This is a work of fiction, any resemblance to anyone is coincidence. Please consider donating to Nifty to keep the website we love the way it is!
As always, PLEASE feel free to reach out and if you have an idea for the story I would love to hear it! This part of the story starts to get a little exciting. More to come! XOXO
Part 3:
We all jumped into my parents Jeep (I was driving it since it was so nice outside) and took off towards the Sonic. We collectively ordered 24 corndogs and I still don't know why. We went back to my house which is like 2 miles from the Sonic.
After chilling for a couple of hours Kason announces that he needs to head home and asked if I could take him up to the school to get his car. So assuming the night was over the three of us go up to the school to drop Kason off at his car. Once we said goodbye to Kason I drive over to Colton's truck and got ready for this amazing and weird day to end.
He looks at me and says, "I had the best time today, thank you again for letting me hang with you guys. I don't really have any true friends other than my girlfriend and even than she kind of limits who I can hang out with."
"Of course anytime. And hey you have my number now so don't be afraid to shoot me a text if you wanna come chill."
"Can I cash that offer in right now? I don't really want to go home, my mom is probably drunk and I don't really feel like dealing with that tonight."
Shocked and confused I said, "Well sure. I'll call my mom real quick to make sure it's okay since It is a school night." Mom said yes to my surprise and distain, usually a stickler for the rules gave in and let him come over for a little bit.
The next thing to happen completely shocked me. Colton looks me in the eyes and doesn't say a word, just looks at me. "Take a picture it'll last longer." I say, trying to sound somewhat flirtatious. Colton leans over to me and says, "How about I do this instead," he then pushes his lips against mine and gives me a kiss with so much passion it felt like he was trying to save my life. Forget what they say about first kisses, nothing is like it. I felt like I had fallen off of a trampoline and got all the air knocked out of my lungs. After what felt like ages and his hand cupping my face he finally pulled away. "Hope that last long enough" "Oh that's not enough" I say and then pull him by the back of his neck into me and kiss him with as much passion and heart that I can manage. I open my mouth a little and he gets the hint and carefully pushes his tongue in my mouth. Our tongues wrestle for dominance over one another. Feeling bold I let my hand fall from the back of his head and run it down his neck and over his chiseled jaw.
This time I pull back and have a little heart attack. I at a loss for words say, "Colton I'm sorry."
"What are you sorry for?" He asks while rubbing my back and shoulders. With tears in my eyes I say, "I don't want you to think that I just do this with every straight boy I hang out with or I try and flirt my way into their pants or something."
"Well my pants are still on, and I started it." He winked at me and then leaned in and gave me a quick peck on the cheek. "Come on. I'll race you to your house. Last one there is a rotten egg!!" He screamed while running to his truck. I start up the engine of the jeep and take off towards my house.
As I pull into my house, I see him in my rearview just screeching in behind me. Walking in I see that my mother has gotten home finally and is starting on dinner. Colton walks in and not knowing my mom was there and slapped me on the ass as hard as he could and said, "I guess I don't mind being last since that's my view." MORTIFIED.
"Hi Colton, I'm Nates mom. I wouldn't recommend beating this one in anything. You don't want to see him when he gets mad." She says ingnoring the fact that Colton just slapped her sons ass.
"Oh, Hi Mrs. Heart, I, umÉ I'm sorry."
"For what?" My mom says playing dumb. "But please don't call me Mrs. Heart, call me Tiffany."
"Mrs. Heart I'm so sorry. IÑ"
"Honey I'm just messing with you. I'm happy to have you here."
"Okay well now that it's awkward. We're gonna go hangout in my room." Our house was nothing to boast about. With mom and dad both being teachers for the district it wasn't like we could afford a mansion. We walked into my room to find my brat of a little brother playing my PS4. "Umm what are you doing in here?"
"Mom said I could if I didn't mess with your stuff."
"Looks like you did?? Get out you pest." I say with rising anger.
"Who's the meat head?"
"GET. OUT." I slam the door as I push him out, hoping that Colton wouldn't judge me for my little brother.
"Meat head huh." he says chuckling a little bit. "Sorry about that. He still thinks that he's little enough to get away with shit like that." "Nah it was cute. Just not as cute as you." He says as he pulls me by my waist so that I'm standing in front of him. He leans in and just as he's about to kiss me licks the tip of my nose and starts laughing. Disgusted I playfully shove him on the bed and wipe my nose off on my sleeve. "You are an awful human being."
