I got a lot of responses from my last story, and I'm planning on writing more of this if there continues to be interest. Let me know what you want to see. Feel free to email any comments to qcummings@live.com
Standard disclaimers apply. If you aren't allowed to read sexually explicit gay materials, don't read this. Also, in real life always use protection, even if the guys in my stories don't. This story is fictional, and should not be interpreted as anything but fantasy.
Almost a week had passed since the night when Finn fucked Will in the glee room, and Will couldn't stop thinking about the football stud's long, meaty cock, and how good it felt buried deep in his ass. He wanted another chance to fuck, but it just wasn't working out. Rachel had somehow heard through the grapevine that Finn was getting after-school lessons from Mr. Schuester, and promptly demanded that she be included as well. That really drained the privacy out of the private sessions, and neither Will nor Finn had enough time (or a good excuse) to sneak off together on any other night.
But now it was the weekend, and Will's wife, Terri, had decided to treat herself to a maternity-clothes shopping spree at an outlet mall on the other side of the state. Will managed to get out of it by saying he had a lot of homework to grade, but he didn't really have any. He just wanted a break from her, and got hard just thinking about getting another shot at Finn's gorgeous meat. He texted Finn the following:
"Nothing to do this weekend. Come over for some lessons at 1pm."
Finn texted back to ask for directions, and Will sent back his address. It was noon, so Will had an hour before Finn would show up.While he waited, he grabbed a locked cash box that he kept in his closet (he said it was for fundraisers, but his wife had long since forgotten all about it–she wasn't interested in old things). He took the box into their modestly-sized living room and placed it on the coffee table. Their home was furnished mostly in the style that Terri liked: somewhat traditional, but with a tragically gaudy and ostentatious flair. The couch and armchairs were adorned with matronly floral patterns, but were overstuffed in a misguided attempt match current trends. The coffee table was ornate, but cheaply made. The overall effect was that of a carefully, but poorly, curated showroom. They didn't really do much "living" in the living room, just watched TV when they had time (which for Will was not often).
Will unlocked the box and pulled out a porn DVD. He opened up the faux-antique wardrobe they used as an entertainment center, inserted the disc in the player, and sat down on the couch. He sank down in a bit into the huge cushions, and pulled his t-shirt up over his head and tossed it to the side. Next, he unbuckled his belt and unzipped his jeans. He lifted his butt and slid the pants down past his round cheeks and firm legs, then kicked them off onto the floor, leaving him sitting there in just his tight fitting boxer briefs. He was half-hard, and his dick was growing quickly with anticipation, both for the porno he was about to watch, and for another ride on Finn's stiff pole. The thought of Finn's cock made his asshole twitch, and he rubbed his pucker through his underwear, pressing his middle finger hard against his tight hole, imagining the fucking he was going to get as soon as Finn arrived. He pressed play on the remote to get the video started and started stroking his now-hard cock through his boxer briefs.
The porno was a gay one called "Exxxtra Credit" that he'd picked up a few years ago to satisfy a burgeoning curiosity for man on man sex. Needless to say, his curiosity blossomed into desire, and led him to seek out a little cock and ass on the side, when his wife wasn't around. The plot (as always) was ludicrous: a suspiciously old-looking "teenager" asks his math teacher after class if there is any way he can improve his grades in the class. The teacher looks him up and down and asks if the boy can help him measure something big, then he comes out from behind his desk and squeezes the bulging cock in his pants. The cheesy background music begins, and they go at it furiously in the classroom. Will had seen it a hundred times or more, but it never failed to get him off.
He watched the teacher on the screen bend the student over his desk and start rimming the boy's hot hole. Will stroked himself and massaged his balls through the fabric of his boxer briefs. The head of his hard cock was leaking a bit of precum, which was just beginning to soak through and form a wet spot. He shifted his attention from his balls back to his asshole, watching the porn teacher's tongue fucking the other guy's hole and imagining that his finger was Finn's tongue lapping against his rosebud. He pushed his finger hard against his hole and groaned as it pushed in a tiny bit, rubbing the fabric of his underwear roughly against his sensitive hole. His cock pulsed, and the wet spot at the tip of his cock grew larger.
