Remember to give money to Nifty! Support the publishing of these stories.
To Randy's pleasant surprise, when Abbey pulled his cock from his ass he didn't immediately reach for his clothes. He walked over to the bed and flopped on it naked, his cock glistening with lube and cum from Randy's ass.
Abbey patted the bed next to him. It was Randy's apartment and this boy was inviting him to sit on his own bed. In any other situation the older boy might have taken offense, but instead he just sat on the bed where he was told.
"So you and Brian have been fucking for a while," Abbey said.
Randy didn't respond.
"How did you guys meet," Brian's class and team mate pressed.
Most gay boys like to brag about their conquests and Brian was one hell of a conquest, a high school football star, clearly Abbey's competition and yet Randy still didn't respond. It was not like the quarterback didn't know, they had fucked in front of him.
After an awkward period of silence, Randy said "I don't kiss and tell."
Abbey mulled this over.
Randy eventually ventured, fearful that he had upset Abbey, "if that means I won't be invited to your club again that is ok. But I would think the fact I will keep your secrets you, of all people, would appreciate."
Abbey did appreciate and happily told the boy "we made you a member of 'sex club'"
This was good news, as was the fact that the quarterback was still lying naked on his bed.
Eventually Abbey ventured "have you taken his big cock? Didn't it hurt?"
Up until this point, Randy had assumed Abbey's interest had been out of animosity or competitiveness. It suddenly dawned on him that maybe Abbey was curious about being fucked by Brian. Abbey had seemed to like being fucked by Clifford the weekend before.
If he had known what had transpired on Sunday between Brian and Abbey his suspicions would have been confirmed.
"I won't talk about Brian," said Randy. "But I can tell you a large cock is actually more pleasurable than a small one. It hurts going in and while you adjust to it, but it hits your prostate every time it is all the way inside you and when a cock connects with your prostate it causes so much pleasure."
That explained for Abbey why he had enjoyed being fucked by Clifford, who was pretty big, just not as big as Brian. Still, he couldn't imagine Brian's cock not hurting no matter how much pleasure the prostate generated as it was so much bigger.
As he studied the older boy who had a big smile on his face Abbey knew instinctually that Brian had fucked him and had done it on more than one occasion. And the fact that he had fucked Brian back meant his football centre probably had fucked him not in the aggressive way he had fucked Jessy but more like Randy had fucked Brian on the couch the weekend before.
Randy, sensing what was going on in Abbey's head, said "you know there are ways of taking a big cock the first time that can make it easier."
"Such as," asked Abbey, genuinely interested.
"In the porn industry they practice on different size dildos, from smaller to bigger, until they are stretched enough for the scene," suggested Randy.
Abbey had no intention of putting a dildo in his ass and his expression made this fact clear to the older boy.
"Different positions hurt more than others," said Randy.
"How so," asked Abbey.
"It is a combination of the angle and some positions invite the top to be more aggressive," said Randy.
This made sense to Abbey who recalled fucking Brian hard. In fact, he had fucked Randy even harder.
"Is what we just did one of those positions that hurt," Abbey asked.
"Maybe," said Randy, adding "doggie can be worse" so as to lessen the implication that sex with Abbey was anything but pleasurable.
"Did I hurt you," asked Abbey outright.
"I asked for it," was the response.
Abbey was one who often played through pain and took this as confirmation.
"Sorry," said Abbey, with true contrition.
"Don't be," said Randy. "I don't mind it a bit rough. It just took a while to get used to it and I was so turned on at the end I was sad it stopped. Didn't you see my erection?"
Abbey had seen his erection and it gave him an idea.
"Can you show me the best way to try taking a big cock for the first time," Abbey asked.
"I can," said Randy. "And I can loan you my apartment tomorrow if you want to try it with Brian."
Abbey sprung an erection immediately at the idea, confirming for both boys what this was really about.
Randy offered to light up a joint but Abbey declined as he wanted to have full control of his faculties. While the weed had made the previous weekend's experience easier, he wanted to truly experience what was happening now.
