Remember to give money to Nifty! Support the publishing of these stories.
Both Abbey and Brian were turned on, but for very different reasons. Brian was boned thinking what it must be like fucking the Indian boy's virgin ass, having already taken the boy who was topping's, his black teammate, virginity. Abbey was thinking how erotic the two of them looked making love (as opposed to having sex, which was pretty much all he had experienced since creating 'sex club', though there had been the odd erotic and intimate moment).
Abbey had created 'sex club' just for sex. He hadn't been getting sex from his girlfriend (he still wasn't and barely saw her) even though he thought he loved her and he thought he might marry eventually someday after high school and college (she was rich and beautiful and they would have beautiful children together). But since creating 'sex club' he had witnessed his schoolmates being far more intimate and far more intense than he had experienced at the club.
Some of the difference between what Abbey got out of 'sex club' and the others were he knew was his own choice. He was captain of the team, quarterback, a prefect and head boy of the school, he had no desire to let his guard down. What would they think of him if he was seen to swoon like a little girl over one of these boys? He was a man and someone who everyone else looked up to. He was straight, he had the most beautiful girl at the nearby girls' school as his girlfriend and the two of them were the envy of everyone.
But while 'making love' and being intimate and so sensitive in the way he had had just witness Clifford be with Moogash wasn't something he had pictured for himself with a guy he was a little jealous. Clifford was looked up to and was a star football player and a prefect. Did what he had just witnessed make him think any less of his star running back?
The closest Abbey had gotten to being that intimate was with Brian. Which caused him to glance over at Brian, who was leaning against the ping-pong table next to him naked and hard, just like him. Could he imagine himself getting even more sensual and erotic with his centre. They now had both fucked each other. He had taken Brian's cock up his ass three times now and he had cum every time so he was clearly turned on by the sex and by that big cock.
They had been friends before but that hadn't lasted. Brian was competitive and when he had been introduced into having sex with the local girls down the hill Brian was only too eager to show he was the better man because he had a big cock. He was also competitive in school and on the field, even though Abbey was winning by being head boy and captain and quarterback of the team.
Then Abbey began to scroll their recent encounters since they had made up through 'sex club'. That day on the top floor when Brian had expressed his regret at their growing apart and said he actually had feelings for him was probably a lie to get him into bed. He had doubted his sincerity at the time but that big hard cock in front of him and the possibility of fucking his centre had made him go along. In fact, as he reflected on it, Brian had suggested that very first time that he 'could' fuck Abbey if he wanted with that cock. Brian's motivation all along was probably to fuck him. Abbey had to threaten him that day to make him only keep the head of his cock in his ass and jack off so Abbey could experience what it would be like to have the head of such a big cock in his ass. How can you be intimate with someone you can't trust?
At Randy's place it was Randy, who clearly knew Brian had been having sex with him, who was so concerned that Brian would hurt Abbey with his big cock he devised an elaborate plan that including Randy being able to physically stop Brian from thrusting his cock up into his ass. Clearly Randy did think he could be trusted.
When he rode Brian again in front of the others at 'sex club' he knew in advance that Randy and Brian had agreed Brian wouldn't fuck him but just lie there and let him ride his cock and he was still reluctant to do it with everyone watching and Brian having given his word. If Randy hadn't cornered him he probably would have do it that day or ever again.
And what about earlier that day? Brian had started the day trying to convince Abbey to be a bottom and let him finally be the one in control and fuck his ass, something he didn't trust him to do. Brian only offered to be a slave after he had said no and was starting to freak out and consider bolting from the house, feeling cornered and trapped in the guest bedroom by Brian so aggressively hitting on him that morning. Even after offering to be a slave for the day, before the day was done Abbey had let his teammate fuck him. It hadn't been painful (it had actually been pleasurable) though that may have been because it was over fairly quick. What if Brian hadn't cum so close to Abbey's orgasm, would he have kept fucking him? He had seen the way he had been with Jessy and Clifford, he could be rough and uncaring once he started to have sex.
Had Brian been manipulating him all day long just to get him to give up his ass? Had being a slave been just to get his guard down? Brian had fingered his ass while sucking him before moving up and sliding his cock into his ass.