Will then slipped his boxer briefs off and spit in his hand for lube, then started stroking his cock while the porn teacher's cock disappeared into tight ring at the center of his student's luscious bubble butt. As he watched the fucking on screen, Will was re-playing his first fuck with Finn, remembering how full he felt as Finn fucked him on his back on his desk. God, it had felt good. He imagined how hot Finn's tight ass would feel around his cock. He wished the boy had some interest in getting his ass fucked. Nobody had ever complained after getting a good fucking from him. And hell, Finn loved having his ass eaten... maybe it was only a matter of time before he could convince him he'd enjoy it.
In the meantime though, Will was perfectly happy to be pounded by the young stud. He grabbed a butt plug and a small bottle of lube from the box and lubed up his ass and the toy. The plug wasn't too long, but was pretty wide at the base. Even at its widest point it wasn't as wide as Finn's schlong, but it was close. He began pushing the cock-like toy into himself, groaning as it stretched his sphincter open furhter and further as he pushed it into place. By now the teacher in the porno had his student on the ground on all fours and was fucking him doggy style at a rapid pace. Both men were grunting and panting and Will could hear the teacher's skin slap, slap, slapping against the boy's ass as he long-dicked him. Will groaned as he felt the wide base of the plug pop into his hole. He didn't want to waste any time when Finn got there. He wanted him to be able to shove his entire meat deep into him in one hard thrust. His cock twitched with anticipation, and a trickle of precum oozed out of the slit. He stroked his cock to milk a little more out as he watched the teacher in the porno spraying his cum all over his student's back.
Then the doorbell rang.
"Coming!" Will yelled, then stood up and sped to the front door in the next room, his hard dripping cock bouncing as he ran. He opened the door and his lungs lept out of his body. It was Puck. "Fuck! What the hell are you doing here?!" yelled Will, as he attempted to cover his cock with one hand and pulled Puck into the house with the other so he could close the door before anyone else saw him.
Puck looked Will up and down, raised his eyebrow and gave a sly smirk. "Gee, Mr. Schue, you seem really happy to see me."
"Puck. I'm going to ask you one more time. WHAT are you doing here? It'd better be good, or you need to leave. Now." Will couldn't hear any moaning from the next room, and was thankful that Puck had arrived just as the scene was ending. Now he just needed to get rid of him before the next one started.
Puck was a good friend of Finn's. They were both on the football team and both in glee club. He was a little shorter than Finn, but he more than made up for that with bravado. He was the kind of guy who could pull off a mohawk with ease. He'd made it known around school that he fucked a lot of older women, a habit he fell into when he started cleaning pools for wealthy families around town. Finn may have been a virgin until he'd fucked Mr. Schuester's ass earlier that week, but Puck was well experienced in the ways of sex. It had been a few weeks since he'd fucked any pussy, and that was the longest he'd gone in years. He'd never done anything with a guy before, but he needed someone to fuck.
"I saw you and Finn in the glee room." Puck said.
"I don't know what you're talking about." said Will, trying to play dumb.
Puck snickered. "Right. You just forgot the hard ass pounding he gave you on top of your desk. Look. I'm really fucking horny, and none of my girls will put out, so here's what's gonna happen: you're going to let me fuck you, and in exchange, I won't tell anyone you're fucking your students." Puck squeezed the outline of his hardening cock, and Will could see that it was long and thick.
"Puck, you need to leave right now and never come back."
"If I leave now, I'm texting your wife about your little fuck session with Finn. You really shouldn't leave your phone lying around unlocked in public places."
Will knew he was cornered. He couldn't let his wife, or anyone else, find out about this. She'd leave him for sure, and he'd lose his job. He'd lose everything he'd worked for his entire life.
"Fine," Will said. "But not today. You need to leave now, and we'll work out a time later. After school."
"No dice, Mr. Schue." said Puck. "I'm horny now. I need to get this in your ass right now. If I have to leave without dumping a load in you, all deals are off." Puck undid his buckle and started unbuttoning his button-fly jeans one button at a time while looking Will directly in the eyes with one eyebrow cocked. Will could see his bushy pubes, and realized he wasn't wearing any underwear. "We got a deal, Mr. Schue?"
Will sighed and his shoulders drooped. He no longer bothered to hide his now-deflating cock. He knew he didn't have a choice. "Fine Puck, I'll let you fuck me, but you have to leave me alone after today. And you can't tell ANYONE about any of this."
