casually reached for some toast, trying to act nonchalant despite the butterflies in his stomach.

"Good morning!" Mason said, looking between Sadie and Hunter with a bright smile on his face. "The sun is really shining today."

Hunter smiled slightly back at him before responding. "Morning, Buddy," his voice was low and smooth. "Hope you slept okay last night." Mason could feel himself blushing as he found himself wishing he hadn't slept quite so well...

Sadie chimed in then: "It IS such a beautiful day! And I'm so glad you two are getting along so well. It's nice to see family bonding over breakfast," she added with a glance to their mother, doing dishes nearby. Their mom laughed and told them to eat up. They all dug into the eggs, toast, hash, and sausages that covered the table. Mason was too nervous to eat much, he kept glancing at Hunter across the table as the family engaged in conversation about the day to come. He kept thinking about the feel of his big cock in his hands. He hadn't seen it, but he felt like he'd gotten to know it intimately all the same.

Mason took a deep breath, trying to ignore the sudden rush of heat that was flooding his cheeks. Barely thinking clearly, he slowly inched his foot across the floor until it reached Hunter's. He waited to see if Hunter would move his foot. When he didn't, he started to play footsie with him under the table, shyly but sensually glancing at him as the conversation flowed at the table. Feeling emboldened, Mason started to slide his sock-covered foot up Hunter's leg, moving over his sweatpants from his shin to his knee and then beginning to tracing circles on his thigh with his toes. His heart pounded as Hunter locked his gaze on him with an unreadable face.

He felt Hunter tense beneath him but he didn't say anything or make any moves to stop him. Instead of pulling away or getting nervous, Mason simply smiled softly at him before continuing to move higher still until finally settling his foot on Hunter's crotch. He began rubbing with his foot, feeling the bulge of Hunter's cock through his sweatpants, all the while the family kept talking to them over breakfast as if nothing was happening.

Mason looked at Hunter, his eyes glittering with desire and excitement, and he could see Hunter's own eyes mirroring his emotions. The two of them locked gazes as Mason continued to stroke Hunter's hardening bulge with his foot under the table, feeling increasingly aroused. He ran his foot up and down Hunter's thick cock, feeling the heat radiating off of him through the fabric, and Hunter was starting to look increasingly uncomfortable--but in a good way.

Their parents had some errands to run and Mason offered to finish cleaning up in the kitchen, so they headed out. Next Sadie got up, saying she wanted to take a nice hot shower before getting ready for the day. She offered Hunter to join her, but he said he wanted another helping of food so it wouldn't go to waste. Mason couldn't help but smile at that as his sister left the kitchen and went upstairs. It was just him and Hunter now, alone in the kitchen with a heightened sexual tension that neither could deny.

Mason finally worked up the courage to make a move, and with everyone else out of the room he stood up from his seat. His heart was pounding as he moved around the table. Hunter stared at him impassively as he straddled his lap, pressing their bodies flush against each other. Heart pounding with anticipation, desire and anxiety He leaned in close and captured Hunter's lips in an impassioned kiss, exploring every inch of his mouth hungrily. He could feel himself melting into Hunter as they kissed; it felt so right being this close to him that Mason couldn't help but deepen their kiss further still.

As they made out, Mason could feel Hunter's bulge under him growing harder and bigger with each passing second. Mason felt an overwhelming urge to taste him. Without breaking the kiss he shifted himself back slightly so that he was straddling Hunter more firmly. He ground his hips against Hunter, feeling that bulge rubbing against his ass through their clothes. Mason pulled away from the kiss then, looking into Hunter's eyes as if asking permission before slowly sliding himself down until he was kneeling between the older man's legs, the table behind him. He wanted to take Hunter's cock out of his pants and feel it in his hands, so he reached down between them and slowly untied the drawstrings of the sweatpants and pulled at the waistband, revealing Hunter's hard length beneath.

Mason couldn't help but gasp at the sight; it was bigger than any other cock he'd ever seen in person! He felt a wave of arousal as he looked up at Hunter with desire in his eyes. He licked his lips almost unconsciously before asking: "Can I...?" Hunter nodded wordlessly, giving Mason permission to do whatever it was he wanted. Mason smiled in response before slowly reaching out and taking Hunter's cock in his hands. He could feel the heat radiating off of it, and he ran his thumb over the tip, coaxing out a drop of precum. He toyed with it in his hands for a few more moments before looking up at him again with an eager expression.

