Make sure to support nifty.org with a donation. I know I've loved reading these stories for years and now am writing for you. In fact I'm wearing a wrestling singlet as I write this...
A few days after the threeway with Dave, Scott and I ran into each other outside our houses after practice.
"Hey there stud. How are you?" he asked.
"Not bad, practice kicked my ass today but I'll survive" I replied.
"Well I hope your ass is okay because I was wondering if we could hangout again later" Scott said.
"Oh I think I can rally up some energy" I said.
"How about I come over in an hour or so?" he asked.
"Works for me, house is empty for the evening so we'll have a few hours" I said.
"Cool, I'll text you in bit. By the way, all those squats are making a big difference" he said while he slapped my ass and then walked away.
The idea of doing any homework was now impossible as I could only think about what was to come or more likely, cum. I headed in to get ready. I did a full body cleanse, shaved and showered.
A little while Scott texted as promised, "Be there in 30, wear that singlet from last time" he wrote.
I was hard before even pulling it of the drawer. I slipped into it and waited downstairs. When he rang the bell, I greeted him at the door in just my singlet.
"Hot, let me inside before someone sees anything" he said.
I led him upstairs to my room. When I entered my room I turned around to face him. He already had his jacket and shirt off and I could see he was wearing one of his old team singlets. I reached for the button on his jeans and freed him of his pants. I got on my knees to slip the pants off of his feet.
I looked up and he was stroking his hard cock through his singlet. I reached up and cupped his cock and balls.
"Get up here and kiss me" he demanded.
Scott pulled us in close for a kiss. He had his tongue down my throat while his hands rubbed my back and moved down to my ass. As he grabbed my ass cheeks our cocks pressed against each other's. I ran my hands along his upper back, massaging his firm body while we continued to kiss.
Scott nudged us towards the bed and I fell back when I felt the mattress against the back of my legs. He climbed on top of me.
"I think I want to do something with you. Can I try and fuck you?" Scott sheepishly asked.
"You can do more than try" I replied.
"You know what I mean. I'd like you to be my first" he said.
I kissed him on the lips and said "You're going to love it, just follow my lead as it takes some patience to start if you know what I mean".
I grabbed the strap of his singlet and began to pull it off of his shoulder. He took the hint and pulled the other strap off and peeled the singlet down his torso. He was all pumped up from today's weight training and was quite the sight.
I pulled my singlet down to my waist and got out from underneath him. I fetched the lube and went back to the bed where Scott was laying on his back rubbing the head of his hard cock. I stripped out my singlet and climbed up on him. I straddled his body so that I could sit on his cock when ready.
Scott grabbed the lube and squirted some on his cock. He rubbed it all over the length of it and then grabbed my cock with the excess amount. I took the lube from him and slicked up my hole. I reached down and rubbed the excess on his balls which he really liked.
I grabbed his cock and guided him to my hole. I sat on the head and began to work his cock into me.
"Oh wow, it is even better than your mouth" he said.
I gently rode his cock up and down to get him deeper inside me. It felt really good without much effort. I leaned down and kissed him.
He started out very gentle only using the top half of his cock inside me. I coaxed him to go deeper by pushing down on his cock with my ass. He worked his way in until he was fully inside of me. I switched my legs so my feet were flat on the bed on both sides of him and this allowed him to go deeper. I could feel him hitting my inner ring. Fuck he was deep in me and it felt amazing. I sat up straight and reached behind me. I held his balls in one hand and massaged his balls gently. He moaned and continued to fuck me. Scott became a little bolder and made more frequent noises. He also picked up his pace and fucked me more assertively. He fucked me like that for a few more minutes.
"Let's change it up, I'll lay on my back and you can fuck me from the top" I said.
I let his cock slide out and rolled on my back. I lifted my legs in the air and told him to get in position. Scott slipped his cock back into me and I could really feel his thickness when he was balls deep in me.
Scott took control and began to fuck me faster. My cock was squeezed between us gushing out precum as he continued to nail my prostate. After a period of whimpers and grunts, he was strangely silent as he focused on fucking me.
"Dude I am going to cum soon" he said.
"Cum for me, fuck it into me" I replied.
Scott's increased pace led to his big balls slapping against me. He thrusted the length of his cock into me a few more times and then let out a deep, gutteral groan as he climaxed. His cock pulsed inside of me as he launched his cum into me. I grabbed my cock and stroked it and only after a few strokes I shot my load all over my chest and abs.
He laid on me while he caught his breath. His cock continued to twitch inside of me and once that subsided, he slipped out of my hole. The cum on my stomach smeared between both of us making us stick together which was an added turn-on.
"Wooh, I have never cum like that. It was intense. What's it like for you?" Scott asked.
"It also feels incredible but different. You've got a big dick and it stimulates me in a few ways. Maybe someday you'll find out what it is like" I replied.
He had all sorts of questions about anal sex so I did my best with my limited experience. I told him the main thing was to communicate with your partner, respect the bottom's wishes and you'll be rewarded with a fantastic fuck.
"Dude I am hungry, what you got to eat?" he asked.
Ahh, there was the Scott I knew. A hot fuck had boosted his confidence and the hunger brought out his bro side a little. We slipped our singlets on partially and headed down to the kitchen. We made sandwiches, sat at the table and ate. Then he had more questions. When he stood up to clean his plate I could see he was hard again. Perhaps the Q & A got him horny. I got up and stood next to him by the sink. After throwing stuff in the dishwasher I grabbed his hard cock.