"That's what I said, isn't it?" teased Puck. He winked at Will and stepped a little closer to him. Puck finished unbuttoning his fly, and now Will could see the thick root of his thick cock amid the untrimmed patch of hair. Puck reached in and hefted his cock and balls out of his pants. The long shaft drooped down in an arc over his heavy balls. His cock looked about 8 inches, and was as thick as a Coke bottle. He was also uncut, which surprised Will.
"I thought you were Jewish, Puck." said Will as he gawked at the piece before him.
"Eh. We're not too strict about it in my family." Said Puck, and he shrugged. "So, where do you want to be when I fuck this monster into your ass, Mr. Schue?" he asked "I could just bang you right here, up against the front door. Or maybe you'd prefer a long slow fuck in your bed?" Puck was clearly enjoying the control he had over the situation. Then he heard what sounded like a moan from the next room. "Huh, sounds like you've already got someone in here." he said, as he walked past Will and into the next room. Immediately, he saw the porno playing on the TV. The scene that was now playing took place in a stark-looking room with a small twin-size bed and some posters of beer and scantily-clad women. It was supposed to look like a dorm room, and the guys on the bed were supposed to be freshman roommates who had met a few minutes ago. Now one was lying back on the bed while the other worked his ass up and down his new friend's long, thick pole.
"No wonder your cock's been dripping. This is fucking hot Mr. Schue! And I don't even like guys!" said Puck as he pulled his tight t-shirt off over his head, revealing his tight six-pack abs, and finely chiseled pecs. Will's cock started to throb and expand again to its full size. "Stop staring and get over here so I can fuck you!" said Puck.
Will walked over hesitantly, just now remembering that his ass was already plugged with the toy. But before he could do anything to take it out, Puck walked up behind him, bent him forward with a shove, and tried to shove his cock into his teacher's hole. His cock hit hard plastic, and he jumped back.
"OW! Fuck man! You are one sick fuck!" yelled Puck, and yanked the plug out of Will's ass. "Looks like you've been dying to get your ass fucked again, eh? Hope you like my fat Jewish cock filling you up as much as you like that toy."
Puck didn't bother to take his jeans off, he just pressed the head of his wide cock against Will's loose hole, and groaned as he felt it slip past the sphincter with a slight "pop." He was a lot thicker than the plug, and Will could tell he was thicker than Finn too, so even though Will's ass wasn't exactly tight, it felt like he was being torn apart by the girth of Puck's massive dick.
"Oh, fuck yeah. Your ass is so much tighter than the MILF pussy I usually get." he said as he bucked his hips forward and tried to thrust his cock in further, but it was too thick.
Will winced and yelled "Damnit, Puck! Get some fucking lube if you're going to fuck me with that thing!" He pointed to the lube in the little box.
Puck pulled his cockhead out, leaned over to the table to grab the bottle of lube and poured a stream of the stuff all over his cock. He rubbed it in with a few strokes, then lined his glistening hard cock back up with Mr. Schue's hole. "Ready?" he asked.
Will braced himself on the arm of the overstuffed easy chair he was now bent over. "Go for it." he said.
This time when Puck thrust forward he felt his shaft sink into Will's ass. "Unnghhhh FUCK! So fucking tight, Mr. Schue!" His cock didn't sink in all the way, but at least 4 thick inches of his meat were now buried inside of Will's ass. Puck loved the feeling, and he immediately began pounding his cock in and out of Will's ass. He was fucking him hard, trying to force as much of his thick cock into his teacher's ass as he could. Will was wincing at the girth of Puck's cock, but despite the slight pain, he loved the feeling of the big hard cock ramming into him, opening him up like never before, not that he was going to admit that to Puck. Still, he couldn't help but moan quietly as he felt Puck's meat pistoning into him.
Puck felt his cock sink in and force its way past some other barrier deep inside Will's ass, and he groaned as his shaft slid home and his pelvis pressed tight against Will's bubble ass. "Unnghhh! Fuck, Mr. Schue! You like me fucking you with my whole cock? You fucking like that?" Will could feel Puck's foreskin sliding inside his ass as the boy kept on deep-dicking him, harder and faster with each thrust.
