Remember to give money to Nifty! Support the publishing of these stories.
The next day Brian went to the school at lunch time and waited outside of the dinning room for Abbey to emerge. He was glad Randy had told him to do that because when he told Abbey that Randy had told him what he wanted to do and he was on board, Abbey hummed and hawed. If they had left it up to Abbey to show up at Randy's place he probably wouldn't have come.
Brian thought, maybe Randy was right, that this was the only way to get his cock into the quarterback's ass. While he still held out hope he might get to fuck the quarterback, he also realized that, even if he never got to actually fuck his teammate, he wanted at least to get his big cock all the way into his teammate's ass at least once.
This was a major attitude adjustment for Brian. Even though he had listened to Randy's plan and arguments and was convinced of its merits on the face of it, secretly he had hoped that before the day was over he would be fucking the quarterback hard.
His own ass was very sore from the pounding Randy had given him the previous day and he had, when he showered this morning and felt how sensitive he was back that, that he could make a similar mark on Abbey. Even if he didn't get to fuck Abbey as hard as Randy had fucked him, he hoped he could fuck him as hard as Abbey had fucked him. That only seemed fair.
But now he was faced with the possibility that Abbey would chicken out altogether and he wouldn't even get to put his cock into the QB's ass.
Whispering quietly in Abbey's ear, even though they were alone in the hall, Brian said "you can take as little or as much as you can. Though I have seen you on the field, you can take a pounding and still win the game for us."
Brian's choice of word was intentional, as part of him still held out a faint hope that Abbey might actually let him fuck him, in spite of what Randy had said and in total disregard for the longer term goals of Randy's plan. Plus Brian thought this would work by making it a challenge, about being tough, but Abbey still didn't agree to go with him.
This was proving much more difficult than he had imagined. He now had to accept that Randy had a better understanding of his teammate and friend than he did. He had no choice but to fully embrace the older boy's plan.
"I promised Randy I would not move," said Brian, which was true even if he had woken up this morning fully intending to fuck the quarterback before the day was out..
"You can stop at any time, and I will not tell anyone about what happens today, no matter what you decide," promised Brian. This seemed to work.
Nodding, Abbey went with the boy.
The two football players made their way down the hill in silence. Abbey was wondering if his teammate would keep his word, and hoped Randy would be a calming influence. Brian, who was excited that his teammate was going to sit on his cock, was still a little sad due to the realization that Randy had been right; and that he had done some damage in his treatment of Clifford and Jessy (his regret was not that he had hurt them, but that this was interfering with his ability to fuck this boy he found himself attracted to and was also jealous of).
Randy opened the door naked. This had the desired effect and distracted the boys from their nervous thoughts and got them thinking instantly about sex in a hopeful way, making them excited at the prospect of getting laid.
Randy started right away talking, thus breaking the silence of the long walk down the hill. As the two boys undressed, Randy explained how this would go, that both he and Brian would give Abbey a massage. Brian didn't understand the point of this as he wanted to get his now hard cock up the quarterback's ass as soon as possible. Abbey, though, remembered how massaging his ass had made it so easy to take Randy's cock the day before and welcomed the older boy's suggestion, glad that he was taking charge.
Next, Randy explained, he and Brian would take turns sucking on Abbey's cock. Brian didn't like that idea as it would mean Abbey would cum quicker and he already didn't like the fact that he might not get to cum in the quarterback's ass while. Again Abbey liked this idea as it put them on more even footing and he knew he wanted to be rock hard before he tried to take Brian's cock as the hornier he was the more he would want to try it.
Then, Randy continued, he would hold Brian's cock upright and Abbey would sit on it as slowly as he needed to and could stop altogether and everyone go home or stop and try again later, entirely up to him. Brian didn't understand why Randy would be holding his cock. Abbey knew perfectly well and was reassured that Randy's hand on Brian's cock would prevent Brian from getting impatient and thrusting that monstrous cock up into him, a thought that caused Abbey to glance over at it as they were now naked and it was hard and very intimidating.
Once Abbey was all the way down on Brian's cock Randy would go back to sucking his cock. Brian had mixed feelings on this idea as on the one hand it incentivized taking all of Brian's cock on the other it would mean that Abbey would definitely cum before Brian could cum in his ass. Abbey, like all the other suggestions, liked his idea.
Finally, Randy said, surprising both boys as they each assumed that once Abbey came their little experiment would be over, he would replace Abbey on Brian's cock and ride him until he came if Brian hadn't already inside Abbey. This had it desired effect and Brian, who was starting to try to picture ways to go back on his promise and was considering thrusting up into his teammate if he sensed he was getting close to cumming, calmed down and returned to accepting that this was about getting all the way into Abbey and with Randy sucking him Abbey was more likely to ride him so he would be getting to fuck the quarterback and he would get to cum in someone's ass, if not Abbey's then Randy's (and with Randy he knew he could fuck him and hard)..
This plan had its desired effect on Abbey who was visible relaxed, just as he had been noticeably tense when he had first walked in the door.
The naked quarterback got facedown on the bed and as the older boy massaged his ass and upper hips to get his ass muscles to relax. Brian, thinking this was just a massage, worked his shoulders and legs as these were the tense muscles on an athlete and this was how it was often done by one of the assistant coaches after a game.
Randy began to apply lube to the football player's asshole and told Brian to continue to work his butt cheeks and thighs. He hadn't stopped Brian from massaging his shoulders and leg muscles as it probably relaxed the boy, but the goal was to get Abbey to take a big intrusion into his ass with the least amount of discomfort. That meant massaging the ass and upper legs. The fact this hadn't occurred to Brian on his own Randy wondered if it was because Brain was so self-absorbed, because when you have a huge cock you don't think about what it is like to take it or because the boy had BDSM tendencies, something he had begun to suspect the day before.
