Make sure to support nifty.org with a donation. I know I've loved reading these stories for years.
The last couple of weeks have been pretty interesting with my neighbor Scott's discovery that he likes guys too. We have texted back and forth as he has lots of questions and thoughts. Long story short, he is into guys now but still dates a female classmate off and on. He confessed that she jerked him off a couple times but that is all he's ever done sexually. He said my blowjob was the best thing he's ever done so kudos to me, I guess.
At school and practice, Scott kept a distance. He tried to act like he did before with me but on the rare occasion when no one is around he'll rub my shoulders or show other signs of physical intimacy. Dave and Dylan remain clueless and on several occasions I almost slipped up but have kept things quiet regarding Scott. At practice, Dave strongly hinted that we need to hang out again with or without Dylan. He mentioned he bought some new gear that we needed to try. I promised him we would hang real soon and that my door is always open. Of course he winked, lightly slapped me on the ass and said "Oh don't I know it!". I blushed and returned to drills.
After practice, Scott texted to see if I could help him with something after practice. I said he could come over after dinner. I figured he was itching for a blowjob and since I love providing them, I figured I would enable him. I also made sure I was ready for anything, just in case he was feeling bold enough to fuck.
Scott came over and we talked in my bedroom. He strolled in wearing long gym shorts and a t-shirt. He apologized for being cold in public but didn't want to take any chances of someone seeing us interact too much. We agreed that as neighbors we could do a little more than we have in the past in public but no physical stuff.
So I asked Scott what he needed help with. He started by asking questions about my sexual past which I was hesitant to discuss who I have been with. I lied and said summer camp was where I met someone. I told him about fucking and being fucked which he said might not be his thing. I talked about finding things online on gay health and suggested some porn sites he might like.
"I really liked how smooth you were. If you don't mind, can you help me shave some things?" Scott asked.
"Do you think anyone will say anything? You know in the showers or locker room" he said.
"I tend to avoid busy times in the shower but if anyone says something, I tell them it makes sex better. They usually get uncomfortable and move on" I said.
"Do you want to do this now?" I replied.
His huge smile answered my question. I closed the bedroom door and told him we could help each other. We went into my bathroom and I closed the door except for a crack to prevent it getting too stuffy in there. He stripped down to a tight pair of blue Nike compression shorts. I stripped down to my compression gear, which I deliberately chose to wear in case things went beyond a conversation. It was an off brand of compression shorts that were a thin, white material and no stitching across the bulge. It left nothing to the imagination and became translucent when wet. My cock started to get hard before my pants passed my knees. Scott also was showing a semi in his compression shorts.
He reached out and rubbed my bulge between his fingers. I was hard before he even touched me and had to adjust my cock in my shorts. I reached for his bulge and rubbed the head of his cock between my fingers and thumb. His cock began to stretch the compression shorts. I reached in and adjusted his cock so it ran lengthwise and I ran my finger along the bottom side of his cock which for me is pretty sensitive, especially when encased in spandex. Scott leaned his head back and uttered a quiet moan.
"We'll never get anything done at this rate so let's get started. I'll take care of you later" I instructed.
I told him a quick plan, begin with trimmers and then switch to shaving oil and a razor. I put down a towel on the floor and got on my knees to start. I told Scott to get naked and he slipped the shorts off. I set them aside and began to trim the hair from all around his thighs. I figured I would work my way towards his cock and then have my way with him. He didn't have any hair on his ass cheeks or back and he had a thin treasure trail so I quickly moved on to his pubes. I grabbed a hold of his hard cock to keep it out of the way. I licked the top of it to tease him a little. I clipped away starting at the top and worked downwards towards his cock. Pretty soon his pubes were gone and he was feeling himself and commenting on the difference. I used the trimmers carefully on his balls to make the shaving easier. I could smell his clean sweat eminating from him. I told him to spread his legs and removed any visible hair between his legs. I ran my finger along his perineum, partly to see how much hair was there but also to gauge his reaction. He had a little hair and let out a little gasp when I rubbed back on forth just behind his ball sack.
"So much more sensitive when someone else touches there, wow" he said.