Randy gestured for Abbey to rollover; when the quarterback did and was facedown on the bed, the older boy massaged his ass and upper hips to get his ass muscles to relax. Applying lube to the football player's asshole he continued to work his butt cheeks and thighs with his other hand.
Getting off the bed, Randy got Abbey to stand and then replaced him on the bed but lying face up.
"Take your time, and sit down on my cock," said Randy, holding his cock so it pointed straight up. "This way you can control the speed."
Having just pounded Randy's ass, Abbey saw the logic to this position: it allowed the bottom a modicum of control. Of course the top could always shove upwards, as he had seen Brian do mercilessly to Jessy when the towel boy was sitting in his lap. Abbey just had to trust that this boy, who he didn't really know, wouldn't do the same to him (even though he had every reason to since abbey had just brutalized his ass and he had admitted it had hurt). But something about Randy's demeanour assured Abbey he wouldn't.
Getting up on the bed, Abbey stradled Randy's hips, facing him, and lowered his ass until it connected with the older boy's cock. Between Abbey moving his hips and Randy aiming his cock, the head connected with Abbey's hole.
Immediately Abbey tensed. Randy could see the boy tense and knew that this instinctual response would make entry more difficult and perhaps, in spite of his advance work, painful. Randy quickly took hold of Abbey's cock and began to stroke it with his free hand and he let go of his own cock with the other and began to play with the quarterback's balls. This focus on Abbey's genitalia took the boy's mind off what was happening behind him and he sunk down onto the cock easily and once he was sitting down on the other boy's hips the cock buried in his ass connected with his prostate and sent pleasure through his body from the inside out..
Abbey was amazed. When Jessy, whose cock was pretty small, had entered him it had hurt, though not too intensely and, as the boy didn't move once inside him he hadn't minded. Later when Clifford had fucked him he had felt pain when he entered him and some discomfort throughout, though the pleasure when the cock hit his prostate (which he now knew was what had been happening) more than offset that and before long he had been enjoying being fucked. This time he felt no discomfort at all and genuinely enjoyed having this older boy inside him, even if he was gay.
As Randy stroked his cock Abbey began to move up and down on the older boy's cock. Randy responded by slowing the stroking to match it to Abbey's movement. Soon the quarterback was essentially fucking himself. When he sat down on the cock Randy's hand around his cock would pull the skin up around part of the head (being cut there was only so much loose skin to move) and when he lifted his hips up the skin would pull back.
In addition to holding the skin of Abbey's cock in his hand like a sheaf, Randy played with the younger football player's balls cupped in his hand and used his index finger to rub the skin between his balls and his anus. This drove Abbey wild and soon he was pounding down hard on the cock trying to make it hit his prostate harder and harder.
The effect was too much and soon Abbey was cumming, shooting rope after rope of cum all over the other boy's chest and stomach. Randy could feel Abbey's cock contract on his cock with every shot of cum but it was not enough, as he was not anywhere close to cumming yet, even though the sight of this sexy young high school quarterback with his broad shoulders, smooth body, blond hair and blue eyes riding his cock had him extremely rock hard.
When Abbey was about to stop cumming he lifted off the older boy's cock, knowing he was starting to want it out of his ass, even though it had given him such pleasure seconds before.
Abbey lifted off and moved so he was lying next to Randy on the small bed, after Randy moved over to make room for him.
He had appreciated the older boy had let him control the experience and he knew he had been selfish, getting off of his cock before Randy had cum.
Randy was disappointed he hadn't gotten to cum in the quarterback's ass. This fucking without condoms was a total turn on. The best thing about these virgin straight high school boys was they were disease free and he wanted their cum in his ass and his own cum up each of theirs. But he also knew he had to let them run the show because one wrong move would either get him excluded from their 'sex club' or end their experimenting.