"Gonna have to try harder than that to get rid of me sweetheart. Put on something good. And I'll try not to get distracted by you too much." I put on Parks and Recreation, since it is after all the greatest tv show in history. "Ugh Parks and Rec really?" Colton questions. I look at him with daggers and say, "Get out of my house if you're going to disrespect this show."
"The office is better. Point blank."
"Damn. I knew you were too good to be true. Finally found a flaw."
"Okay it's not bad, just not as seasoned as the office."
"I won't argue with someone who's taste includes listening to Michael attempt to make everything a joke."
"That's it. You can't insult the king of comedy like that." He then jumps on top of me and mercilessly starts to tickle my sides. I start to laugh uncontrollably and scream "STOP PLEASE OH MY GOD" He doesn't let up so I have no choice. In between laughs I throw my knee up and as hard as I can into Colton's ass. This in turn forced him to land on top of me.
"You could have just asked for a kiss dude." Then kisses me yet again. Sending a million questions through my head including why this hunk of a man is on top of me kissing me. Once he pulls back, he just stares at me. "Why are you staring at me again?"
"You just have the most amazing eyes is all." My eyes were amazing, take his eyes and make them lighter and that's what my eye color was. "Thanks but I'm pretty sure yours are way more beautiful. Colton can I ask you a question?"
"Anything, except why I think the Office is better the Parks and Rec."
"No I'm serious. I thought you had a girlfriend and you were totally straightÉ" I trailed off worried about what was going to come next.
"Hmmm. I knew this was coming. I guess it's hard to explain, I am still with Macy but I've never felt a connection like you and I have. Even just today I felt something when you grabbed my hand on the Titian and I knew that something was going on here. You were so comfortable with me and didn't care about what other people thought or if they were wondering why we were hanging out together. Then on the bus it was the cutest thing when you fell asleep on me. You also pretty much shut me down when I was asking questions about you." "I'm sorry about that by the way. I just take my beauty rest seriously, it takes some work to look this good." I interject. "No, it was fine. I liked that you didn't really mind it. Then in the parking lot when I was staring at you, I don't know what came over me. I just had to kiss those perfect lips of yours. I knew that you were something else. SO, I don't know Nate, I really don't. Macy and I have pretty much been done for a while now. She just won't let me leave her; she keeps saying that she'll kill herself if I walk out on her. Or that she'd get pregnant on purpose so that I'd have no reason but to stay with her."
At a loss for words I simply say, "Wow. That is crazy."
"To say the least. But I think it's finally time to do it. I've never dated a boy before, and I don't know if you like me or if I would even be good enough to deserve you. I don't want you to think that I'm just trying to jump into a relationship because of my current one failingÉ" I grab his face with both hands and give him a gentle kiss. "I don't think that at all. I just wanted to know where your head was at. I think you're amazing and gorgeous. And you're right. I don't want to rush into anything because we have a lot of things to figure out first."
"Okay. Thank you for understanding Nate. And I don't want you to think I'm not interested. Clearly I am." After he said that we just cuddled up together and started watching tv. He kept giving me small kisses on the top of my head but eventually wondered down to where he was kissing me in the small of my neck. "You're going to start something you can't finish." I said softly moaning as he sucked lightly on my neck.
"Oh, I think that I smell a challengeÉ" He breathed into my ear causing me to moan louder then I intended. He clapped his hand over my mouth to stop me from making any more noise. Colton whispered in my ear, "Better not let your parents know what we're up to in here."
He continued to manipulate my ear rolling the lobe over his tongue and then biting it softly. I could feel myself getting hard in my pants and tried to reach down and grab it. Colton beat me too it and slapped my hand away from my aching erection. He slowly started to rub the outside of my pants up and down the shaft of my now raging boner. I was completely at his mercy and couldn't even put a thought together.
As I laid there in between his legs, rubbing up and down his thigh I felt his own erection start to push against my ass. I was cursing whoever invented jeans from allowing me to get better access. I wanted to badly to touch it, but I knew as soon as I did Colton would slap my hand away. Suddenly, Colton moved from under me and in one move had my legs on his shoulders and was grinding his hard dick against my clothed hole. Although I couldn't feel the entire thing, I knew he had to be packing at least 8.5 inches or more.
Without his hand over my mouth a started to moan again, not wanting this to happen he quickly started kissing me deep. Exploring my mouth with his tongue as he did. This went on for what felt like an eternity, not wanting it to end I pulled him closer to me so that our upper bodies were touching. I started to snake my hands up his shirt in an attempt to pull it off of him.
