When I was in college, we started a Saturday night movie club. It evolved into a recurring event all on its own, not because we planned it that way. We would go out to the late show, the later the better, and then stay out half the night talking at a pub or late-night coffee shop.
We all met as freshmen living in the dorms, but later the guys lived all over the city and the club was a good excuse to get together to hang out. I was one of the core four original members, but we had a bunch of occasional members who would sometimes come and sometimes not. It was all guys, none of whom had a girlfriend. I wasn't out and as far as I knew the rest were all straight, so it was a very hetero boys club. Over time, it became a "thing," with a name ("Magic Shadows") and a loose membership.
One night, an occasional member brought a friend, whose last name was Hargrave, called Hargie. Hargie was short, about 5'6", and baby-faced, he was 21 but could have passed for much younger. He had dirty blond hair, blue eyes, a bad haircut, ears that stuck out, and spindly stick arms and legs. He was generally kind of funny looking. Personality-wise, he was very awkward and desperate to be liked. You could sense that he had been picked on as a kid.
Hargie never became anyone's close friend, but we never told him to stop coming either and he became a regular.
One January night, we carried on with movie night despite a heavy snowfall. There were four of us that showed up to the movie and then everyone came to my apartment to crash, (I lived downtown, so this happened fairly often with the guys who lived in the 'burbs). The two couches filled up first and so I told Hargie he could have a blanket on the floor or share my bed. He chose my bed.
Usually I sleep naked, but since I was sharing a bed I kept by boxers on. Hargie wanted to talk about movies and video games but I wanted to sleep so just uh hunhed and mmhmmed until he finally shut up and I drifted off.
I woke up in the early morning, before the winter sun was up, because I was hot. I was hot because I was big spoon to Hargie, whose naked back was pressed into my bare chest.
This was interesting.
How did we end up like this? Did I initiate it? But I was asleep? Was he aware? Did he object? Was he into it? He seemed sound asleep.
I snuggled in a little tighter and put my hand on his chest. No reaction.
I certainly had a raging boner. Could he feel it? He must be able to feel it pressed against his ass. He must be okay with this.
I let my hand slide down his front across his hairy belly to feel for an erection in his underwear. Nope. But still no reaction.
I got braver and slid my hand inside his boxers to feel his cock. It was soft and uncut and small. I slid the loose skin up and down gently and it started to come to life.
When it was hard, it still wasn't that big, probably 5". But it became clear he was awake and into it. He squirmed and his breathing sped up as I jacked him. I kept going with no let up and he came with a small grunt, clearly trying to be quiet so as not to get caught by the guys on the couches in the living room.
He was still hard as he panted softly, recovering. I still held his dick, gently caressing it.
"Your turn," he said.
I rolled on my back and he flipped over and tugged off my boxers so I was naked. My hard cut 6" was sticking out at a 45 degree angle, begging for attention. To my surprise, he went down on me and sucked me.
It was clearly not his first time. There was no hesitation and he had good technique. He also was savvy enough to back off before I came and switch to licking my balls for awhile. Then he took mercy on me and finished me off, swallowing all my cum and staying on me until I pushed him away. Then he cuddled in close with his head on my chest.
I was kind of blown away by what had just happened and found it hard to process. But I liked it.
We both fell asleep again.
I woke up to the voices of the guys in the living room getting up and Hargie pulling on his clothes beside the bed.
I made everyone breakfast and coffee and sent them all home. Then I jacked myself, reliving the feel of Hargie's cock coming to life as I stroked him and the sensation of his warm, wet mouth on my knob.
Next week, Hargie asked if he could stay over after the movie. I said yes. He was the only one to stay over.
This time at bedtime, there was no discussion required. He followed me into the bedroom and crawled into bed while I was in the bathroom. I got in beside him wearing my boxers and turned out the light.
He was on his side with his back to me and scooted closer. We started spooning and I realized he was naked, so I pulled off my boxers and snuggled in as big spoon, my boner pressed up against his hairy ass crack. He wriggled and squirmed so my cock slipped between his cheeks and my cockhead pushed against his pucker.
To my surprise, he was pre-lubed and my cock slid in him easily. It felt too good. I couldn't help but fuck him and it wasn't very long before I dumped my cum inside him. Then he jacked himself to his own orgasm with my cock still inside him. Then we fell asleep.
In the morning, I fucked him again, this time on his back with his legs on my shoulders. I pounded his ass as hard as I could, which made him howl with pleasure. After I unloaded in his ass, I jacked him so we both got off. We showered separately and he left right after breakfast with no discussion or comment whatsoever. Just a "see you next Saturday."
The next movie night, the same thing happened again. He came home with me, lubed his ass, got in my bed naked and spread his legs for a good, hard fucking. Then round 2 in the morning and he disappeared without a word.
This went on for weeks. One of the other movie night guys, Derek, finally noticed that Hargie was sleeping over at my place every single week and asked why. Don't ask me what made me do it, but I told him the truth. All of it. In detail.
Derek calmly asked if we were boyfriends. I said, I don't think so, just Friends With Benefits. He asked if he can join in. I said sure.
That night, both Hargie and Derek came home with me and we had a 3 some. I didn't talk to Hargie about it ahead of time. He was submissive and I thought he would enjoy being tag-teamed. I was right.
When we entered my apartment, I immediately started stripping off my clothes until I was naked with a boner. Hargie saw what I was doing and followed my lead, although with the extra step of fishing out a tube of grease lube out of his pocket and working it into his furry hole, right in front of us while we watched.
Derek was last to get undressed, but it was a worthwhile show. Derek was a short, blond fit guy with a big nose and a trim, smooth body. He was well-proportioned, except for his boner, which was enormous. It was at least 7" long, thick and uncut, dripping precum. On his small frame, his cock looked even bigger than it really was.
Hargie wasted no time getting his lips around it and sucking it for all he was worth. Derek threw his head back and blissed out. After a minute or Hargie switched to me and it was my turn to be primed.
"Let's go to the bedroom," I said.
Hargie hopped on the bed on all fours and Derek got in front of him to have his cock sucked again. I lined up at the back door and pushed in, spit roasting the boy.
As soon as I came, making plenty of noise, Derek was elbowing me out of the way for his turn. Then he stretched Hargie's hole even bigger, pounding hard until he unloaded in him. Derek never even pulled out after he came, but greedily went and fucked him a second time straight away.
This time it took longer and he could thoroughly enjoy it. Hargie moaned and whimpered under the assault.
When it was over, I rolled Hargie on his back and jacked him back to an erection and right through until he came, which took no time at all. It was a big load too, the first shot hit his chin and the rest splattered all over his chest and belly.
We all needed showers afterwards, so we took turns in the bathroom until everyone was clean and tucked in bed, Hargie in the middle. I turned out the light.
"It's a good thing you two are pint-sized, or I would have to upgrade to a king bed," I joked.
"Fuck off," said Derek.
"With a king, we could get four in here," said Hargie.
"If it's four, does that make it an orgy?" I asked.
"I'm pretty sure," said Derek.
"You can invite more than four if you want," said Hargie.