Remember to give money to Nifty! Support the publishing of these stories.
Brian was appreciative of what Randy had done for him. This had been a thoroughly enjoyable experience and Randy had been right about everything from Abbey's reluctance to show up to the fact he had clearly broken his teammates trust. Without prompting, Brian got off the bed and got on his knees and took the cock of his dealer friend into his mouth.
Abbey thought about just letting his teammate service this gay boy with his mouth, something he had obviously done before, but he too was appreciative. Randy had made this almost painless and definitely pleasurable. Sure he was queer but he was a really nice sensitive guy who had his back, literally. Since Abbey knew what the boy liked from the day before and as Randy had missed out riding Brian's cock, which he suspected the boy had actually wanted to do (that he was not just offering to do this as an incentive to convince Brian not to move though it was that as well), Abbey wet two fingers with his mouth and slid them into the older boy's ass.
Abbey didn't need to finger fuck him like the day before as he could feel his ass contract around his fingers the second he shoved them in the older boy so he knew he was starting to cum. Nevertheless Abbey did finger fuck him, in rhythm to the contractions of his ass.
Randy had been so turned on by the two naked blond high school football players in his room and especially by watching the quarterback successfully take his centre's cock that when Brian dropped to his knees he knew it wouldn't take him love before he came. Then with the unexpected intrusion in his ass by Abbey's two fingers, it was too much. He blew his load into Brian's mouth. The younger boy swallowed it down like he had so many times before.
Abbey didn't need to finger fuck him like the day before as he could feel his ass contract around his fingers the second he shoved them in the older boy so he knew he was starting to cum. Nevertheless Abbey did finger fuck him, in rhythm to the contractions of his ass. It made it one of the most intense orgasms Randy had ever hard.
Having satisfied their host, Brian got up off his knees and went and sat at the table, still naked. Abbey wasn't sure what was up, but he knew something was, so he went and sat on the other chair.
Interestingly Abbey no longer wanted to throw on his underwear in the presence of these two boys, both of whom had bigger cocks than his (Brian's being huge). He was fine being naked around them.
Randy sat on the bed and started by asking "how was that for you Abbey."
If they hadn't all been naked Abbey probably would have felt uncomfortable talking about this. He admitted it had been really good.
"It had hurt at first. But Randy you made it so easy and you were right about a big cock being about to give so much pleasure from the inside out," said Abbey. At the risk of over stroking Brian's ego he added "I felt so full and it definitely did a number on my prostate. That orgasm was so intense."
"You don't need to tell me. I had to swallow it down, you almost drowned me. As did you Brian," said Randy. Both boys beamed with pride which Randy though was cute as they were straight boys and he, a gay boy, was talking about how much each had made the other cum.
Turning the subject to the real reason Brian had sat at the table Randy said "I was thinking that we need to up the game like in fight club and make everyone do what you just did as part of their initiation."
Abbey looked to Brian to see if he had put Randy up to this. It would be like Brian to want to fuck everyone.
"Everyone in 'sex club' has now taken Brian's cock," pressed Randy. "He has such a big cock that if you guys have all taken it then shouldn't the new boys have to too?"
This seemed to confirm for Abbey that this was Brian's idea and it was all about him getting the chance to fuck each of the new kids. Brian had, after all, been upset Jessy had chosen to give his virginity to Abbey.
"Some not willingly," shot back Abbey, who was starting to get pissed that this was just some play for Brian to become the main attraction at sex club.
"We have a new person lined up and he is already worried about being fucked," said Abbey. "Just the prospect of being fucked by Brian might scare him off. I am still intimidated by Brian's cock and I just took it all the way up inside me. Plus Brian can't control himself. He probably only behaved today because you were here and you had put in some safeguards, like your hand on his cock and your offering to make him cum when I was done, and I would have left if he hadn't."
Abbey was right. In fact, Brian had woken up that morning fully intending not to behave and to fuck Abbey as hard as he could. The fear that Abbey wouldn't follow through and Randy's controlling the situation had made him keep his word in the end.
Brian normally would have been defensive at the accusation, even if it was true, but he was too distracted to take offense to the quarterback saying he couldn't be trusted.
"Who is the new guy," asked Brian.
"Steven," answered Abbey.
Brian's heart sank.