Abbey didn't know if his teammate and 'friend' had manipulated him. He had enough doubts to distrust him. In fact, he found himself getting mad at the thought. He also was a little angry at himself for contemplating letting someone, anyone, especially Brian, make love to him the way Moogash and Clifford had done.
Abbey had a hard cock that needed release and Brian had said he was going to be his slave for the day. He decided that a slave needs to be fucked and he would do that to Brian in a way that he probably deserved.
Abbey grabbed Brian, who was still leaning against the ping-pong table next to him with a hard-on, having watched the 'love-making' while Clifford took Moogash's virginity and now watching the two naked uncut boys cuddle on the floor, and turned him around and bent him over the table.
The two blond boys were evenly matched in size and build, so if Brian resisted this would have ended up in a wrestling match. Unbeknownst to Abbey, Brian was getting into rough sex with Randy and Abbey's sudden aggressiveness was a turn-on. While Brian did have as his goal a desire to fuck his quarterback hard he also liked to be fucked hard himself.
Having showered and gone to the toilet there was no longer lube or cum in Brian's ass. Abbey, not knowing Brian was up for it, didn't want to pause to get lube in case Brian tried to pull away, so he spit on his hand and applied some to his teammate's ass. He did it again for his own cock.
With spit for lube, Abbey shoved his cock hard into his centre's ass.
Brian was a centre and he had spent the season with his ass in Abbey's face ready to hike the ball. This was how Abbey wanted to fuck Brian from behind.
'Try to manipulate me and fuck me' rang through Abbey's mind as he became even more aggressive and began to fuck Brian hard and fast bent over Brian's own ping-pong table in his basement naked.
Abbey was not usually aggressive. He played football which was an aggressive sport, but he was the quarterback. It was a position that involved strategy, quick thinking, finesse and, above all, remaining calm. Emotions were the enemy for a quarterback and he was a good QB because he didn't get rattled, no matter how the game was going. But naked in Brian's basement with his cock in Brian's ass, suspecting that this was all Brian had been interested in all along he was suddenly a slave to his emotions.
Maybe it was the thought that Brian had manipulated him that day and had won by Abbey not stopping him when he had let Brian fuck him. Maybe it was the sight of the two uncut boys having sex that had him so turned-on he couldn't control his baser instinct. Maybe it was the enjoyment he had gotten holding onto Brian's collar when his teammate had been wearing leather, so much pleasure Abbey had put a leash on Brian's collar as they fucked literally 'doggie' that morning. Abbey had no idea but he needed to fuck Brian hard. And Abbey did.
Abbey pounded Brian's ass with suck force his teammate was pushed across and into the rough ping-pong table. Abbey had cum four times already and he was intent on cumming a fifth time but he knew it would be difficult. He needed to go hard just to cum and he wanted to go hard to get back at Brian. He wanted to make Brian feel it.
The savage pounding of Brian's ass went on for a while. Abbey didn't know it but Brian loved it. When he had pushed Brian down his big cock had slid under the table. While the thin ping-pong table was digging into his pubes Brian didn't care, he enjoyed the pain, he liked the domination Abbey was exerting and he loved being fucked for a fourth time that day by his quarterback. In fact, in Brian's competitive mind, he was winning as he had brought out the aggression in Abbey and was getting him to do something he never thought his teammate would do, and that is let down his guard and give into his emotions, giving Brian something he wanted, a rough and primal fucking .
If everyone had been offended by Brian taking Clifford's ass and fucking it without permission and how rough he had been with poor little Jessy, as Randy claimed, what would Clifford and new boy Moogash think of him being fucked this hard by Abbey, their hero. This was a win-win. He was loving it and if it should knock the quarterback down a few points in the other boys' esteem that was just icing on the cake.
It took quite a while of viciously ramming his cock into Brian's ass before Abbey began to cum. When he did he cried out and his whole body tensed. While normally he would shove in and stop and let the orgasm wash over him he kept ramming to him (if he had known that Brian had done the same to him earlier while he had cum the irony would have been lost as he was so caught up in fucking and cumming in Brian's ass). And Abbey never made a sound when he came, and here he was crying out as he kept pounding his cock in and shoot his cum in Brian's ass.
