This story is completely fictional. Unfortunately none of this has happened to me or anyone that I know.
Happy Catfish.
Pt.1
"Sorry if I seem hesitant, I get a lot of fakes on here."
"It's all good, I completely understand. I've been fooled by my fair share of fakes too. I can assure I'm as real as the pleasure you're going to get when we meet."
I don't know why, but lying through my teeth to grown men who think they're going to get to fuck me, turns me on like almost nothing else. JakeJizzenhaal93 here was my latest catch, I'd been talking to "Jake" for about an hour on kik, and he was starting to let his guard down.
"I've got to tell you, I've been rock hard for this entire conversation."
"Me too! I've been massaging my balls this entire time." I sent him a picture of my shaved balls in my cupped hands, my five inch erection standing proudly.
Despite never being with a man, or having any sexual experiences with another person at all, I always kept myself so clean and smooth from my neck down that you'd think I was a fulltime sex slave. I just loved the sensation of pleasuring myself, and being completely shaven smooth made the experience that much more pleasurable. I still hadn't gotten the courage to use anything larger than my finger for anal masturbation, but God did it feel good.
"When can we meet? I have to have your ass in my hands, I won't be able to think about anything else..."
"You're making me blush! I can't stop thinking about your cock in my mouth, and your cum in my ass. I can meet on Monday at about 2am, if that works for you." I was lying of course, I had no intention of actually meeting him.
"That works for me, where should we meet? You said you can't travel, right?" I stated in my online add that I didn't have a car, despite being 20 at this point.
"I'll definitely need picked up, are you ok with car play? I'd love to find a secluded spot and ride you in the back seat ;)" I was being partly honest here, I did fantasize about being fucked in the back seat of someone's car, just not his.
At this point I was so turned on by this conversation I had to start masturbating. I was laying on my side on my bed, completely naked, slowly stroking myself as the conversation continued.
"I'm more than okay with car play!"
"Great, I love a good car fuck. Could you send me another pic of your cock, I need to come to it!" I really needed to cum. Jake didn't know it, but this whole conversation was like foreplay for me.
"I'll gladly send you all the pictures you want, if you send me a picture of you."
Fair enough, I thought. I got myself into a sexy pose, lying on my side. I positioned one leg just over the other in the "draw me like one of your French girls" position. I always admired my body. I had very little muscle in my upper body, so my shoulders were small, accentuating my hips, and I had the perfect amount of fat to have Acup breasts and a plump butt. I was what you would call a "twink", and my body drove men wild.
In my day to day life, you really couldn't tell how feminine I was due to the clothes I wore. I just looked like a scrawny guy. My family and friends had no idea that I was gay, or at least they never hinted to knowing, and I didn't plan on coming out anytime soon.
After taking the picture with the selfie camera on my phone, I cropped it to make sure my face wasn't in view, and sent it to Jake. I couldn't help but admire my photo. My hips making an attractive curve, my breasts accentuated by me laying on my side, and my small erection peeking out from under my thigh.
I waited for Jake's message about how sexy my body was, they always said the same thing, but the message never came. I waited for about five minutes.
"Are you still there?" This has never happened, my photos never scared men away, men would beg for me after showing the my body.
Another five minutes passed.
"Sorry, I just needed to verify something."
"It's ok, is everything alright?"
Without another word, Jake sent a photo. My eyes widened and I froze in shock. Jake hadn't sent a photo of his cock like I was hoping, he sent a photo of me from that previous summer. There I was, standing with the rest of my college Freshman physics class.
I decided to try and save myself.
"I'm confused, did you send me the wrong photo?"
"Don't play dumb, Curt, I know it's you. I recognized the mark on your leg."
Shit, it was clear as day in the photo, my birthmark on my right leg. It wasn't a big or obvious birthmark, but still visible, and fully on display in both photos.
I started thinking back to that class, trying to remember if there were any Jakes, but there weren't any.
"My name isn't Curt." I had to keep trying.
"Look, I know who you are, I'm in this photo too, but my name isn't actually Jake."
"I'm fucked!" I thought. My heart was pounding faster than it ever had, and my cock hadn't been so flaccid since I was a kid. I had no other option than to stop lying.