Then the doorbell rang again.
"Fuck! Shit!" yelled Will. Puck started fucking Will even faster, determined to empty his cum into the teacher's ass, and worried that whoever was at the door would prevent him from getting off.
After a moment, Will heard the door click open, and Finn's voice ask hesitantly "Mr. Schue? It's me, Finn." Then Finn rounded the corner and saw his best friend Puck with his huge rod buried deep in Mr. Schuester's ass and fucking him hard over the edge of the easy chair. Behind them, he saw more sex. The "roommate" who'd been getting fucked was now fucking his roommate sideways at the edge of the bed. Finn's jaw dropped. "Puck?! Mr. Schue?! What the?!"
Puck didn't slow his pace. He grabbed Will's shoulders to hold him in place as he slammed his cock in to the base over and over again. His balls were slapping against the round firm cheeks of Will's ass, and the sound of it filled the room. "Unnngh! Yeah!" grunted Puck. He looked over at Fin, but he kept plugging Mr. Schuester. "Damn, Unnghh... FUCK! I'm no homo man, but this feels fucking amazing! So... fucking... tight! UNNGHH" And with that, Puck began to shoot thick ropes of cum into Will's ass. "UNNGHHH! FUCK! Take that load, Mr. Schue! UNNGHH FUCK!"
Finn just stared with his mouth agape as Puck pumped his load deep into Will's ass, still not slowing down the speed of his fucking. He couldn't believe how thick his cock was. It looked like he was ramming a tree trunk into Will's hole. Not a drip of cum could escape while it was it was still inside him. As Puck's cock started to deflate, he stepped back and slid his dick out of Will's ass, releasing a trickle of cum that dripped down onto the teacher's balls.
"Damn! It feels good to finally bust a nut. Y'know what I mean, Finn?" Puck winked at his friend who was still too shocked to speak, and slapped Will on the ass cheek. Puck's cock, now only semi-hard was still a thick 5 inches, and the head was now hidden by his foreskin. Finn had never actually seen Puck's cock, because of the partitions between showers in the locker room. It was the first uncut cock he'd ever seen, and he couldn't pull his eyes away.
"Dude, it's just a fucking cock. Now stop staring at me and take a turn on his ass. It's not like it'd be the first time you've fucked him anyway" sneered Puck.
Will turned around and stood up. "No, Puck. You got what you asked for and it's time for you to leave. I'm not a toy, and I won't take any more abuse from you."
In the porno, one of the "roommates" had just finished shooting his was all over his buddy's face, and a new scene was starting. It looked like it took place at a frat house during some kind of raucous party.
Puck looked down at Will's cock and saw that it was still rock hard and wet with precum. "Abuse? Looks like you fucking loved the pounding I gave you." said Puck, grabbing Will's cock and starting to stroke it.
"Ohhh, fuck!" moaned Mr. Schuester, "You've gotta stop or I'll shoot! Not yet, it's too soon!"
Puck stopped. "Too soon for what?" he raised one eyebrow and looked sidelong at Finn. Suddenly he realized what was going on. "Fuck! You guys were gonna fuck again, weren't you?! That porno was just your warm up, wasn't it?! Well, don't let me stop you boys. Go ahead and fuck! I won't make a peep. I promise." he said with a slight smirk.
Finn spoke up. "Mr. Schue... I wouldn't mind if he watched. I've been thinking about you all week, and all I want to do is get my dick back inside you. I don't think I can wait another week until next weekend. Plus, I've always thought it'd be kind of hot to have sex with someone else in the room."
Will had been waiting all week for Finn to fuck him again. His cock was huge, and he was still dying to get it in him again. He didn't want to give Puck the satisfaction after he'd blackmailed him, but he couldn't turn down such a hot offer either. "I can't believe I'm saying this... but fine, you can fuck me, and Puck can stay and watch if he wants. Finn, you'd better get your clothes off and get over here before I change my mind."
Finn was just wearing sweatpants and a tank top, and he slipped them off in an instant and spit on his cock for lube. Will laid back on the overstuffed couch and spread his legs so his ass was right at the edge. Finn propped Will's feet up on his shoulders and put his huge, hard cock in position. "Ready, Mr. Schue?" he asked.