Abbey realized he had used this boy now twice for his own please. He considered sucking on the older boy's cock but he felt cock-sucking was demeaning (even though he wanted his girlfriend to do it) and this cock had been up his ass so he definitely didn't want to put it in his mouth.
As if he could read the football player's mind Randy said "you could just jack me off."
Abbey figured he owed the boy at least that, though he wasn't that keen on even jacking this gay boy's cock. He reluctantly wrapped his hand around Randy's cock and began to stroke.
Randy liked having this boy in his bed, even if he was just jacking him off, though the huge load of cum that was dripping down his sides was cold and distracting.
Randy reached out with both hands and began to run his hands over the quarterback's firm body.
Abbey didn't particularly like having his chest, stomach and thighs touched by a boy he knew to be a fag, though strangely he didn't mind Randy playing with his cock and balls with his other hand. He liked having any attention paid to his cock and balls but having his body touched felt too intimate, especially knowing this boy was queer.
Abbey didn't say anything, he just sped up his stroking of the older boy's cock trying to make him cum quickly and get this over with.
"Can you put a finger in my ass," Randy asked in a panting voice.
Abbey had learned from Jessy that this had added to his experience with Steven and vice-versa and Abbey was up for anything that would get this over quicker. He really wasn't liking having his body explored by this gay boy.
Abbey reached down as Randy bent his knee up to give access to his butt.
Abbey's finger slid in easily. He had, after all, been fucked by the quarterback earlier.
Abbey could feel his own cum in the other boy's ass.
Randy was now moaning as Abbey used his finger to fuck the boy. On his own initiative he added a second finger which caused the gay boy to exclaim "god yes."
With both their hands on each other the stimulation was enough and soon Randy was adding his own cum to Abbey's load on his stomach and chest.
Randy had offered to let the boy jack him off because he hadn't wanted to push the boy's limits. But that had been intense. Having the quarterback finger fuck him and jack his cock while he played with the boy's gorgeous body had stimulated all of his senses. Of course, being gay, he couldn't have known that he had actually pushed the football player's limits just by his exploring the younger football player's body.
With the deed done, Abbey removed his fingers from the older boy's ass, let go of his cock, got off the bed, pulling away from the gay boy's grabby hands and went to the washroom. He washed his cock and his hands and the spots where his and the other boy's cum had splashed him.
When he came out Randy was finishing wiping the cum off his body, using the pair of briefs he had been wearing when they stripped to sop up what was a big mess. Abbey's load was bigger the competitive football player had noted with pride and a bit of guilt since it had been caused by a gay boy's cock being up his ass.
Nevertheless, Abbey had to admit that this had been a fun experience, even if he hadn't like some aspects largely because Randy was gay, though he did like the boy and he did trust him to fuck him and that trust had not been betrayed. This boy had let him control the speed while riding his cock and had put up no protest when he had pounded his ass earlier so as to release the pent up adrenaline from his earlier victory in the quarterfinals.
Abbey decided just then that he trusted this gay boy more than he did Brian. If he was going to try taking Brian's cock he wanted this boy there.
"I'd like you to be here tomorrow when I try to take Brian's cock," said Abbey. It's not like the boy didn't know what he was planning when he offered his apartment.
"Really?"
"Yea, I think you being there will be a calming influence on Brian," said Abbey as he began to get dressed.
"I understand," said Randy, realizing he wasn't being invited to a threesome but rather as a teacher and guide. He liked this quarterback. While he had initially not liked the way Brian and Abbey had interacted, he knew Brian pretty well and he thought he could help make Abbey's experience with a really big cock go easier. And the thought of seeing them naked and fucking in his bed was incredibly hot even if he wouldn't be part of the action.
Randy watched the quarterback dress, admiring this football star's body and self confidence. As soon as the door closed Randy began to jack his cock, thinking more about the possibilities of tomorrow than the fact that his cock had just been up this quarterback's ass and the cum oozing out of his ass.
NOTE: Nifty needs donations to provide these stories. http://donate.nifty.org/donate.html