I looked up at him and just smiled. Then I went back to the task at hand. I brushed away the excess hair and told him it was time for shaving. I used a face cloth to moisten his skin. I pumped the oil into the palm of my hand and began to rub it on his balls. I grabbed the base of his cock and stroked his hard cock with the oil. He moaned but I told him he'd have to wait until after the shaving for anything more. He objected a little when I oiled up the crack of his ass but I told him to trust me as it would feel great and it would even everything out for a clean look.
I shaved his balls and had him squat for the remainder. I rubbed his hole with oil and he let out that now familiar gasp. Since he didn't object. I briefly caressed his hole and then I shaved it until he was completely smooth. I washed him off with soap and applied a light layer of moisturizer. By this point his cock was dripping with precum. I squeezed the head of his cock to get more precum on my finger and then tasted his precum while looking him in the eyes.
"I think it is my turn now" I said while standing up.
Scott got on his knees and peeled my shorts off. My hard cock stood straight out and he wrapped his hand around it and stroked me a few times.
"Wow you are really wet" he exclaimed.
"Dude, you have no idea what a turn on it was to be up close and touching you. On top of that handling your cock and shaving you smooth. Also, wait until you slip on a singlet or something tight, you are going to love the feeling" I said.
Since I shave routinely these days I only needed a touch up. I walked him through how I do it and he did a pretty good job. He went a little overboard with the oil but since it felt great, I wasn't going to complain. Scott stroked my cock on occasion but tried to focus on shaving me. I could tell he was enjoying this because his cock remained rock hard the entire time and a thin stream of precum dripped to the floor.
When it came time to shave my ass, he hesitated. I suggested I bend over and spread my cheeks but I sensed that might be too much for him. I took over and shaved my hole as I usually do. Then he washed my cock and balls clean while on his knees.
Scott grabbed my cock and started to rub the head with his thumb. He used his thumb to spread my precum all over the tip. He stuck his tongue out and licked the very end of my cock.
"Salty and a little sweet" Scott said.
Scott started to get a little bolder and took more of my cock into his mouth. He was getting into a good rhythm and I rubbed the back of his head. I moaned and told him that he was doing an amazing job for his first time. He was able to get the entire length of my cock down his throat a few times.
We were both totally into it when out of nowhere Dave popped his head in the door. He was saying something to me before he saw what was going on.
"Hey there, I was bored at...holy fuck!" he shrieked.
Scott immediately let go of my cock. His cock was rock hard and he grabbed a towel to cover himself. He had a look of shock on his face but there was no way to lie about what we were doing.
"Wait Scott, it is okay. He's why I know how to do all this stuff" I said.
"I think I need a minute" Scott said.
Dave and I went into the bedroom and Scott closed the bathroom door. I grabbed a pair of shorts to throw on.
I filled Dave in on the single encounter I had with Scott and emphasized that he was brand new to discovering this other part of him. I suggested maybe he leave so Scott could calm down and head home if needed.
"Hey Scott, Dave's going to leave. He and I won't say anything especially considering we are all in the same boat so to speak" I said.
From behind the door, Scott replied "No one has to leave, hang on".
Scott came out of the bathroom. He had put on his compression shorts and had lost his hard on. He grabbed his shirt off of the bed and put it on.
"I am so, so sorry Scott. I am so used to popping by unannounced and had no idea I would walk in on you two" Dave said.
"It is okay, one thing kind of led to another" Scott replied.
Scott sat on the bed looking a little indecisive. I put my hand on his knee and reassured him that everything would be fine. He put his hand on top of mine and agreed.
"Damn Scott, you are packing more than I expected! How do you squeeze into a singlet?" Dave asked.
"I usually wear extra tight compression shorts underneath and avoid any compromising situations. Up until recently I have never popped a boner in a singlet but this guy changed that for me" he said pointing a thumb at me.
"Also, these shorts feel totally different after shaving, kind of hot" said Scott.
"What had you all eager to come over unannounced Dave?" I asked.
"Oh I got some gear in the mail, thought I would get your opinion" Dave replied with a smile.