"Finn, what do you think? Get that dick in me!" said Will.
With that bit of encouragement Finn pushed his cock in through Will's sloppy wet ass ring. After getting fucked by Puck's thick cock, Will's ass wasn't nearly as tight as Finn remembered, and this time his pole slid in to the hilt with little resistance. "Awww, fuck that feels good! Ugh!" moaned Finn as his pelvis slammed against Will's ass. He started thrusting in and out of the hot, slippery hole, lubricated by a load of his best friend's spunk. Will was grunting and pushing his ass against Finn's cock. His own cock was slapping against his taut stomach with each thrust, and oozing a steady stream of shiny precum.
Puck was getting hard again, and started stroking his cock with both hands. His foreskin slipped back and forth over the head of his meat and he moaned as he watched the muscles in Finn's butt flex as he thrust his thick long pole into Will's ass. Puck didn't like to apply labels to himself. He thought of himself as simply sexual. He wasn't one to turn down a hot fuck or a hot show. And this definitely qualified.
Finn was getting into his fucking, and he leaned forward so he was almost parallel with Will. It had been almost a week, and though he'd been jerking off every day, the excitement of getting to fuck Mr. Schue again meant Finn wasn't going to last long before he blew his wad. He could feel his orgasm building at the base of his cock, and he starting pistoning in and out of his teacher's ass as fast as he could. "Unnghhh! Fuck! Mr. Schue! Feels... so... good... UNNGHHH fucking you!"
Will grabbed onto Finn's ass cheeks and pulled him deeper into his ass each time he thrust his cock into him. Finn's cock was rubbing against his prostate with each thrust, and the deeper he fucked, the better it felt. Puck's fuck was great, but his cock couldn't hit the spot like Finn's did. Maybe it had something to do with Finn's bulbous mushroom head. Or maybe their cocks just curved a little differently.
Suddenly, Finn threw his head back and moaned, "Unnghhh! I'm cumming! Oh, fuck! Awwww, yeah!" He slammed his hips into Will and held his prick deep inside Will ass as he unleashed a flood of hot cum into him. He held his cock deep inside until it stopped pulsing with pleasure, then he relaxed and collapsed on top of Mr. Schue, whose legs were still propped up on his shoulders. After resting a few moments, Finn stood up and his cock slipped out of Will's ass, still hard and glistening with cum and sweat.
Puck was now sitting in the easy chair he'd bent Will over earlier, his legs spread wide. His cock was pointing straight up, and he was stroking it with both hands using spit for lube, occasionally pulling the foreskin down with one hand and rubbing the sensitive purple head with the slick palm of the other hand. He was so into this that he didn't notice Finn's loud orgasm. He got close to the edge, but stopped short. When he opened his eyes he was surprised to see Will and Finn sitting next to each other on the couch across from him, staring at his cock and body and stroking each other's wet cocks.
"Fuck, can't a guy get a little privacy while he's beating his meat?" Puck joked. He grabbed his stiffy at the base and slapped it around on his tight abs. "One of you guys wanna come suck another load out of this?"
Will and Finn looked at each other, still pumping each other's cocks. Will gasped and pushed Finn's hand away. He was getting close again. He stood up and walked over to Puck, kneeling down between his legs. "I bet you don't have any cum left in you after the way you filled my ass." he said.
"Wanna bet?" taunted Puck, then he pulled Mr. Shuester's head toward his crotch by the hair. Will grabbed Puck's shaft near the base and opened his mouth wide. His lips pushed Puck's foreskin back with as his warm mouth engulfed the stud's engorged head. Puck's dick stretched Will's mouth wide, and he could only get the head and an inch or so of the shaft in. Luckily, this didn't bother Puck at all.
"Awww, damn! That's almost as good as your ass! Awww, fuck!" Puck groaned. He was writhing in pleasure as Will stroked his tongue against the sensitive underside of his cock. He grabbed on to the back of Will's head and began bucking his hips so his shaft was pumping back and forth through Will's hand and his cock head was popping in and out of Will's mouth. His eyes were shut tight, and he was grunting loudly with each thrust into Will's fist and mouth. Will's cock was dripping pre-cum in a puddle at the foot of the chair.