That's when he stopped suddenly. "I can't do this. Not yet." With that he sat up on the edge of the bed and put his head in his hands. I scoot up behind him and put my arms around his waist. He pushes my arms off of him. "Nate I'm sorry but I need to go home." At a loss for words I stand up and wait at my bedroom door for him to put his shoes on.
I walk him to his truck and stand there with my arms crossed questioning everything that happened in the last 20 minutes. He turns to me before opening his truck door. "I'm sorry Nate, I really am. It just went a little fast for me. Please don't think that I don't want for this to happen." He attempted to give me a hug, but I just stood there with my arms still crossed not wanting to give into the muscle hunk that had just played a mind game that left me confused. "Can you please hug me back?" I finally gave in and loosely wrapped my arms around his waist and let my head sink into his chest.
"Colton, I can't play mind games with you. I know you have a lot to figure out, but that doesn't mean that you get to string me along to end up getting hurt in the long run."
He then pulled back and smiled at me. "I'm not trying to play any games with you. I just need a little time to think is all. You're still the cutest human I've ever seen." Colton placed a light kiss on my forehead before getting into his truck. He rolls the window down and looks out at me. "Don't think that I'm not still into you. Because I am. I just need to think about some things before I get too far into this." Even though I wanted nothing more than to say, `Screw you I won't let you play me.' I smiled at him and said, "I know. Take your time."
As I watched him pull out of my driveway I knew that everything had changed and that my life was only going to get crazier.
------------ The next morning
I woke up to the sound of my alarm ringing in my ear. I had no desire to get up specially to see Colton at school today. I could live the rest of my life without having to see him honestly. I turn off my alarm and see that I have 4 missed messages, 3 missed calls and a voicemail from the devil himself. Okay maybe a bit dramatic but I was so embarrassed by what happened. Whatever it was.
Against my better judgement, I opened his text messages. They read as follows:
"Hey Nate, please pick up the phone. I want to sort this out."
"Can you please pick up" "????" After I read the messages, I listened to the voicemail that he left.
"Okay well I will take your silence as an answer. I just wanted to call and let you know that I ended things with Macy tonight after I left your house. I couldn't be with her anymore knowing that all it was doing was adding to my pain. I want you; I want to be with you. I want to fight every day to make you the happiest person on earth. I know it won't be easy, but I want to try my hardest to gain and win you over. Please just give me a simple yes or no."
I was goobsmacked, Macy and Colton were the "it" couple, they were the ones who were supposed to make it out of high school and get married one day. They were the ones who would come back 20 years from now and still be together with 3 perfect kids. I didn't know what to do. So I did what any logical person would do. I called him. Like the dumb bitch I am obviously. I mean what did I think would come from this? Hello? Am I stupid or just dumb.
He answered on the first ring.
"HeyÉ" I said shortly.
"Hey beautiful, did you get my text messages?"
"I did, I'm sorry that I didn't get them or your calls. I tend to sleep like a rock, or so I've been told." I say trying to lighten the mood.
"Sorry that I blew up your phone. I was kind of freaking out and had no one else to talk to. You're the only one I wanted to talk to." There was a long pause before I finally let in and decided to go with the flow as my mom told me.
"Colton, I don't really know what to say. I just want to be with you. I want to be happy. If you can make me happy then so be it."
"Okay, I totally understand that. Hey, look out your window."
Confused as to why he would be saying that. I look out and to my surprise sitting outside was Colton's truck. "What are you doing here?"
"Well I live like two minutes away, so I figured that I would come over so we could have breakfast together. I got in my truck as soon as you answered the phone."
"You are insane." I say while laughing. "Are you going to sit in your truck or come inside?" I met him at the front door and smiled as he said, "God bless America I'm so glad that you answered."
"And if I had said No?" I said while putting my hands on my hips.
"Then I would have looked like a total creep." He then leaned in and gave me a gentle kiss on the lips, not too hard but just enough force to feel that he really meant it. "And I brought donuts. So, I hope you like them."
"How the hell did you have time to get donuts? And if you got the wrong kind then I'm kicking you out." I say leading us to the kitchen where my Dad has just started to cook breakfast. "Well I went and got them but got enough for both of us just in case you did answer. And if you didn't answer I was just going to eat my feelings away." He says as we make our way into the kitchen.
"Hey Coach, hope you don't mind me crashing breakfast."
"Not at all Colton, how are you?" my dad asked while stirring his eggs.
