This story is a complete work of fiction and all characters are copyrighted to FOX. This is in no way a representation of the sexuality of the actors.
This series is following along with the first season. I don't cover each story lines, so it would be ideal if you watched the series while reading the episodes to follow along if you aren't familiar enough with the storylines (I don't explain everything that is always happening).
Also, note that I do realize that I changed Finn's cock to be only nine inches, instead of ten.
************** Episode No. 17 "Bad Reputation" **************
Puck couldn't believe he was third on the glist, a new list that was published to list the members of glee club according to sexual prowess. The only people on the list that could've honestly competed with him were Brittany and Santana, not Quinn. "I've got to do something about this," he said to himself as he left the glee club room.
He was trying to think of what, or really who, he could do to get that number one spot when Rachel walked up to him and said, "Do you want to come over to my house tonight and work on the glee club assignment?"
If it were any other girl, he would know what exactly they wanted, but Rachel was no ordinary girl. She might actually want to work, and not just fool around. He knew she had a boyfriend, but obviously they haven't done much, since she was awarded negative points on the glist. Puck agreed, and was excited about the possibilities of taking another girl's virginity.
Once Puck arrived at Rachel, it was clear that she only wanted to work on an upcoming glee club video she was working on. Puck even went in to kiss her a few times, and was rejected. He was feeling even worst about himself than ever. "I can't believe I can't even get to first base with Rachel. I used to be top dog at this school, and now I can't even get some middle-school action with a glee club member."
Puck reluctantly did help out Rachel, hoping she would eventually change her mind. It never happened. The next day at school, Mr. Shue had to start interviewing the kids individually to figure out who made the list.
"I know you did it Puck, someone saw you putting up the list." Mr. Shue angrily told Puck. He needed to stop the list being made again, or the glee club was going to be cut.
"I was moving the list, someone put it on Rachel's locker, so I was being a man and moved it," Puck said. "Besides, if I made it, I would put myself as number one. You and I both know that I'm the best fuck at this school."
"Actually, if I remember correctly, you weren't that good as a fuck as you think you are. But, I don't think you're talking about the one receiving the cock, now are you?" Mr. Shue said, getting a little hard in his khakis.
"Want me to show you what I mean then?" Puck asked, while standing up. He has always wanted to fuck his glee club teacher.
"No, I don't think that's appropriate Noah," Mr. Shue said.
"I'm fucking tired of hearing you say that," Puck said, somewhat angrily. "Now, let me show you why I should've been number one on that list." Puck kicked off his shoes, and unbuttoned his pants. Within seconds he was completely naked, looking at his teacher. His dick was at full length.
Mr. Shue looked at his hot student, still not wanting him to fuck him. He was the teacher, he should be in a position of authority at all times. Puck sensed his teacher's hesitation, and knew he had to work fast if he had any chance to get any ass tonight. He walked over, and pulled off his teacher's vest and unbuttoned his top buttons. He quickly pulled off his top, and unbuckled his belt. He pants were down before Mr. Shue could even realize it. Puck didn't bother pulling them off, and he shoved his teacher around to face his desk, grabbing in a tight hug. Puck's dick was pressed against his stomach and Mr. Shue's lower back.
"Now, here is a lesson for you, Mr. Shue," Puck said, smearing his precum leaking from his dick all across his teacher's back. Mr. Shue just moaned in acceptance he reached for a bottle of lotion on his desk. He handed it to Puck.
Puck quickly lubed up before he started to enter into Mr. Shue's tight hole. The only guy to ever fuck Mr. Shue was the football coach, Ken. There is a big difference in dick size between the two Will noticed. Puck wasn't even all the way in to know that this wasn't going to be as relaxing as it was with Ken.
"Just wait until things get a little better, then I'll really get to show you why I'm number one," Puck said, trying to inch his dick further in the hole. Mr. Shue did already notice the control Puck had with his hip thrusts.
"Now Puck, why can't you use those hips when you're dancing?" Mr. Shue joked while Puck slid his cock a little more in.
"Maybe I would if I had this ass as motivation more," Puck said, while slapping Mr. Shue's butt cheek. After several minutes, Puck was mostly in, and was able to work his cock in and out more to show off his skills. He had a nice rhythm going, and he decided to put on leg up on the desk. This change of direction of Puck's cock caused Mr. Shue to almost collapse in bliss. Puck started fucking him right where it felt good.
"Fuck Puck, you are good," Mr. Shue half moaned. He started to frantically jack himself off. There was no way he was going to let this opportunity pass him.
Puck wasn't exactly thrilled that his teacher was going to cum soon, but knew that he was also getting pretty close. He decided to pick up the pace, grabbing Mr. Shue's hips to steady himself a little better. Mr. Shue started to get in sync with Puck's thrusts, until he couldn't take it anymore.
"Ughhhhh," Mr. Shue moaned as started to shoot his man juices all over his desk.
"Get ready for my turn," Puck said, as he thrusted his dick even further into his teacher. Mr. Shue thought his ass was going to fill up with how much cum he felt enter his ass. "Now," Puck said while sliding his dick out, "you know why I would've put myself as number one." He quickly got dressed and left the room, his teacher with his pants down and filled with his teen juices. **************
When it was time for Rachel to show her finished project, Jesse was pissed he was triple cast with two other guys to play opposite his girlfriend. He also was even more annoyed that one of those just happened to be his somewhat-boyfriend, Finn.
"I'm sorry," Finn texted Jesse, "I had no idea that she was using all of us."
"But why would you do it without talking to me first?" Jesse texted back. "Come over to my place. I think we should talk."
Finn was nervous what Jesse was going to say. When he arrived at Jesse's, he was confused on how calm Jesse was acting.