Finn was stroking his cock and watching the blowjob and the porno on the TV, in which a group of seven frat boys had pulled off each other's togas during the middle of a party and proceeded to fuck each other like something out of the kama sutra. He got some inspiration from a guy who straddled another guy who was lying on his back on a beer pong table, and feed his dick to him. The guy just sat on the other guy's chest and fucked his dick in and out of his mouth. Finn looked back to Will and Puck. Puck's eyes were still clamped shut with pleasure, so Finn hopped up quietly from the couch and as quickly as he could he climbed onto the chair and straddled Puck's chest.
Puck opened his eyes to see a thick pillar of quarterback cock waving in front of his face. Finn's balls were heavy, and they hung down below his pulsing wet cock. Puck didn't think twice, he just opened his mouth wide to accept Finn's hefty meat. "Ohhh, fuck yeah! Suck it, Puck!" yelled Finn, and he started thrusting his cock in and out of Puck's inexperienced but talented mouth. Puck's lips wrapped tight around Finn's huge cock and he moaned as he felt the fat head of it slam into the roof of his mouth with each pump of Finn's pelvis. Puck remembered how hot Finn's ass was when he was fucking Mr. Schue on the couch, so he grabbed a hold of his firm, tight ass cheeks, one in each hand. He could feel the muscles flexing in his palms as he pulled Finn's cock deeper into his mouth.
"Unnngh! Puck, you sure know how to suck a fucking dick!" yelled Finn. He was so turned on by watching his huge cock pumping in and out of Puck's mouth. Puck was taking about half the length of it, but it kept slamming against the back of his mouth instead of sliding down his throat. Finn didn't know how to get it deeper into Puck's throat, and he didn't really care. The pleasure from this alone was going to set him off any minute.
Will was still working Puck's cock head with his mouth and stroking up and down his shaft with one hand. He figured with Finn sitting on Puck's chest, it was a perfect chance to test his limits. He pulled off of Finn's cock for just a moment to grab the bottle of lube. Finn and Puck were too worked up with their blowjob to notice. Puck groaned into the mouthful of cock Finn was feeding him when Mr. Schue took his cock back into his mouth. While Will sucked and stroked the teenage cock in front of him, he also lubed the fingers on his free hand, and then slid his middle finger behind Puck's ballsac and probed gently until he found the warm, tight rosebud.
"Unnghhrhr ffmmmuucmmmkckmm UUNGNGHHH!" grunted Puck as Will's pressed against his virgin hole and slipped in ever-so-slightly, just the tip. Puck groaned loudly. He spread his legs wider apart to give Will better access, and he started pushing his ass against him, forcing Will's finger further and further into his warm hole. Clearly, he was enjoying the sensation, so Will thrust his finger in all the way to the knuckle. Puck gave a muffled yell and pulled back momentarily, but as Will persistently finger fucked him, all pain faded into pleasure, and Puck was soon bucking his ass onto Will's finger again.
Will kept sucking at Puck's purple head and licking around the rim of it while his finger rubbed against Puck's prostate with each penetration of his finger, sending shockwaves of pleasure through Puck's body. It was only moments before Puck let out a wild cry. Will felt the thick head of Puck's cock swell in his mouth, then felt six hot ropes of cum pump through the pulsing shaft and splatter against the back of his mouth. Puck didn't slow down as he unloaded down Will's throat. He kept bucking away, fucking Will's mouth and being finger fucked. As the last of his cum drained out, Puck felt more relaxed than he ever had before. "What a fucking hot orgasm," he thought to himself. Finn was still fucking away at his mouth, and the scene that had just unfolded nearly pushed him over the edge.
Will sucked the last bit of jizz out of Puck's softening cock, then let the thick slab of meat flop out of his mouth. He looked up, and from his position, all he could see was Puck's hands grabbing Finn's perfect ass cheeks, pulling them apart slightly to reveal the dark puckered ring of his asshole, and below that his heavy, low-hanging balls swinging with each thrust. Will could tell from Finn's moans and grunts that he was right on the edge of shooting his second load of the day right down Puck's throat, and he wanted to be a part of it. So, he moved closer and in one graceful motion buried his face between Finn's spread cheeks and burrowed his tongue deep into his virgin hole, lapping and thrusting into the warm, sweaty trench.