"Oh, my world is turning sir." Colton then turns to me and puts his arms around my waist pulling me into a hug. I suddenly realize that I am not even close to being ready for school, breaking the hug I look at Colton and say, "I'm gonna be late! I need to shower and get dressed!"
"But what about the donuts!!??" Colton jokingly says.
"No time!" I run out of the kitchen and to my room with Colton in tow and quickly grab some clean underwear and get the shower hot so I can bathe quickly. I close the door to the bathroom before I strip down only to hear from my bedroom. "Hey! That is rude! Some of us would like to see you naked!"
I poke my head out of the door and say, "Some people will have to wait until they earn it and or pay for it." I wink at him before returning to my shower to wash off. While I was in the shower, I realized that I hadn't locked the door. I turned just in time to see the door swing open and a full-grown man child sprint at me. Through the glass door on my shower I see him grinning at me. "So now you have no choice but to let me see."
"Again, not until you earn and or pay for it." I wink as I grab my towel from on top of the door, thankfully the doors to the shower were half-way frosted so all he could really see was from my waist up. I dried off then wrapped the towel around my waist as I stepped out of the shower.
Colton gave me the biggest puppy dog eyes as he sat on my counter. "Pwwwease" He pleaded.
"No you crackhead. Not right now. Now get out of here before I kick you out for good." Still trying to keep up the sad puppy dog look he hung his head and walked out into my room. Making sure to add his feet dragging so that it might persuade me to change my mind. I locked the door behind him so he wouldn't get any bright ideas.
Deciding to play into his game after he left, I finished drying off, raked a comb through my hair and put my underwear on and wrapped the towel back around my waist. Walking into the room I shook my hips back and forth. "Oh hell yes. I do get to see my sexy boy naked." Colton says with a smile. Did he just say my? Or am I dreaming things up.
"Why don't you help me take it off then." I slid up to Colton and ran my hands over his chest. He places his hands on my waist and swiftly pulls down the towel to reveal the underwear I have on.
"That is the cruelest joke ever." Colton says with disappointment all over his face. I lean in and give him a soft kiss. He kisses me back and then we start making out and fall onto the bed. I straddle him and let his tongue into my mouth. After our tongues wrestle around for a little bit I pull back and look into his eyes. "I'm sorry. But sex is a big deal to me. I don't want to just jump into bed because we're super attracted to each other. I'm not saying it won't happen soon, but I need some time first."
I look at my phone and realize that we are so late to school. I jump up and grab some blue jeans and a T-shirt to wear that day. "Come on cutie, I'll let you drive me to school."
Once we got to the school we agreed to meet back up for lunch. As I jumped out of Colton's truck I turned and saw Kason walking towards me. "So, Nate, you wanna tell me why the fuck you're getting out of Colton's truck?"
"Well, he lives near me and my truck is in the shop right now." A flat out lie but I knew that Kason would totally buy it.
"Hmm I guess that could be true. Come one were late for Mrs. Walters class."
The day pretty much went on without anything too crazy happening. Since it was the end of the school year. There wasn't too much work to be done. Mostly we were just here because the state told us we had to. When the 5th period bell rang for lunch we all departed for the lunchroom. Being in the drama club we all usually ate together in the theatre room, but I had told Colton we could at least see each other for a little bit. As I walked up to the table, he was sitting at he quickly got up and came over to me. "Hey beautiful. How's your day?"
"Boring. To say the least. But better now."
"Do you trust me?" Colton ask me. "The jury is still out on that, but I'll play along." I answer, what could this boy be up to I wonder.
"Okay, good. Follow me." A million questions ran through my head as I walked to the front doors of the school with him. "Um, Colton? Where are we going?"
He looked at me and said, "I told you to trust me." I followed him to his truck and got into the passenger seat. I opened my mouth to question him again but was met by his lips instead. After a rather passionate kiss. He pulled back and said, "I've waited all day to do that. Let's go to your house. No one is there right?"
"We still have three more class periods Colton."
"I have it under control. They guys at the guard shack never stop me and ask me where I'm going. Plus, it's the end of the school year. We can afford to skip three classes."
"Okay well, your parents aren't teachers. So, when my parents kill me, I hope you can live with yourself." I quip at him. "Oh hush. It won't be that bad. And your parents already love me. Might as well give them a reason not to." He says while grabbing my hand.
"Sooo, did you see Macy today?" I ask. I was actually curious since we went to a small school and I didn't see her at the school today.