"Fine, you got me. Tell me who you are, were we close at all?" Maybe I could get "Jake" to keep this to himself.
"We weren't very close, we rarely talked at all, but I always wanted to work up the courage to talk to you, you were so cute, but I wasn't sure you were into men."
I tried thinking back to any openly gay or bi guys in the class, none came to mind.
"Ok. That still doesn't answer my first question."
"Jesse"
I didn't know what to say. I looked at the class photo again and saw Jesse standing on the other side of the group. He was tall with dark hair, bright blue eyes and a pretty handsome smile. I could remember having a slight crush on him, but nothing I couldn't ignore during class.
I closed the app, not knowing how to continue the conversation. I laid in my bed for a while before being able to fall asleep. I couldn't stop thinking of Jesse.
A few days passed without either of us messaging the other, I also didn't hear anything from my friends who were in the same class as Jesse and I, so I assumed he wasn't telling anybody about our conversations, then again, I didn't remember him ever being openly attracted to guys, so he was probably protecting himself.
A week later I was sitting on a bench on campus reading a textbook when someone sat down next to me. I didn't pay any mind to the random person.
"I still haven't been able to get your body out of my mind" a full but soft voice said.
I gasped so loudly the pigeons a few feet away took off in flight. I dropped my textbook as I jumped off the bench and turned to look at familiar face. Jesse's eyes widened and he put his hands up.
"Woah hey, hey calm down" He started smiling widely.
"Jesus! You can't just say that!" I half yelled, I realized I didn't want to draw attention to myself, we weren't completely alone in the area.
"I'm sorry, please, I didn't mean to scare you." He said as he picked my book up and gestured for me to sit down.
Hesitantly, I sat down as far away from him on the bench as possible.
"What do you want?" I asked, trying to sound stern.
"To put it simply...you." He said, looking into my eyes and smiling.
I sat there staring at him, not knowing what to say. I could feel my heart beating faster, my face was getting redder.
"Look, I know you're not out of the closet, and now you know that I'm not either. I think we can help each other."
"I-I was just messing with you! I'm not actually into guys! I just like catfishi..." I was panicking, but he cut me off.
"Don't lie. I believe that you were catfishing, but why would you ask for photos of my cock if you were just trying to mess with me?"
My face grew redder, and in betrayal of me, my cock started to swell in my shorts. I'd never been sexually humiliated, but I was clearly getting turned on by it.
"I knew it" His smile grew wider as he moved closer to me. "I'm guessing you aren't getting any, have you ever actually been with a man?" He moved closer.
"N-no." I said, not having any room to move further away on the bench.
"I can help you, I can show you what you're missing out on." He was almost in my personal space now.
I was glowing red, fully erect, and nearly in tears in embarrassment.
"Come on, let's go talk somewhere more private, we can go to my dorm room. Besides, that doesn't look likes it's going to go away anytime soon." He glanced down my crotch.
I don't know why, but I stood up, grabbed my textbook, covered my erection as nonchalantly as possible, and followed him to his dorm.
After a lengthy, quiet walk, we entered Jesse's room. He closed and locked the door behind us and moved to sit on his bed.
"Feel free to set your stuff down, make yourself at home." He said kindly.
I didn't move. Somehow, I was still fully erect. I continued to stand there with my book in front of my crotch.
"Suit yourself" He took his shoes off, followed by his shirt, then his shorts, only leaving his boxer briefs on. He had the body of a swimmer, lean with a healthy amount of muscle definition.
I caught myself staring and looked away. I heard the creek of the bed and glanced over to see Jesse laying on his bed, stroking his seven inch cock through his boxers while staring at me. I gasped and nearly fainted. I didn't think it was possible to get anymore erect, but I was.
"Come on, put your book down and come join me."
I tried to say something, but nothing came out.
"You can either join me, continue watching me, or leave. It's your choice, but I promise you, it'll be worth it if you stay." He said in a soft voice.
I glanced at the door, then back to Jesse, I didn't move. Jesse smiled, still stroking himself.
"I thought so. Let me help you get started, come here." He gestured for me to go over to him with his other hand.