Finn yelp with surprise, and by reflex he hefted his pelvis forward, away from the intrusion. This motion thrust his cock hard into Puck's mouth, and he threw his head back as he felt the flared head of his cock pop into Puck's throat, and the rest of his cock slide home. "UnnnNGHH! FUCK! Holy shit! Fuck, yeah!" yelled Finn as his cock bottomed out in the back of Puck's throat. He pulled it out so only the flared tip was still in his mouth, then started pumping the whole length in and out. Finn's balls slapped against Puck's chin with each thrust, and each time he pulled out, he felt Will's tongue drill deeper into his ass.
He didn't last long with all that stimulation. "Oh fuck! Oh fuck! FUUUUUCK! UNNNGHHNNGGHH" Finn groaned as his cock started pumping a river of cum into Puck's mouth. Will felt Finn's hole clenching and spasming on his tongue, and he kept probing his hot, sloppy hole until his moaning and bucking subsided, and he collapsed onto Puck. Puck swallowed furiously, and not a drop escaped. He stroked Finn's shaft, and squeezed every last drop out and onto his tongue.
After a moment's rest, Finn got up, his quickly softening cock still drooped down at least 5 inches, and it was now slick with Puck's saliva. He said, "Mr. Schue, that was fucking awesome! Woah, you really leak a lot of juice..." Finn looked at the puddle on the floor below Will's cock, which was still oozing and dripping pre-cum all over. Will was still kneeling, but he was sitting back on his feet, and his prick was pointing straight up and bobbing up and down as blood continued to pulse through it.
"Fuck, you guys are so hot!" said Will, slowly stroking his cock, being careful not to get too close to cumming. "But I think it's about time I got some help with this." He squeezed his cock at the root and waved it around, flinging precum all about.
Puck and Finn looked at each other. Finn said "I guess if getting fucked feels as good as having your tongue up my ass, I'll try it out."
A sly smile spread across Will's face and he said, "Trust me, Finn. It'll feel even better than that."
Puck smirked and raised one eyebrow. "Hell, that finger fucking felt pretty fucking good too. If you're gonna fuck him, you've gotta fuck me too."
Will stood up and looked at the two naked, sweat-sheened jocks before him, Finn standing, and Puck still in the chair with his legs spread wide apart and his soft, uncut cock draped over his balls. "I'd be happy to oblige you both. Go kneel on the couch with your asses in the air."
Puck hefted himself out of the chair and he and Finn walked over and did as Will asked, displaying their asses for him. Will smiled at the sight of their firm, athletic asses waiting side by side on the couch for him. He wasted no time, and was soon on his knees eating out Puck's hole and rubbing his middle finger in circles against Finn's. Both boys were moaning and writhing, and he managed to press his finger two knuckles deep in Finn's ass before he couldn't wait any longer.
Will stood up grabbed the lube, then slathered some on his slender 7-incher, then fingered some into Puck's tight hole. "You ready for this?" Will asked, then leaned forward and rubbed the rosy head of his cock in circles at the opening of Puck's chute.
"Ohhh, fuck yeah Mr. Schue." said Puck, his head thrown back and his eyes closed. He groaned as he felt Mr. Schuester's warm member slowly, but easily sliding into him. Will wasn't pumping it in and out, he was just slowly leaning toward Puck's body and watching his cock sink inch by inch into the jock's virgin hole. When he bottomed out inside of him, Will leaned forward, pressing his chest against Puck's back and wrapped his arms around Puck's torso. Then he ground his pelvis hard against puck's plump ass, drilling his long cock as deep into Puck's warm crevasse as he could.
"Unnghhh! FUCK!" yelled Puck. "Finn, you're gonna love this shit!"
Will slid his cock out so just the tip was still inside, causing Puck to groan. Then he thrust forward, burying his shaft to the hilt and eliciting another loud groan from Puck. He pumped in and out a few times, relishing the way Puck's hole clenched tight on his hard shaft as he fucked. Then without warning, he slipped his slick cock all the way out. "Looks like you're warmed up." he said, picking up the lube and squirting some into the palm of his hand. "I think it's time for Finn to get some cock in that ass of his."