Brian had thought he was the only one who knew about Steven's tendencies. He had planned to get Steven to have sex with him first and ideally take his virginity, and maybe even fuck him hard since he wasn't going to be able to fuck anyone hard for a while at 'sex club' due to Randy's plan.
Now that Brian knew the other boys had recruited Steven he would have to leave him alone and hope that Abbey and the other's agreed to Randy's suggestion so he could at least get his cock into the younger boy's ass.
"I think he might be willing to let me fuck him," ventured Brian, still thinking of the boy's appetizing untapped ass. "I caught him checking me out in the shower and I got him to briefly hold my cock at the urinals and he was rock hard."
"We're you going to tell us about Steven," asked Abbey suspiciously, as they were supposed to be all recruiting teammates for 'sex club'. Any lead Brian had he should have told his teammates about.
"Of course," Brian lied. "I just haven't seen any of you since it happened" and then added "which is why I didn't know one of you had recruited him" trying to turn this around on the other boy's.
Before the two boys could get into a dust-up, guessing something was going on, Randy pressed on. "If the boys are left to choose they will always choose the smallest cock to be fucked with and a larger cock feels better."
Abbey knew this to be true now.
"Plus 'sex club' is based on 'fight club' and it needs to be increasingly difficult, or at least that is what I got from the movie," said Randy.
Abbey, who had come up with the club, had to admit that this was the original idea and one of the appeals to them as football players.
Randy pressed his point by noting "Brian's cock is intimidating, but that is the point. You are all football players. You are supposed to overcome obstacles. You did. You took it like a champ, and you said you liked it."
Abbey hadn't just taken it and liked it, he had thoroughly enjoyed it, shooting a massive load in Randy's mouth. That is why Randy had started the conversation with that fact. But now he needed to frame it for the club in terms of a challenge for the boys as that would be the only way Abbey would sell it to his teammates. And Abbey would have to sell it to the others for this to have any chance of becoming a rule.
Randy knew the boys didn't like Brian (and Brian didn't make it easy) so they weren't going to just jump at the chance to have Brian put his cock in their ass unless there was a compelling reason that suited the goals of 'sex club'. These boys were having fun having sex and experimenting, as evidenced by the fact Abbey had come to his apartment today outside of 'sex club' but they needed the deniability and rationalization that this was a club with rules, and not a bunch of boys having sex.
"Let's see how Steven fits in and then we can talk about it," said Abbey.
While this answer was non-committal, it was the most responsive the quarterback had been about any rule change. Abbey was cautious by nature and always liked to be in charge.
Randy didn't know Abbey that well so he decided to press his advantage and suggested "perhaps you two could do what you just did at the next sex club. This new boy Steven will see his quarterback take it and this will convince him to do the same. And it will show the other boys, who Brian didn't treat fairly when he fucked them, that it his cock can be pleasurable. That Brian isn't always a pain in the ass."
Randy couldn't help but smile at the pun he had just made. It was good that he had because Abbey was starting to get his back-up at having this idea pressed on him, and it made him smile. Though it didn't totally undo the damage Randy had done by pushing him.
"How do we know Brian will behave," asked Abbey. "How do I know he will even behave with me if we recreate this at sex club?"
"He has promised," said Randy.
In response to Abbey's sceptical look, Randy said "I will vouch for him. He will do like today."
"Assuming he can be trusted, which I doubt, tell me again why this is in the club's interest," asked Abbey.
"The more people who are willing to bottom the best for everyone," Randy quickly answered, having exhausted all of his most compelling points. Brian had told him of Jessy's concern at their meeting, about that he would get tired if he were the only bottom.
Brian looked like he might join in the conversation and, while Randy realized he had pushed the quarterback too hard, Brian would make maters worse. Plus Brian was visibly agitated at the two boys talking about him as not being trustworthy.
Randy shot daggers at Brian. If he tried to argue that he was trustworthy then Abbey would never buy this first step in Randy's plan, and it was in Brian's interest to shut up as step one was about getting Brian's cock into each of his teammate's asses.
Brian, who is his own worse enemy said "I am trustworthy." When both boys made faces he added more meekly "well I can be. I promise. I was good today wasn't I?"
Randy had no idea if this had undermined every point he had made. Brian was going to be a problem. Too bad this big cock wasn't on one of the other boys. That would make Randy's mission easier.
