Remember to give money to Nifty! Support the publishing of these stories.
Randy figured he should take control if only to ensure that it actually happened. He knew how intimidating a big cock like Brian's could be for a first timer. Curiosity only got you so far and he wanted Abbey to try this for both the boy's benefit and his own, as he so wanted to see these two hot football players fuck.
Randy had thought that Brian and Abbey would look hot having sex the second he had arrived at Brian's house and saw this hot quarterback, not that he knew he was the quarterback and Brian the centre at the time. He just picked up on their alpha personalities and they way they clashed. He had just assumed it would be Abbey fucking Brian (he didn't know that had already happed as he predicted). For Randy, the fact that it would be the other way around made it all the hotter.
These were two hot boys, both blond hair and blue eyes. Brian was taller and Abbey had a better physique, though each was in great shape.
The more he thought about Abbey taking Brian's cock, an idea formed in his mind on how to take 'sex club' to the next level. Now that they had made him a member he had a vested interest in ensuring it was as hot as it could possibly be.
While his own sex with Brian had always been mutual and respectful, he had watched the boy with his teammates the week before and the dynamics were anything but. Brian had shown such condescending attitude towards Jessy and the rough way he fucked him had been brutal to watch (though the young boy took it like a trooper). And then there was his basically raping Clifford.
Abbey was clearly straight. While he didn't notice it at the time as he was so focussed on touching this high school football player's body, on reflection he had felt the boy cringe when he had run his hand over his chest and abs.
Both boys would require some manipulating if the next day was going to work, let alone Randy's plan for 'sex club' to unfold.
Randy messaged Brian and asked to come over before he went to the club to sell drugs.
Randy figured the best way to manipulate Brian would be to let him in on the plan. He needed Brian to put whatever personal history and team politics were at play behind him and get with the program.
When Brian arrived, it was clear he thought they were going to have sex as he proposed they smoke a joint.
"I need to talk to you about a plan I have for 'sex club'," said Randy, "and I need you on board."
Randy had judged Brian correctly because the boy was suddenly all ears at being part of a conspiracy to manipulate the others.
"What did you have in mind and what do I need to do," asked Brian.
"Abbey is curious to try taking your cock," said Randy.
"I figured as much," said Brian, who proceeded to tell Randy that Abbey had fucked him and what is more, had kissed him while he had been fucking him. He had then let him put the head of his cock in his ass and jack off the weekend before when the two were alone. He also told his occasional lover that Abbey was still hard after he had jacked off into his ass so he had blown him.
This surprised the drug dealer, who thought he had Abbey pegged. Maybe he wasn't as straight as he had thought. Though it was probably just the two boys' intense former friendship was trumping their macho competitiveness now that they were experimenting sexually. Plus kissing does make sex much more intense.
Whatever the case it didn't change the plan. The fact that he and Brian might have something going on between them might make the next day easier, but it wouldn't make Abbey want to take Brian's cock in front of the other players. That is why he was doing it at his place and not at sex club the next week (or whenever it next met).
"I want to fuck everyone at sex club," said Randy.
"We made new rules," said Brian. "Everyone has to be fucked to be a member of sex club."
"That is a start," said Randy, "but I want to fuck everyone in the club myself."
"The guys would never agree to that," said Brian, confused as Randy normally didn't take the lead in what they did together and the few times he had it had been because he wanted Brian to fuck him.
Normally that is true, Randy almost always let the other person lead as he was completely versatile, he liked both topping and being the bottom equally. He was just happy to be having sex with some hot guy. But having seen these high school boys in their football uniforms all macho and competitive that morning and then having had his cock in the winning quarterback's ass had been such a turn-on. He didn't tell Brian he had already had his cock inside Abbey, as the boy likely had feelings for the QB and maybe also for him,or that he had jacked off thinking about the quarterback since.
The fact that Brian hadn't asked him how he knew Abbey wanted to try taking his cock suggested he didn't really want to know, further confirming the boy had feelings for his classmate.
Responding to Brian's statement of the obvious, Randy said "of course they wouldn't agree to a rule that everyone has to be fucked by me. But they might agree to being fucked by you?"
"Why would they agree to be fucked by me," asked Brian, "most of the players hate me."
"Why does Abbey want to try to take your cock," asked Randy.
"Abbey and I used to be friends and we made up last weekend," Brian started.
"Get real," said Randy. "Abbey wants to see if he can take it because you are the biggest one in the group."
"I am the biggest in the school," Brian said proudly.
"Look I like you," said Randy. "I know, I like you too," said Brian. "But sex is sex," said Randy. "When I saw your cock I knew I had to see what it was like to be fucked by that big cock. For most of these boys and whoever else gets recruited it will be about experimenting and for some, like Clifford, it will be about bowing to peer pressure."