Dave opened his backpack and pulled out a few things. The first were some singlets mixed in with a few other types of athletic gear.
Scott started to realize that Dave and I were very open with each other. He sat on the bed close to Dave to look at what Dave brought.
"So you guys have been having sex, like this whole season? I realized you were friends but had no idea you were fucking each other" he said shaking his head while smiling.
Scott picked up a speedo and jockstrap from Dave's assortment. He looked at them and felt the material of each.
"Wait, you said a singlet feels great after shaving. Let me try one of yours on" Scott said.
I went to my dresser and pulled out a couple of singlets. I threw him the one I thought might fit better (i.e., tighter). Scott took it and went into the bathroom. Dave and I looked at each other and I shrugged my shoulders not knowing what to expect. I looked at Dave's new singlets. They were not a regular competition brand but something sexier. They were cut lower in the chest and the legs were a little shorter than anything I have. Also the material was sleeker.
"I did some hunting around online and found a couple brands that clearly target gays. I think you will really like these. I have one on underneath and was hoping we could have a little fun tonight. Obviously, the last thing I expected was to walk in on you getting your dick sucked" he said while shaking his head.
"These last few days have been really unexpected. Hell this past year has been mindblowing" I said.
As we were giggling about things, Scott stepped out of the bathroom. He was just in my singlet and by the looks of his swollen cock, he was turned on by wearing it and/or this whole situation. There was a whole other level of stimulation for me seeing him in my singlet. I knew that I would be replaying this sight in my head many times in the future. That tight, muscular body and thick cock was an amazing thing to see wrapped in tight spandex. It was great to finally be able to look at him, look at his hot body and hard, veiny cock without worrying about someone catching me.
"Dave, did I hear you say you are already wearing a singlet? Is that a thing for you guys?" Scott asked.
"I first wore one when Dave was giving me wrestling lessons. I got hard while wrestling him. It was really hot. He got hard too so we figured out we were into each other. We have been using them on occasion ever since" I replied.
"Well maybe you can show me what you mean" said Scott.
"Are you sure? You are processing a lot lately. There's no rush" I said.
"Nah, it is fine. I can see you trust each other. I may not want to do anything but checking each other out in singlets is okay with me" Scott said.
Dave stood up and pulled off his shirt. He had on a bright blue singlet with gold trim. It had a `N2N' patch on the front. Dave unbuttoned his jeans and pulled them down. When he stood up, he was sporting a hard on and had already been leaking precum through the material. I grabbed one of Dave's new singlets, stripped naked and put it on. It was a tight fit and the singlet cupped my balls and cock really well. I adjusted my hard cock and the straps to make it fit right. My freshly shaven body made the snug fit extra stimulating.
Scott looked at me and then at Dave. He rubbed his balls and cock through the spandex, stroking his cock.
"How does it feel now that you are shaven?" I asked Scott.
"It feels too good. I am going to be hard at practice and it is all your fault." he replied.
I walked closer to him and asked if I could touch him. Instead of speaking, he lifted his arms. He placed one on my shoulder and gently pulled me towards him while he rubbed his cock with the other. I got right up next to him and felt the material along his back. I ran my hand down to his firm ass. I rested my hand on his lower back and rubbed his abs with my other hand. I then grabbed his cock and stroked him a couple of times. Dave came over to me and put his arm around my waist and stroked my hard cock through the singlet. Scott reached in between us and rubbed the tip of Dave's cock. We moved closer towards each other and helped Scott realize the joys we have experienced.
I kissed Dave and dove in deep with my tongue. I then turned to face Scott and tried the same. He kissed me with firm lips at first but then opened his mouth and fully kissed back with tongue. Scott then grabbed Dave's chin and pulled him in for a kiss. I dropped to my knees and began to suck Scott's cock through the material while I rubbed Dave's hard cock. The two of them continued to kiss and one of them massaged the top of my head. I moved over to Dave and began to lick his leaky cock while I stroked Scott's cock. I pulled Dave's cock out through the leg of his singlet and slid the material up so that his cock and balls were fully exposed. I swallowed his cock to the base and worked it up and down. I used my hands to free Scott's big cock. I spit in my hand and lubricated the tip of Scott's cock with my saliva.
