This is fiction not reality. Please donate to nifty so we can keep writing stories for you all to read.
Rafe brought David to get checked at the hospital. Soon they returned home.
Eli was waiting for them when they got home. Rafe settled David in his bedroom to play with his toys.
Im glad David is back but we need to talk says Eli. Im gonna make him something to eat says Rafe. Eli got handsy and pushed Rafe to a wall you raped me man says Eli. But Rafe cut him off quickly. I didnt, you loved my finger. I added my cock. Sure it hurt but i felt your hole relaxing and quivering on my cock. You were loving it assures Rafe pushing Eli away. Eli knew Rafe was right. But he wasnt gay. He loved Lani. He sure as hell wasnt gonna be someones bottom bitch.
Rafe stops what he's doing. Look, im sorry ok... The way you were fucking Evan. The way your ass looked. The way it tasted. The way it liked my finger. I couldn't help myself. When you said stop i should have but i knew you were confused about everything but your ass was so damn nice on my dick admits Rafe. Eli cant help but smile a little. Please... You cant tell anyone about it ok begs Eli... Im straight assures Eli. Our secret but man... If you ever want to try it again or crave it let me know. Ill gladly help you out promises Rafe. Eli smiles and leaves.
He goes to the station to put Evan in his cell for the night. But Evan had other plans. You already called your lawyer, lets go orders Eli. Evan smiles. I want a piece if what Rafe had earlier says Evan. Evan looks at Eli with a big smirk on his face. I dont know what you mean says Eli, lets go ads Eli. I saw him fucking you... If you don't want the whole damn station and the world to hear it, lock the door and bend over the table now says Evan. Eli swallows the lump that had formed in his throat. Eli locks the door and looks at Evan. Please starts Eli. Dont beg, just shut up and do as I say or else orders Evan. You do this, once your in jail... Watch your backs... I have people who can beat the shit out of you swears Eli. Evan laughs. We both know thats not true says Evan. Take the cuffs off now orders Evan. Eli does. Please man... Im not gay swears Eli. Thats ok... You seemed to like getting fucked by Rafe... Why not me asks Evan? Your a killer, a kidnapper and now a rapist says Eli. But no ones gonna find out right? And besides its not rape if you enjoy it says Evan stroking his already hard cock. Eli snarls. Bend... Over... Now orders Evan getting impatient. Eli slowly and reluctanly does so. Youll regret this i swear says Eli weakly. Evan looks at Elis nice black butt, he smiles. He spreads the cheeks and sees the tiny black hole... Rafes load still in there asks Evan... Y-y-y-yeah says Eli sadly. Evan smiles. Had to keep him inside you huh says Evan. Rafes a great fuck admits Evan before shoving his face in Elis ass and eating it. Making Eli moan and groan uncontrolably. Eli found out that having his ass eaten drove him insane and even more hornier to fuck. His dick was... Leaking precum. After about seven minutes of having his ass eaten did Evan stop and lube his cock with his spit. Please Evan... Dont do this, ill do anything else begs Eli. Evan dosent listen and pushes his cock inside Elis tight fighting hole. Eli wants to scream out in pain but cant. He cant have his co workers/fellow cops or Lani see him with his pants around his ankles and getting butt fucked by a crazy man and a suspect... Murderer... Kidnapper... He looks back at Evans cock... Smaller then Rafes so that was a good thing. Don't do this man begs Eli one las time to deafs ears. Evan ignores Elis pleas and begins to shove his cock inside Elis tight fighting hole... Full of cum... Elis hole was still very sore from Rafes fuck that he could barely take Evans. Fuckkkkkkk groans Eli in pain... Fuck yeah moans Evan as he burries his hole cock inside Elis tight fighting hole... Your ass is still soooo tight and warm... And so wet from Rafes load. He shot such a big load... You had to keep it in you huh asks Evan? Fuck you groans Eli in pain... It fucking hurts cries Eli. Oh shut up stud and take it, you took Rafes, my cock isnt as big as his says Evan. Your ass feels amazing on my dick admits Evan. Eli gritted his teeth together. He couldnt believe he was in this predicament. Evan was right. He did enjoy Rafes cock. And he knew Eli would never say anything and press charges. What would people think of him. He began to think about Rafe and how he had fucked him earlier. Kissing his neck, playing with his nipples fucking him slow... Rafe had prepped him with a rimjob and fingering. Evan