"I'll think about it," said Abbey, who got up and began to get dressed. He didn't even go to the washroom to wash his fingers, which had been up Randy's butt, which was a bad sign because it suggested he just wanted to get out of this conversation and out of Randy's place.
While Randy figured he had lost the argument he knew better to say anything else. When he saw Brian still about to add in his two cents worth he waved him off and, thankfully, the younger boy bit his tongue.
They watched Brian dress and leave in silence.
When he was gone Brian said "what the fuck was that about?"
"You knew the plan," said Randy. "What the fuck were you thinking."
"I know, but what was all that about I can't be trusted," said Brian defensively.
Randy shook his head. He had a fondness for this high school football player but he could be so dense.
"Answer truthfully. At any point today, either before you got to my place or when we were having sex did you contemplate breaking your word to me and trying to fuck Abbey," asked Randy.
While this hit a nerve, as it was true, Brian denied it with an extremely unconvincing "of course not."
Randy knew he was lying.
"Would you like to fuck me hard right now - as hard as I fucked you yesterday - before you go back up the hill," Randy asked.
Without thinking Brian said an excited "definitely", not realizing this simply confirmed what Randy suspected.
"Do you want to slap my ass while you ram your big cock into me," Randy ventured, probing the boy's desires.
"Oh god yes," said Brian, again without thinking.
Their sex had been for the most part love making and not overly rough. It seemed Brian was more than happy to see it change. His having Randy fuck him hard was reflective of a streak in the boy that craved getting and giving pain (which had been evident when he raped Clifford's ass and fucked the towel boy so violently).
"Would you like to tie me up," Randy asked, softer, as he was a little saddened by his suspicions being confirmed and the realization that their relationship had irreversibly changed.
"Yes," said Brian, with huskiness to his voice that, along with the fact that his cock was now fully hard, betrayed just how turned on he was by BDSM.
Randy sighed.
"I'll make a deal with you," said Randy resignedly. "We can experiment with this side of you on our own if you stick to my plan and only do what I tell you at ;sex club'. If Abbey agrees that all boys have to sit on your cock, no moving while the boys ride you, no rough housing even if one of your teammates lets you fuck him, and no putting yourself before 'sex club'. If you find a boy for the club you tell Abbey and the others, you don't try and fuck him on your own."
"I had already agreed to that," said Brian defensively.
Randy shot him a glare.
"OK," said Brian, "I promise."
"I have to go to work but I will bring some BDSM gear back and next time we get together was can start to experiment," said Randy resignedly.
"Can I at least fuck hard and slap your ass now," asked Brian pleadingly? "You promised."
"I didn't actually," said Randy. "I asked if you wanted to. I was trying to determine how much you were lying when you said you hadn't thought about fucking Abbey and whether or not you could be trusted with our plan. And you clearly were lying and you cant be trusted as you have a side of you that craves roughness." (It was more than roughness, but Randy didn't want to offend the boy any more than calling him a liar already had).
"I know you came here today hoping to fuck Abbey hard in spite of you giving me your word for a plan that frankly is totally in your interest," said Randy. "I wouldn't let you fuck me right now even if I had the time."
Brian turned red with embarrassment and anger at having been tricked, and not even realizing it being so fixated on the possibility of rough sex and bondage and maybe more.
"But you will try some of these things with me," Brian asked meekly, duly admonished.
"Yes," Randy said. "If you keep your promise I will keep mine. So let's see how you do at 'sex club' and take it from there."
Brian reluctantly began to get dressed. For his part, Randy was a little sad to see that big cock disappear into the high school football player's pants. He wouldn't have minded being fucked hard by that thing before he went to work (Abbey's fingers in his ass had left him wanting more).
Brian left and walked up the hill. Now he would actually have to behave at sex club and with his teammates. He wanted to try some of the things he had seen on the internet and the fact that Randy would was exciting. In his wildest dreams he hadn't thought he would get to try them in real life. It was enough of an incentive that he resigned himself to following the older boy's instructions at 'sex club'.
NOTE: BRIAN AND RANDY's SIDE STORY IS UNFOLDING AT http://www.nifty.org/nifty/gay/highschool/teens-curiosity-leads-to-more/
NOTE: Nifty needs donations to provide these stories. http://donate.nifty.org/donate.html