Once the last rope of cum had shot out of his cock, and up his centre's ass, the quarterback yanked his cock out. He was finished and done with Brian and he just pulled out without any thought about Brian and turned and walked away, going over to the couch and dropping down, a little out of breath having fucked Brian so hard and for so long.
Slowly Brian stood upright. His pubes and ass were sore but it had been worth it. He got some fun rough sex, from of all people, reserved controlled Abbey. And he had gotten it in front of Clifford who could no longer blame him for raping his ass. On top of that, Moogash would tell everyone of how rough the quarterback had been, in stark contrast to how gentle Clifford had been with him for his first time.
Turning Brian was disappointed.
There on the cushions Moogash was lying on his back and Clifford was sucking him off. Either they hadn't watched Abbey abuse him or they had found it a turn-on. Either way he hadn't gotten the icing on the cake of damaging Abbey's pristine reputation as the calm trustworthy quarterback and head prefect.
As for the cake, Brian had gotten fucked hard and had gotten four of Abbey's loads up his ass that day. That was something he was happy about. But Brian hadn't cum yet. He desperately wanted release.
Going over to the couch Brian sat next to Abbey. He hoped his big hard-on would attract his teammate, as he knew his teammate liked his big cock. Abbey ignored him and was watching Clifford and Moogash, and catching his breath.
Something about how brutal Abbey had been fucking him Brian suspected he wouldn't care that Brian had not cum yet. So when Abbey made no move to touch his cock, Brian asked pleadingly "would you help get me off?"
Abbey looked for a second at Brian's big cock. He did find it appealing. It was impressive and he had enjoyed it in his ass now three times. But it was attached to Brian and this boy couldn't be trusted and was despicable.
Lifting his head off the cushions Moogash said "I could jack you off and you can cum on my face." It wasn't Brian's ideal choice. He wanted Abbey to get him off because Abbey seemed to be rejecting him after having used him for sex. And a hand job is the lowest on the list of things he liked.
But beggars can't be choosers. Plus, Brian thought, maybe once he starts jacking such an impressive cock he will want to put his mouth around it.
When Abbey made no move to help him get off, Brian got up and walked over and knelt next to Moogash's head and the Indian boy wrapped his hand around Brian big cock and began to jack it.
As Clifford sucked Moogash's cock the Indian boy jacked the other football player. As both boys were boned from having been fucked, Moogash and Brian came within a minute of each other, Brian cumming first so Moogash's face was covered in cum when he shot his load into the black athlete's mouth.
It being close to 11pm Abbey decided to show some leadership.
"Let's get you cleaned up," he said to Moogash, who had Brian's cucm on his face, his own dried cum on his stomach, and Clifford's cum up his ass. Abbey led him up to the second floor guest room, gave him a towel and took him into the bathroom to shower.
Abbey stayed watching him through the shower glass door. This brown boy was hot. Abbey loved looking at his uncut cock. There was no time to do anything with him (especially since he had just cum in Clifford's mouth) but he knew he wanted to soon, maybe at the next 'sex club'. So Abbey simply admired the boy's naked body as he showered.
Moogash found he liked the attention. Normally at school he was self-conscious in the locker-room not being particularly athletic, being Indian, and in the shower being uncut. But he liked the quarterback watching him in the shower.
Moogash thought this had been the best evening of his life. He had lost his virginity, to a football player and schoolmate he thought was cool, and that guy had sucked him off. And he had jacked off Brian's big cock (he even liked Brian had cum all over his face which probably should be demeaning). And now the way the school quarterback was looking at him he suspected he would get to have sex with him. He didn't know what he wanted to do but Moogash knew he would be willing to do anything Abbey wanted.
When Moogash had finished showering and made it back downstairs, Clifford had already dressed and left, needing to be back at school my 11pm. Moogash dressed and left too.
Brian and Abbey turned off the lights and went to their respective rooms. There was a tension between them but neither wanted to figure it out and they definitely didn't want to talk about it. They had a big game the next day.
What Clifford gets up to back at school with his teacher can be found at: http://www.nifty.org/nifty/gay/adult-youth/can-i-fuck-you/can-i-fuck-you-14
NOTE: Nifty needs donations to provide these stories. http://donate.nifty.org/donate.html