only ate his ass a little and didnt use as much spit. His dick began to slowly rise at the thought of Rafes fuck. What was happening to him? After about five minutes of a hard pounding Eli still couldnt take it. It was painful. Evan was just fucking him to humiliate him and hurt him. His dick slowly went down. Images of Rafe flashing through his mind. His body. His big cock. His kisses. His fingers on his nipples. His arms wrapped around him. Fucking him slow and deep. He was quickly brought out of his dream when Evan started battering his ass even harder and deeper causing Eli more pain... Before unloading deep inside Elis ass, mixing along with Rafes cum. He quickly pulls out and gets dressed and sits back on the chair with a big grin on his facs. Eli weakly gets dressed and handcuffs Evan again. You have a really nice ass to fuck says Evan tauntingly. Eli wants to kill Evan but rushes out. He went home and showered and shat all the cum from his hole and man was there a lot... He got dressed and Lani came home. That night they made love. But his hole was still in pain. But he couldnt stop picturing Rafe fucking him as he fucked Lani. Once he came they both drifted off to sleep.He was up early the next morning. He went out for a run. He bumps into Rafe. Sorry man says Rafe. Eli looks at him angrily and runs away. He stops to catch his breath, falls to the floor and cries... A few minutes later Rafe asks him whats wrong. Eli quickly wipes away the tears. Leave me alone orders Eli angrily.
Look man im sorry about what happened ok. I got carried away. I shouldve stopped when you asked me too. But i was so caught up in the moment and by the noises you were making i was so sure you were enjoying it says Rafe honestly. You dont fucking understand. You fucking humiliated me in front of Evan says Eli. And for the life of me i dont understand why... Begins Eli. Understand what asks Rafe. You... When you... Were... Fucking me... It hurt... But then it felt so damn good. Fucking Evan and then your fucking me... Im straight. Im not gay. Why would i... Like it asks Eli confused? Come with me begs Rafe.
When they arrive at Rafes house Eli laid into Rafe straight away. What the hell are we doing here huh? You gonna rape me again asks Eli? Rafe grabs two water bottle from the refrigerator and hands one to Eli. Rafe sits down. Look... Eli... Im sorry ok but we both loved it. I dont want you to hate me, we work together and i need us to be on the same page and not hate each other. I promise it will never happen again promises Rafe. You dont fucking understand yells Eli. Eli... Davids asleep says Rafe. Tears are flowing from Elis eyes. I cant stop thinking about it. When im making love to Lani. I picture you fucking me. I cant stop thinking about it... Am i gay asks Eli? Rafe looks into Elis eyes. No... It dosent... I sleep with men and women but at the end of the day. I love women and will always want to have a wife. I dont take it up the ass but im not gay. And i know some straight men that love it up the ass but at the end of the day go home to their wives or girlfriends says Rafe. You love Lani right asks Rafe? Yes... More than anything swears Eli. Ok then... You want a family with her right asks Rafe? Yes swears Eli. Ok then you answered your question says Rafe. But... Says Eli. But what asks Rafe? Why cant i stop thinking... About you... Fucking me... The way you did... At the police stations asks Eli? Rafe smiles... Maybe... You have an itch that needs to be scratched once in a while that only a man can do says Rafe. I guess says Eli sadly. Look whatever you need... Im here for you ok... And i dont just mean sex, but your ass was so fucking amazing but im your friend and if you need to talk im here... Whatever you need swears Rafe. Eli wipes his tears and hugs Rafe. Thank you says Eli taking his leave. Rafe smiles.As Eli was walking home he bumped into Evan who had been released from police custody. He didnt want to deal with him so he walked right passed him. Evan smiles and whistled as Eli walks away...
Evan runs into his father Orpheous. Why you grinning so much asks Orpheous? Nothing really says Evan. Dont get too cocky now says Orpheous. Im not just somethig unexpected happened today and i have a secret and i can use two someones to get what i want says Evan happily... Orpheous looks at his son... Wondering what he was refering too.
Evan smiles and tells his father everything about what happened between Rafe and Eli...
Thank you so much for reading. I always like comments and feedback. Remember to donate to nifty... Stay tuned... More to cum...