"I want you so bad," he said breathlessly. Hunter stared back at him, eyes dark with arousal.

"Then take me," he replied with a hoarseness in his deep voice. Mason smiled, feeling anticipation like never before. He wanted to make this moment special for them both; he wanted to give Hunter the most incredible pleasure imaginable.

He leaned forward then and tentatively licked the head of Hunter's cock before slowly taking it into his mouth inch by inch. Mason felt himself trembling with nerves but also excitement as he tasted Hunter for the first time, savoring every second of it. His tongue explored Hunter's thick shaft, swirling around it as he bobbed his head up and down, gradually increasing the pace. Mason felt Hunter's fingers thread through his hair, helping to guide his head up and down on the big cock. Mason felt himself becoming more and more aroused with every second that passed, and he wanted to make Hunter feel as good as possible. He slowly deepened the blowjob until his nose pressed against Hunter's bush, taking him in deeper than ever before. He kept sucking on him with skillful technique, swirling his tongue around the shaft while using one hand to stroke from base to tip as he bobbed up and down on the thick cock.

Mason felt Hunter's hips bucking lightly up against him as his breaths grew more and more ragged. He could feel the other man growing closer to orgasm with every passing second, and Mason wanted to make it an experience that neither of them would soon forget. He increased his efforts, licking and sucking to push Hunter over the edge; he was quickly learning where Hunter's most sensitive spots were and he focused on those areas while lightly stroking with one hand.

The sensation sent waves of pleasure through both men as they moved together in perfect harmony--Hunter thrusting into Mason's willing mouth while gently guiding him along. Finally, with one last shuddering breath from Hunter, Mason felt the warmth of Hunter's cum flood his mouth. He swallowed every last drop, savoring Hunter's taste on his tongue.

Mason looked up at him with a satisfied smile as he slowly released him from his lips; strings of cum and drool connecting him to Hunter's cockhead. "That was amazing," Mason said softly before pressing one more gentle kiss to the tip of Hunter's cock and licking his lips clean.

Hunter panted as he looked down at the teen--his girlfriend's sexy twink brother--feeling a sense of satisfaction wash over him alongside inklings of guilt. "Yeah it was," he replied before pulling Mason up into another passionate kiss. Hearing footsteps in the upstairs hallway, Mason headed to the cupboards to get tupperware for the leftovers.

"What did I miss?" Sadie asked as she shuffled into the room, wearing a bathrobe and her hair wrapped in a towel. She was totally unaware of the passionate tryst her boyfriend and brother were engaging in.

Mason blushed as he packed up the food and Hunter smiled, sharing a secret look that only the two of them would understand. "Not much," Mason replied with a cheeky grin. "Just giving Hunter a hard time about not finishing all the leftovers!" They laughed and Hunter stood, kissing Sadie on the cheek before heading to the shower himself; Mason couldn't help but watch him go with longing.

As soon as he was gone, Sadie turned to her brother and raised an eyebrow. "You like him," she said knowingly; it wasn't a question. Mason nodded sheepishly; she still thought this was just a little crush! She had no idea that he could still taste her boyfriend's cum on his tongue...

Mason smiled and shrugged, trying to act nonchalant. "He's a nice guy," he said simply; but his eyes told the real story -- one of longing and desire that only Sadie could understand. She grinned knowingly before pulling her brother in for a hug.

"It's okay, Mason," she said softly into his ear as they embraced. "You can like him. It's cute. Just don't get too attached; he's mine, after all." She winked. Mason laughed weakly at her remark. He knew he should feel guilty for fooling around with Hunter behind Sadie's back, but he couldn't help feeling smug knowing that he had already sucked her boyfriend's cock and made him cum and she had no idea. She still thought he was an innocent little boy. `You're so wrong, sis,' he thought to himself.

He smiled and shrugged, deciding to play into her assumptions. "Someday Sades I'll have a man like him and you'll be the one who's jealous," he joked. She laughed and Mason thought that she didn't know how much truth there was in his comment. He brushed aside the guilt that lurked in his mind and refocused on the feelings of desire and longing that were consuming him every time Hunter was around. He wanted more from this man. And he would have more. Sadie or not.