Brian listened with rapt attention as Randy continued. "It was peer pressure that made Abbey let Jessy fuck him. That and the weed."
This caused Brian to laugh. The two had been pretty manipulative the weekend before but it had been worth it.
"OK, what's the plan," asked Brian.
"Tomorrow I want you to pick up Abbey at the school," said Randy. "You have to go when you know you will find him and bring him to my place so he doesn't chicken out."
"Lunch is at 12. Meals are not compulsory on the weekend but most boarders do Sunday lunch as they also don't have to be out of bed until noon," said Brian.
"So be waiting for him, tell him I told you what he wanted to do, and how he wanted to do it, that you are on board and that I will be there, and then you walk him down the hill to my place," said Randy.
"What do you mean by 'how'," asked by Brian.
"So that is the next part of what I need you to do," Randy said hesitantly, unconvinced that the boy would go for this part. "I need you to lie on my bed and let Abbey sit on your cock."
"Hot," said Brian, thrilled that he might just get to fuck his quarterback and former friend.
"Let's be clear," Randy pressed on. "I need you to lie there and let him take you as slow as he wants. No thrusting up. No pressing on his thighs to force him down on your cock. If he stops or pulls off no complaining."
"Why would I agree to that," said Brian, who had loved when Abbey had fucked him and so desperately wanted to fuck him the way he had watched Clifford do the week before.
"Because first of all, that is what he wants to do," Randy said, "and that is the surest way you are going to get your cock inside him."
"But he let me jack off into him he is already curious about what my cock would feel like in his ass even before you and he talked," Brian reminded his friend. "And you yourself said that curiosity about my cock is a powerful force. Plus I want to cum in his ass from fucking, what if he pulls off me right away or before I cum?"
"This is more than about you fucking Abbey," said Randy.
"How so," asked Brian.
"If Abbey's experience tomorrow is good, I think I can talk him into doing it again at sex club," said Randy.
"I doubt that," said Brian.
"You leave that to me," said Randy.
Brian was dubious but figured he would let it go and asked "so why is it important that I fuck Abbey at sex club?"
"I don't know that he will let you fuck him," said Randy. "He might just want to ride your cock again, we would have to see. But the reason is that if the boys see Abbey take it then they might be willing to and maybe make it a rule that everyone has to take your big cock."
"You mean I would get to fuck everyone," Brian asked. "Wouldn't that be Abbey's right as quarterback if anyone's?"
"Again, you wouldn't be fucking them just as you aren't going to be fucking Abbey tomorrow," said Randy. "It is the challenge of taking your big cock up their ass."
"How does this help you to fuck them," asked Brian.
"Your new rule about everyone being fucked probably gives the boy the right to choose who fucks them,' Randy guessed. Brian nodded.
"These boys will instinctually choose a boy with a smaller cock thinking it will be less painful," Randy continued. Brian recalled that Abbey chose Jessy for his first time.
"Bigger cocks feel better," said Randy. "Small cocks don't hit the prostate. It depends on the boy's size but on me a cock that is 7" or larger will hit my prostate and I can cum without even touching my cock." Brian recalled the times he had made the older boy cum while he fucked him.
Knowing what Brian was thinking Randy said "when I cum while you are fucking me I don't stop you, I let you keep going until you cum. But most boys will insist on stopping once they cum as then your cock will start to hurt even more than when they first sat down on you."
"So you are telling me that your plan is for me to lie there and have everyone in sex club sit on my cock until they cum and then they will be getting off me without my cumming," Brian asked confused. "What is in this for me?"
Randy wasn't surprised that the big take away from what he had just said was that Brian might not be getting to fuck these boys until he came and not that Randy had let him keep fucking him numerous times even when it was uncomfortable. This boy was totally self-absorbed.
"First, you will have had your cock inside of each of your teammates in the club." Then Randy added quickly before Brian could interrupt him again, as he had every time he had gotten out a first, "second, once they have discovered how pleasurable it is to have your big cock in their ass they may let you actually fuck them in the future, as opposed to simply sitting on you." This made sense to Brian so he didn't interrupt as Randy added "and third, you did a lot of damage last week with your fucking Clifford without his permission and your fucking Jessy so hard. Right now your chances of fucking anyone other than me in the club is probably nil. This will help the build trust."
Brian reluctantly agreed. He intended on fucking Steven on Friday night, if he could convince the boy to give up his cherry, so there was that. And maybe Abbey would let him be more active than Randy was suggesting was needed.
Finally, Brian asked "how does this help you."