"She wasn't there. Her mom texted me today and said that she couldn't believe that I would do that to her. Or their family. That I was like a son to them. Basically, a big fuck you to me."
I started to gently rub Colton's hand as we pulled into my house. We sat there in silence for a few minutes before I said, "Well, I can't speak on how you're feeling but I want you to know that I'm here for you, and my family is here for you. Even if you do steal me away from school." I added a little hand squeeze to the end of that.
"Thank you, Nate. I really appreciate that. I really need you now more than ever." We got out of the truck and went into my room. I pulled Colton close to me and started to give him soft kisses. Those obviously turned more passionate and then Colton pushed me onto the bed and climbed on top of me.
I pulled my legs up and allowed Colton to straddle me and slowly started to push his growing erection against my ass. I pulled at the bottom of his shirt and pulled away so that he could take it all the way off. I slowly started to feel up his ripped abs to his gorgeous sculpted pecs. With his hands around my neck I let out a small moan. Colton moved from my mouth to my ear and started to nibble hard on my ear lobe. From there he breathed deep into my ear and said, "I want you. Now." With an animalistic growl that turned me on to the point where I almost begged him, "I need you inside me."
He basically ripped my pants off of me and in one move had my waiting hole pointed up at the sky. He dove in with his tongue and started to eat me out. It felt like he was trying his best to put his entire tongue inside me. I let out a loud moan which gained a hard slap from Colton's strong hand. I moaned again and begged, "Hmmm spank me harder." I had never said anything like that before, so it kind of shocked me.
After a couple of minutes of this He flipped me over and said, "I think it's my turn for some pleasure." Although I was not excited that the oral manipulations on my hole were gone, I was excited to get a chance to suck his beautiful dick.
It was my turn to take charge, I flipped Colton on his back and slowly undid his belt and unbuttoning his jeans, never breaking eye contact with him as I went. "Nate, you're killing me here." With saying that he ripped his pants the rest of the way off. As he did this his dick slapped him in his belly button. Yes, it was that big. Remember when I said it had to be at least 8.5? I'm gonna say it was an easy 9 or so.
As I started to run my hands up and down his beautiful member, I started to lean in and took the head in my warm mouth. I heard Colton audibly gasp so I knew I was doing something right. I had never done this before but had watched plenty of gay porn to learn. As I started to make my way up and down his shaft his moans started to get louder.
Feeling more confident I made my way further down his cock taking more of it into my throat then I thought possible. Once I built up a nice rhythm I raised up to where only the head was in my mouth and started to stroke his cock with my hand and fondle his big balls with the other. I decided to work my magic and flick my tongue all around the head of his dick causing him to basically scream.
After a few moments of doing this I could tell Colton couldn't take much more and then impaled myself on his dick taking as much as I could into the back of my throat. My eyes started to water as I got to the base, I could feel the prickly pubic hairs that had to have just been shaved. Colton let out an animalistic growl and then grabbed my head with both of his strong arms.
He started to furiously fuck my face with his dick going in and out of my mouth so fast it was all I could do to not pass out. Colton was now bucking his hips as fast as he could pushing his big dick in and out of my mouth. Before I knew it, he yells out, "I'm about to cum!!!" Determined to give him the best head of his life I shoved my face towards the base of his cock and prepared to take his load into my throat. I felt his cock start to pulse in my throat and was met by shot after shot of his hot and thick load. I lost count after 7. I quickly gulped down his load and laid back trying to catch my breath.
"Not so fast champ. You need to cum too." Colton says while winking at me. He then sticks a finger into his mouth to lube it up. Confused as to what he was about to do I just laid there slowly stroking my own 7 inch dick. Without warning Colton then sticks the slick finger to the hilt into my hole. I gasp out and moan so loud I'm sure the neighbors heard. He then starts to quickly fuck his finger in and out of my hole.
I pick up the pace as he starts to play with my balls as well, I could feel my impending orgasm start to approach. Not wanting it to end I tried to slow down. Colton took that as an invite and took over jerking me off. It didn't even take 3 strokes for me to blow a massive load out of nowhere. I bucked my hips to meet Colton's strong hand as I shot load after load all over my chest and torso.
Sitting there coming down from my orgasmic high, Colton looks at me with the sweetest look and says, "That was absolutely amazing." I reach up and pull him into me and kiss him gently.
I get up and grab his hand, "Come on big boy lets go shower." As we made our way to the shower, I pinched myself because I must have been dreaming.