"So, we need to talk. I think Rachel knows about us, and that's why she wanted to use all of us in the video," Jesse said.
"No way, how could she know?" Finn asked, confused on why Jesse would think that.
"I don't know, but it makes sense. Look, I really like you, but I can't pretend to be dating two different people. I either want all of you, or none of you." Jesse explained.
"All of me? You mean, you think we should...?" Finn asked, thinking that Jesse was wanting to go all the way.
"Only if you want to. I mean, I'm ready for that next step. Are you?" Jesse asked, looking up into Finn's eyes.
Finn got up and walked over to Jesse without breaking eye contact. He straddled Jesse and went in and kissed him on the lips. He broke the kiss and whispered, "I am."
Jesse loved the answer, and pushed Finn on his back on the couch. The two explored each other's mouths with their tongues. Jesse slowly pulled Finn's shirt over his head, and went down and slowly played with his nipples with his tongue. Finn brushed his fingers through Jesse's hair. It wasn't long before Jesse slowly started to make his way down Finn's stomach to just above his waistband. He slid his hands below the waistline and felt Finn's trimmed pubes. He unbuttoned Finn's pants and pulled down his jeans and boxers, exposing Finn's nine inch monster. This wasn't the first time Jesse has seen it, but this time he was actually nervous about the size. There was no way that he was going to be able to fit all of that in his mouth, but that wasn't going to stop him from trying.
Jesse took a breath and went as far down as he could on Finn's cock. This was the first cock he's ever sucked, but after years of vocal training, he was able to loosen his jaw and relax his throat muscles. He felt some accomplishment, getting more than half way down on the first try. He slowly slid his mouth back up the shaft and went back down again. Only this time he went a lot further, pressing his nose against Finn's abdomen. He let the cock linger in his mouth, breathing through his nose. Finn grabbed on to Jesse's ears, encouraging him to continue. Jesse finally slowly slid back up the shaft again, then proceeded to lick the tip of Finn's cock.
Jesse licked his way down to Finn's balls. He played with them with his tongue, while he jacked off Finn's huge dick. Jesse left the balls quickly, and shoved the cock back in his mouth, working it in and out. Finn didn't want Jesse to feel like he was doing all of the work for nothing, so he quickly pulled him up and engaged in a deep kiss. He could taste his own precum in Jesse's mouth.
Finn started to pull up Jesse's shirt, exposing his smooth chest and abs. He lowered Jesse's pants, leaving him in just his briefs that looked like they were about to rip from Jesse's extremely hard cock. Jesse couldn't believe how hard it felt, and as soon as Finn freed it, it bounced right into full attention position.
"I'm glad I freed this thing," Finn said, while groping the cock. He wasted no time, and instantly shoved the cock in his mouth. Finn was amazed how much different it was sucking Jesse's cock then Azimio's in the locker room. This time it was if he wanted to make Jesse cum, not just try sucking cock. He worked his mouth all over the seven inch cock. Jesse has had a few girls give him blow jobs, but never with this much enthusiasm. It was as if Finn was trying to make him cum right then, and if Finn kept it up, he would.
"Woah Finn, slow down there, unless you want me to cum right now," Jesse said, while pulling Finn's face off of his cock.
"I'm sorry, I just am loving your dick," Finn said, while going right back down on Jesse. Jesse was really trying to prolong the blowjob, but Jesse was just too horned up. "I'm going to cum," Jesse warned, expecting Finn to pull off. Finn remembered how he tried to swallow cum already, but this time he was more prepared. As soon as Jesse started erupting into Finn's mouth, Finn opened up his throat and swallowed the eight loads Jesse shot in his mouth. As soon as Jesse finished, Puck sucked all the way back up Jesse's shaft, licking the head for any leftover cum he may have had.
"Damn," Jesse whispered, as Finn made his way up to kiss Jesse again. The two explored each other's mouth with the taste of Jesse's cum being shared between them.
"Let me finish you off," Jesse whispered in Finn's ear while lowering his head.
"Actually, I really want to be inside of you," Finn said, while pulling Jesse back up, and grabbing his ass. Jesse instantly knew what Finn meant, but wasn't sure if he was ready to try that. Finn could sense Jesse's hesitation, but was really wanting to try it.
"I'll be gentle, I promise," Finn said, already turning Jesse around on the couch. Finn spit on his fingers, and started to press them against Jesse's hole. Finn slipped them in, causing Jesse to moan. Finn slowly worked his fingers in and out, until he had all four in the hole. He got some more saliva on his dick, and pressed it against the hole. Jesse instantly felt a major difference between fingers and Finn's cock. Finn noticed Jesse's whole body tense up.
"Relax, it will feel good. I promise," Finn reassured his lover, as he slowly stuck his cock head into Jesse's ass. Jesse winced in pain, but tried to remain as relaxed as possible. Finn let his cock stay in a while, before he tried to inch it deeper inside. Jesse was a natural bottom, and it wasn't long before he was actually enjoying Finn's cock inside of him.
Jesse moaned, a little more loudly this time. Finn took that as a sign that he was finally loosening up and enjoying it more. Finn reached down and pulled Jesse's head around and up toward his. The two kissed while Finn fucked. Finn never felt closer to anyone, and instantly knew that this is what real love making was like. As he shoved his tongue in Jesse's mouth, he started shooting his load in Jesse's ass.
Finn pulled his mouth away, "Sorry I didn't last too long. You jus turn me on too much."
"It's okay, how about we get cleaned up, then something to eat, and try it again?" Jesse said, while standing up.
Finn liked the idea of that.
************** I hoped you guys liked it! Sorry it took so long.