When massaging Abbey the day before, Randy had decided not to work fingers into his hole. He was still hesitant to do it, as he knew a straight guy like Abbey would hate a finger shoved into his ass. A finger can be more uncomfortable than a cock. And as Randy had gotten Abbey to finger fuck him as he jacked his cock, the football player likely would associate having a finger in his ass as being a gay thing. But Randy wanted to stretch his hole for the big cock.
Abbey's hole was a little stretched from his cock being inside the younger boy the day before (Randy wondered if Brian noticed Abbey's hole was red and a little stretched as he massaged his teammates ass). But he needed to be stretched wider or the initial shock of Brian's big cock was going to be too much and he would pull off before it got to his prostate.
Randy worked around the edges of the hole and gently tried to nudge it wider. With Brian massaging his butt cheeks and thighs, Abbey barely noticed that his hole was being stretched ever so gently by Randy.
When Randy was satisfied he had Abbey's hole as wide as he could get it without hurting the boy or noticeably violating him with a finger or fingers, he had Abbey roll over onto his back. Then he and Brian, on the opposite sides of the bed, began to work on his cock and balls.
That Abbey was not rock hard told Randy he was still nervous. Randy took the QB's cock in his mouth and Brian went to work on his balls. Before long they had the quarterback hard.
Randy kept sucking until Abbey said "OK, I am ready, I want to try."
Brian replaced Abbey on the bed and Randy handed him the lube so he could get Brian's cock wet and get used to feeling the shape of the big cock in his hands before he tried to mount it.
Abbey lubed it for a while, clearly hesitant though also fascinated by it, which was a good sign.
Eventually Abbey climbed up on the bed. Randy had him face Brian. He wanted him to look at his teammate as that would make the connection personal. If he faced his feet it would have been to impersonal, and he didn't want this simple to be a challenge to see if he could sit all the way down. He wanted it to be pleasurable for both boys.
The fact Abbey had instinctually kissed his teammate when the roles had been reversed, a fact Brian had shared with the older boy, told Randy that looking into Brian's eyes while doing the most intimate thing a person can do and that is take their penis inside them would add to the boy's pleasure, foster a closer connection and maybe further his plan of making this something all boys at sex club should do with all of the others.
Randy knelt next to the bed and held Brian's cock upright. He aimed it at Abbey's hole and the quarterback leaned back and the cock connected with his hole.
Abbey put his hands on Brian's chest to steady himself as soon as the head got, with some difficulty (and seemed pain) past his sphincter.
Abbey stopped.
When Abbey didn't lean further back after a few seconds and try to take more, Randy wasn't sure what to do. If he took his hand off Brian's cock then the boy might be tempted to impatiently thrust up into his ass, in spite of his promise, and then everything would be ruined. But Abbey needed encouragement and sucking his cock right then, rather than after he had the cock all the way inside, could be just the trick.
Randy let get of the cock, stood up, and lowered his mouth onto Abbey's cock. It was a smart move as Abbey was just starting to deflate in reaction to the pain.
He used every skill he knew to bring the boy pleasure with his mouth and as he did the boy sank down on the cock.
While Randy sucked Abbey's cock he was focussed on Brian. He was prepared if the boy showed any signs of thrusting upwards to use his hands to force the boy's hips firmly down on the bed.
To everyone's surprise Abbey sat all the way down on the cock.
When it connected with his prostate Abbey felt waves of pleasure.
Abbey stayed seated on his centre's lap with the boy's big cock all the way up his ass enjoying the blowjob and getting used to having this monster inside of him. When he felt he was ready he began to move up and down on Brian's cock. Brian kept his word and lay perfectly still, letting Abbey ride his cock.
Looking up at the quarterback Brian couldn't help but think about how he had longed for this moment and how hot Abbey looked. His former friend, quarterback and prefect had his cock up his ass and seemingly was enjoying it. Maybe it was the blowjob he was getting, as Brian knew Randy had serious cock sucking skills; but Abbey was riding his cock, and taking all of it in on the down stroke, so he must be liking it. Brian was so turned on he found himself building towards an orgasm in record time (it usually took him forever).
Brian concentrated hard, wanting to cum at the same time or before Abbey. But before he could he heard Abbey moan and knew, as he felt Abbey's tight ass constrict around his big cock, the quarterback was cumming in Randy's mouth.
As Abbey came he lifted off Brian's cock. Abbey knew he would cum harder if he kept pounding down on the monster cock making it hit his prostate, but he wanted it out of his ass before he stopped cumming. He didn't want to feel any pain like he had at the beginning when it first entered him, especially since he was experiencing the most mind numbing orgasm of his young life.
Brian grabbed his own cock and began to stroke. As soon as he thought Abbey had stopped cumming in friend/dealer's mouth, Brian shouted "get your mouth on my cock right now Randy".
Randy had offered to replace Abbey and he could have fucked his friend's ass as hard as he wanted, but he was so damn close and he wanted to cum while the memory of the quarterback's tight ass around his cock was still fresh in his mind.
Randy didn't need to be asked twice and as Abbey moved out of the way he took the head and the upper third of Brian's big cock into his mouth and started to suck hard. He was rewarded in less than a minute with a second load of cum in his mouth.
Randy didn't spill a drop; even though he had been amazed by the sheer volume of cum each boy had produced. They had clearly both enjoyed the experience and that boded well for Randy's plan.
NOTE: Nifty needs donations to provide these stories. http://donate.nifty.org/donate.html