After a moment of hesitation, I set my book down, revealing how turned on I was. I slowly walked over to the bed.
"Give me your hand" He reached out his.
I reached out my hand, he grabbed it and guided me over to the side of the bed where his face was.
"Pull down your shorts" He let go of my hand and let it run down my leg.
I was too turned on to refuse. I pulled down my shorts, accidentally bringing my underwear with them. Jesse smiled and looked up at me.
"That's a beautiful little cock."
"I..."
Before I could say anything Jesse put his arm between my legs, grabbed my ass and pulled me closer, taking my cock into his mouth. I gasped and impulsively grabbed the back of his head.
"Wait!" I came down his throat in no more than ten seconds, but he didn't stop. He continued sucking on my throbbing cock. I was seeing stars, I didn't know what plane of existence I was on anymore. My hips were moving on their own and I could feel a finger massaging my asshole.
After about 20 seconds I came again. Jesse let me out of his mouth, but kept ahold of my ass.
"You seemed to like that." He said, chuckling.
"Th-that was unreal..." I said through heavy breaths. I was still fully erect.
"Wanna give it a trie?" Jesse asked before closing his mouth around the head of my cock again and massaged it with his tongue.
"I-I've NEver triED it befORE!" I said, trying to control myself.
Jesse took me out of his mouth, grabbed me with both hands, pulled me on top of him like a ragdoll, and pulled me into a kiss. I had never kissed anyone before, but I was in ecstacy. I could feel the tip Jesse's cock resting against my balls, the height difference was pretty obvious. Jesse pulled away.
"Well now is a better time than ever."
I couldn't argue with that logic, so I started moving backwards, not realizing what that would do. Jesse's cock suddenly slid between my ass cheeks, rubbing against my asshole. I jumped slightly in surprise.
"Woah, slow down...we'll get to that later." He said, smiling widely.
I blushed brighter. I had almost came just from the excitement of having his cock on my ass. I never knew just how much I wanted this.
I moved back further until I was in position. I was sitting on my knees, not moving, just staring at Jesse's beautiful cock.
"Go on, it won't bite."
I reach out and grabbed it with both my hands and started stroking it.
"That's it..."
After a good 30 seconds of stroking his cock I knew I had to go further. So I bent forward and took the tip into my mouth. It felt bigger than it looked, and this was just the tip. I continued stroking his shaft as I gently bobbed my head, taking no more than and inch and a half into my mouth.
"That feel great, just like that..." These words of encouragement did more for me than he probably realized.
"Here, let me do you too." Jesse said, gesturing for me to lay on him in the 69 position. I didn't need any coaxing. Little did I know how I'd react to this change. As Jesse took me into his mouth once again, my hips started moving.
I was practically face fucking Jesse at this point, but without much force. Before I knew it, I was taking half of Jesse's length into my mouth, I felt like a pro. This went on for a few minutes, I came a few more times from Jesse's talented mouth, but he hadn't come yet. Suddenly I felt Jesse moving. He took me out of his mouth and moved to a slightly sitting up position, I just ignored it and focused on my job.
After a moment, Jesse started sucking on one of my balls, this was new, not as good as my cock, but definitely enjoyable. Then he stopped and started slowly dragging his tongue from my balls over my taint. My eyes widened, I knew where he was going. Then he spread my ass and before I could react, his tongue was in my ass.
The only thing I could do to keep from yelling out in surprise and pleasure was to keep sucking on his cock. So without thinking I took his whole length into my mouth. Gagging a bit, but not nearly as much as I though I would, Jesse came down my throat. After a good four blasts of cum, Jesse pulled out of my mouth, got out from under me, pushed me into the bed, and dug his face into my ass once more.
"Jesse!" I yellped in a voice that surprised me. I had never sounded so feminine before.
After a couple minutes of heavenly ass eating, Jesse stopped. I was dazed, I couldn't think straight.
"You...are a natural..." Jesse said while sitting up.
After that, Jesse and I sat there talking for a while, actually getting to know each other. I soon came to have more than just a crush on him during that conversation, and I didn't want to leave his dorm.
To be continued...