Will slicked lube all over his cock, paying special attention to the head so it wouldn't hurt for Finn's first fuck. Then he applied some to Finn's puckered rosebud and lined himself up for entry. Puck sat up, so he was kneeling upright, and craned his neck to watch as Will pulled Finn onto his cock by the waist. He didn't push in at all, but Finn pushed back and groaned as the head slipped past his tight sphincter "OHHH fuck, Mr. Schue!"
Will stopped pulling Finn onto his cock for a minutes to let Finn get used to having his hot, hard cock in his anus, even though it was just the head so far. But Finn didn't wait long before he was ready for more. He slid back, and groaned as he felt Will's slick, slender pole prodding deeper and deeper inside of him. "You're almost there Finn," said Will encouragingly. "Just a couple more inches and I'll have my whole cock up your ass."
"Fuck, this is hot." said Puck, who then reached under Finn and squeezed his hefty cock. He stroked it slowly as he watched Finn press himself all the way down on Mr. Schuester's cock, until their teacher's pubes were pressed against the quarterback's tight cheeks. Will then started slowly fucking Finn, allowing himself to pull out only slightly at first, but longer and longer with each stroke until he was steadily deep-dicking him, his balls slapping skin each time his willowy dick buried itself inside him.
Still fucking Finn, who now had a glazed look of sheer ecstasy on his face, Will looked over at Puck. "If you want any more of this, you need to get back down." Puck stopped stroking Finn's cock and got back into position, wiggling his bare ass enticingly. He looked over his shoulder at Will and mouthed "Fuck. Me."
Will popped his dick out of Fin, then sidestepped over to Puck an d shoved it all the way inside him in one hard thrust. "Unnngh! FUCK!" shouted Puck, who hadn't expected him to be so rough. Will then grabbed onto Puck's hips and started pulling him back on his cock while he slammed it deep into him. "Ohhhhh fuck yeah,"groaned Will. "Take my fucking cock you punk! You like getting fucked by your fucking teacher?"
"Unnghh... FUCK... fuck yeah! Fuck me, Mr. Schue!" yelled Puck, whose body was now bouncing forward and back in time with Will's thrusts. Will's cock was pounding Puck's prostate, and soon the pleasure shooting through his body was too much. "Ohhhh, FUCK! FUCK! FUUUUUCK!" screamed Puck as a hot sticky blast of cum shot from his cock all over the cushion beneath him. And then another, and another, until the whole couch beneath him was splattered with his juice.
As soon as Puck started to shoot, Will pulled out, afraid that if Puck's tight ass clenched down on him like he thought it was bound to do, he'd shoot his load into him, before he'd gotten a chance to really give Finn a good fucking. While Puck was still groaning and spasming and erupting his milk all over the couch, Will was already inside Finn and fucking away. He plowed him as hard as he'd fucked Puck, watching his own throbbing cock in disbelief as it disappeared into the gorgeous ass of the school quarterback, who was moaning and writhing on his knees right in front of him. In his living room. On his couch. Next to his best friend, whose ass was stretched and whose cum was soaking into his couch cushion.
The warmth of Finn's ass, and the clenching of his tight ass on Will's cock was too much, especially after such a sex-filled afternoon. Will yelled out "UNGNNNHGGHH! UNGH! SHIT! FUCK!" and started jackhammering his cock in and out of Finn's tight hole. "I'm gonna shoot inside you, Finn! FUCK!" he shouted, and Finn felt a gush of warmth inside him as Will's pent-up load blasted with full force into his ass. Will slammed his pelvis into Finn with all the force he could muster and held it there as five, six, seven blasts of cum blasted into Finn's warm, wet, tight hole. Then Will slowly fucked Finn with his softening dick, like he was trying to push his cum deeper and deeper into the boy.
When his dick was finally too soft to keep fucking, Will let it slip out, and saw that Finn had also squirted a load all over the couch. All of them were exhausted now, and they each found a dry spot to sit and relax and absorb all of what had just happened.
"Fuck boys, I'm going to have to get this cleaned before Terri gets home. You'd better get dressed and head home." said Will, standing up.
The boys agreed, and took a quick shower together before getting dressed and heading home. On their way out, Will said "We should do this again sometime. I hope this wasn't a one time thing."
"We'll see," said Puck with a wink.
Finn looked meaningfully at Will and gave a small sideways smile. "See you later Mr. Schue."