"If they find that being fucked can be truly pleasurable, then that opens the door to my fucking some of them," Randy said. He didn't tell the centre that his end game was to get a rule that everyone had to be fucked by everyone else. While the football centre had proven himself adept at manipulation, he was also impatient as he had proven at 'sex club' when in the very first meeting he had upped the ante to fucking and had nearly ruined everything by basically raping one boy and savagely fucking the youngest. Randy was amazed that the club hadn't been disbanded right then.
It was best to keep Brian focussed on his task, and that is to lie there and be ridden, first by Abbey and if that went well by the new boys (he had already fucked Clifford and Jessy).
"So," Brian asked, thinking back to what the boy had said a few seconds earlier, "can I fuck you now until I cum even if you shoot before I blow my load. All this talk has given me a hard-on."
As if the huge bulge in his pants was not obvious enough, Brian undid his pants and freed his big hard cock.
Just seeing that impressive cock out in the open made Randy desperate to have it in his ass. But he wanted the next day to go well and reminding the boy how much pleasure one can get from fucking right after a talk about the importance of not fucking Abbey when his cock was inside him in order to achieve the longer term plan seemed like it would send mixed signals.
"While I said you might have to endure Abbey riding your cock and getting off you before you had cum, that will definitely be true if you have cum anytime between now and then. Maybe you shouldn't even jack off between now and tomorrow so that the chances of you cumming before he cums sitting on your cock, or ideally at the same time as him, is going to be greater" Randy suggested.
"Then how about you fuck me now. That will make me even more boned," said Brian who stood up and began stripping his clothes, knowing that Randy would take him up on his offer "and you can do it as hard as I did Jessy."
"You don't mind if it hurts," asked Randy, as he stood and started removing his own clothes. He had always tried to be gentle with the younger boy knowing he was just in high school.
"I think I actually want it to hurt," admitted Brian.
This was a complex teenager, Randy thought to himself, but he instantly knew what position he was going to fuck Brian in, the position this high school centre had been in throughout the football game that morning.
When he told Brian, the football player liked the idea, thinking it was just about having seen him play earlier in the day and probably had turned him on. He didn't know that Abbey had fucked the older boy in this position in the very same spot several hours earlier.
After putting lube on his cock and on the bent over centre's ass, Randy shoved his cock in hard and went to work pounding this high school football player's ass. The fact that Randy had cum four times that day, one by Abbey's hand and three by his own, meant that it took him a long time to cum, no matter how hard he fucked this younger boy.
He knew first hand how uncomfortable it must be for the boy. While he was in good shape and used to being bent over like this, it isn't the same as when he was playing football as the centre just bent over and touched the ball to the grass. Brian was having to brace himself on his finger tips and Randy knew how much that hurt, his own hands which were gripping hard on the player's hips, still ached from when he had been in the same position being fucked my the quarterback.
Knowing it was hurting didn't make Randy go more gently. In fact, it made him go harder.
After what seemed like forever, Randy began to cum in Brian's ass. He didn't bury deep and enjoy the orgasm; he just kept pounding as his cum shot out of his cock into the boy's ass. Even after he came he kept fucking the boy hard and fast and to his own surprise he came again a second and then a third time before he had to stop, exhausted and spent.
As Randy pulled his cock out of the player, Brian stood upright, his big cock rock hard.
"If you had given me maybe five more strokes I would have cum," Brian said. "I can't put on my underwear right now. I am afraid if I touch my cock I will cum."
Randy had gotten so caught up in fucking the boy hard he had lost sight of the objective which was to get him boned but not cum. Though Brian almost cumming from being fucked let him experience first hand what they had been talking about so that was helpful.
"Wasn't it painful," Randy asked out of curiosity not sympathy. He wondered if Brian's experience had been like his.
"Yea, it hurt my fingers and you did a good job on my ass," Brian said. "But that was kinda hot too."
Randy wondered if they had inadvertently introduced sadomasochism into their relationship, whatever their relationship was.
"It took you longer than usual to cum," Brian said.
Randy thought that Brian was likely wondering what he had done with Abbey, so he diverted his attention by saying "I actually came three times while I was fucking you." (While three was an impressive number, Randy wondered how much he had cum as those were the fifth, sixth and seventh time of the day.)
Brian simply said "cool", as he went to sit at the table and wait for his erection to go down.
Brian really was a gorgeous boy, Randy thought, and that is such a glorious cock. He had to fight every impulse not to go over and take it into his mouth and get the load this cock was so obviously straining to blow.
Tomorrow watching him enter Abbey would be something spectacular to see.
NOTE: Nifty needs donations to provide these stories. http://donate.nifty.org/donate.html