Hunter stood in the shower, allowing the hot water to cascade over his body and wash away any lingering trace of guilt. He couldn't believe what had just happened. Mason had sucked him off! It was both unexpected and exhilarating. Before the previous night never had he felt this kind of intense attraction to another man, let alone one who belonged to his girlfriend's family! His mind raced with a million questions as he tried desperately to make sense of the situation--what did it mean? What would Sadie do if she found out? How far could he take things with Mason before it all fell apart? Fuck, he'd already let the kid blow him!

The steam from the shower began clouding up Hunter's vision but his thoughts remained clear. He knew that if Sadie ever found out about their illicit encounter she'd be devastated. She loved her little brother and this could destroy their family. So he resolved right then and there that nothing further would happen between them. But try as hard as he might, Hunter couldn't deny how incredibly attracted he was to Mason; every time they made eye contact or touched each other--even accidentally--he felt an electric current course through him like a jolt of electricity. He sighed heavily as reality set in--there were too many risks involved for anything more than a momentary lapse in judgment on his part...or maybe not? He turned off the water and reached for a towel, but before he could wrap it around himself, he heard a noise in his bedroom. He quickly grabbed his robe and wrapped it tightly around himself as he entered the room cautiously.

Mason was standing there with an expression Hunter had never seen on a man before; one of desire and longing. His blue eyes flashing with emotion as they locked onto Hunter's own gaze. Mason stepped closer to him until their bodies were almost touching, yet neither moved nor spoke for what felt like eternity - both too scared to admit what lay beneath the surface of their feelings towards each other.

Hunter broke through the tension when finally speaking up "What do you want from me, Mason?" His voice husky with apprehension and hope all at once; breathlessly waiting for Mason's response.

Mason took another step forward, so close that Hunter could feel his warmth radiating off him. "I don't know," he began hesitantly, unable to look away from those intense green eyes." I just... need something more." He motioned between them awkwardly before continuing "Something real." As if understanding exactly how much courage that took Mason looked down shyly then back up again after taking a deep breath. "And if it's with you... I don't care if you're her boyfriend," he said, referring to Sadie. He looked longingly into Hunter's eyes, desperate and seeking approval.

Hunter paused, slightly taken aback by Mason's bold declaration before stepping closer until only millimeters separated them. "We shouldn't be doing this," he whispered, mostly trying to convince himself while barely being able to suppress his rising arousal, which was evident in every word spoken no matter how quiet or hesitant.   

Without warning Mason clasped a hand behind Hunter's neck pulling him into an urgent kiss, his tongue darting hungrily against Hunter's lips begging for entry. It didn't take long for Hunter to give in, eagerly wrapping arms tightly around Mason's waist, deepening the already passionate kiss further exploring Mason's mouth relishing everything about it until eventually having to break apart, gasping for air. Both of them stood staring intensely at each other, unable to comprehend just what was happening between them, but knowing full well that they were going down a dangerous road.

Sadie's voice calling from downstairs jolted Hunter back to reality. He took a step away from Mason and ran his hands through his hair in frustration, exhaling deeply before turning to face him. "We can't do this," he said firmly, though the longing in his eyes betrayed the strength of his words.

Mason opened his mouth as if to protest but Hunter put up a hand to silence him. "I'm sorry," he continued, averting his gaze so that Mason wouldn't catch sight of the tears forming in them; tears of regret for what could have been between them and sadness at knowing it had all been just a momentary lapse in judgment on both their parts. "This isn't right. Sadie is my girlfriend--your sister! And she doesn't deserve this."

Hunter left the room, leaving Mason standing alone and filled with guilt. He had seduced Sadie's boyfriend in direct violation of her trust; a trust that he had been so reluctant to break. But Hunter had gone along with it all too willingly, seeming just as caught up in the moment as Mason was. And it felt so good--so right--that Mason didn't want to stop. He sighed heavily before finally allowing himself to admit what his heart had known all along: he wanted more than just a forbidden kiss between them -- he wanted something real with Hunter. Yet at the same time, he knew that if they allowed themselves to explore any further, things would only get messier... and if Sadie found out, she'd never forgive him for betraying her like this.

Next: Chapter 3


Rate this story

Liked this story?

Nifty is entirely volunteer-run and relies on people like you to keep the site running. Please support the Nifty Archive and keep this content available to all!

Donate to The Nifty Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2024 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

The Archive

About NiftyLinks❤️Donate