"Maybe you'd like to go back upstairs?" I asked.
"I was hoping, if it is okay, I brought something you might like" he replied.
When we got into my room, he pulled out a couple of speedos from the pocket of his jacket.
"Mind putting one of these on, haven't worn them in a long while" Scott said with a smile.
"I did swimming when I was younger but switched to wrestling. I kept a couple of speedos just in case I went back to it".
He handed me a faded black speedo. I slipped out of my singlet and put it on. My hard cock was stretching the front pouch even before I tied the strings. For Scott, you could tell he had grown since his swimming days as his speedo was a tight fit, especially when his hard, fat cock was inside in the tiny speedo.
"Guess I have wanted to do this for a while now" he said as he rubbed the length of my cock. He stroked his speedo-wrapped cock as he continued to stroke me. I ran my hand up the side of his torso and across his chest. I pressed my speedo bulge against his and reached behind to rub his bubble butt.
"You know you have an amazing ass in these. Look behind you in the mirror" I said.
"Not bad" he chuckled as he looked in the mirror.
"I think I told you how the swim team used to hang at our pool" he said.
I nodded my head and let him continue.
"I always hung around when they visited. Never thought about it then but something made me happy when they were around. Seeing their athletic builds and wondering if I'd look like them some day" he added.
"That was before you moved here but from what I can tell, you did that and then some" I said as I gently grabbed his waist.
"Ha, thanks. Slide your cock against mine" Scott said.
He looked down watching our speedo wrapped cocks grind against each other. He rubbed the tip of my cock and slid his thumb through my precum in a circular motion. It was heaven so I did the same to him.
"OH. That's perfect. Keep doing that, wow" he panted.
I got on my knees and replaced my tongue for thumb. I enveloped the tip of his cock. I could taste the sweetness of precum mixed with a little sweat. I could smell his sweat and cum from before. Perhaps there was some lingering odors if he ever came in his speedos in the past (I will need to ask him about that later hehe).
"You're going to make me cum, oh fuck!" he exclaimed.
With that he began to cum in his speedo. I tasted the warm cum as it soaked through his speedo. I licked up what I could and continued to run my tongue and mouth along his cock. He pulled me up and kissed me.
"Now how about I help you finish?" he asked.
I did not even have a chance to respond as he got down to his knees. He rubbed my cock and balls with both hands. He stared intently as he gripped my speedo covered cock. I think he was realizing a few things turned him on so I just let it happen. Later on I would realize that he was unlocking a fetish right before my eyes. I rubbed the top of his head and then his neck. I wanted him to know he was doing really well and that whatever he needed right now, I was going to give it to him.
Scott began to tongue the head of my cock. The material was completely soaked by his spit and my precum. Slowly, he made his way down the length of my cock. When he reached my balls he paused.
As he looked up at me he asked "Can we do this in the shower?".
"Yes of course" I replied.
I turned on the shower and warmed up the water. As I held my hand in the stream of water, he approached me and groped my bulge.
I stepped in first and started to slip out of my speedo.
"Wait, leave `em on" he stated.
"So you like a wet speedo? It's totally okay if you do" I asked as rubbed his right nipple.
"Yes, I think so" he said hesitantly.
Scott stepped into the shower. He went down on his knees and resumed tonguing my cock. He stopped and looked while stroking my cock and balls. When I looked down, I could see he was stroking his cock through his speedo. He was already hard again.
He grabbed the top of my speedo with both hands. He reached in and grabbed my cock. Then he lifted it out of the speedo and pulled the suit to just behind my balls. Scott stopped being subtle and dove onto my cock. He had the whole thing in him until he coughed a little from chocking on my cock. Then he slowed down a little and worked my cock.
I held the back of his head and pumped my hips forward. He was more comfortable taking the entire length after getting settled. He now had his cock out of the suit and was stroking feverishly. Seeing how turned on he was began to impact me. I told him I needed to cum. He slid his hand between my legs and started to rub my hole. That was it, I began to cum. He continued to suck me and even swallowed my cum. He then grunted and began to cum on the floor of the shower. I pulled my cock out of his mouth as it was beginning to be too much stimulation for me.
Scott stood up and slipped my cock back into the speedo and then did the same to himself. He reached for the soap and lathered up my body. He rubbed the outside of my suit and then reached in to clean my cock. I rubbed his cock and then added some soap to my hand. We rubbed each other's bodies a little more and then rinsed off.
As we toweled off he said "Why haven't I done this sooner? That was something else" Scott said.
"I am glad you brought those seems like we both enjoyed them" I said.
"After seeing Dave's bag of stuff the other day. I figured I could bring `em. Thanks for going along with it" he said.
"Anytime" I said as I reached for a hug. "You should wear one under your singlet someday" I added.
"That would be hot but I'd pop an instant boner regardless of who was around" he said with a laugh.
He wrapped his arms around me and pulled me in for a hug. We held each other naked for a little while and then moved to the bed. We lay there and talked a little more. I hated to budge him out of the bed but I had work to do before the next day. Fortunately he did too so we called it a night. He slipped back into his singlet and clothes so I had a parting vision of see him gearing up one more time.
To be continued...