I started to take turns sucking both of their cocks. As I worked one with my mouth, I kept the other stimulated with my hand. Both of these hotties were leaking a ton of precum so it was easy to keep everything slicked up. Scott pulled me up and kissed me.
"I think someone needs a break" Scott said.
He lowered himself to his knees and replicated what he saw me doing. He pulled my cock free and tongued my cock. He leaned over and swallowed Dave's cock. I was quite impressed that he was already pulling double duty on us considering he was pretty new to all of this.
"Be careful, you are going to make me cum" Dave warned.
Scott took the hint and dialed things down a little. He stood up and pulled his singlet down and then off. He stood there buck ass naked and proceeded to strip my singlet off of me. Dave slipped his off and then we moved on to the bed. Scott and I resumed kissing. Dave leaned over and began to suck Scott's thick cock. I fingered Dave's hole which got Dave moaning.
"I think Dave wants to be fucked, care to see him take my cock?" I asked Scott.
"Oh yeah, let's see" Scott said.
I pulled out lube from under the mattress and slicked up Dave's hole. I covered my cock with lube and moved behind Dave. I pulled Dave up so he was on his hands and knees. Dave continued to suck Scott while I began to enter his ass. I slid in real easily. Scott was mesmerized watching my cock slide into Dave's ass.
"How does it feel?" he asked.
"His ass is super tight and warm, the feeling of being inside him is amazing. Likewise, when you get fucked right, it feels great" I responded.
Dave took a break from sucking to chime in, "It feels really good and ain't nothing like it, especially when someone cums inside of you" he said.
I looked up at Scott and kissed him. I caressed his chest and abs with one hand while gripping Dave's waist with my other hand. Scott reached out and rubbed my nipple. It was more sensitive than normal and made me moan in Scott's mouth. He reached for my nipple again and grazed it with his thumb. That was enough to make me reach the point of no return. I started to fuck Dave a little faster. I grabbed his hips with both hands and made sure to go as deep inside his ass as possible. That is when I started to cum. I backed away from Scott's lips and focused on my last few strokes with a few more waves of cum flooding Dave's ass. Immediately after, Scott said he was going to cum and launched his load down Dave's throat.
Once Scott's orgasm subsided, I slid out of Dave's ass and reached below to stroke Dave's cock. I had him flip over and then I slipped Dave's cock into my mouth. Dave grabbed the back of my head and began to release his load down my throat. I swallowed the whole thing and rubbed his balls as he started to calm down. I teased his hole and felt a small amount of my load oozing out his ass.
I laid down alongside Dave and Scott did the same on his other side. We laid there while our heart rates returned to normal. For Scott, I am sure a few things were running through his head. In the last week or so he went from virgin to a threeway.
I asked Scott how he was doing and he replied "I am still digesting all of this and have so many questions but one thing I know is that this was fucking hot. I have had two of the biggest orgasms this past week and have been jerking off thinking about what we did so that has me spinning" he replied.
"Don't feel you have to resolve everything. Dave and I are still sorting all of this out. I don't think there is one path for this so we've been taking it a little bit at a time" I said.
"Imagine if us three and Dyl..." Dave said but froze mid-sentence.
"Wait, Dylan? Dylan Morrison? He's into this too?" Scott practically screamed.
"Never in a million years would I ever thought he did dick! He is straight as it comes and has a lot of girls interested in him" he continued.
"Well I guess the cat is out of the bag. Good job Dave" I said with a laugh.
"Yeah, he figured us out after we shared a room on that first away trip" Dave said.
"I am sure he would have fit right in with us tonight" I said.
"Speak for yourself, he's a thick one" Dave joked.
We all laughed and continued to cuddle a while.
"So wait, you never checked out a guy until just recently" Dave asked.
"Well probably not the whole truth. I used to hang with the swim team when my brother was on it. The guys were always cool with me being around as the little bro, even when they came to use the pool. I would look at them in their speedos but never processed what I was sensing was attraction. They were usually just in speedos with everything on display and were physically strapped. I thought it was more of that they were older, more developed and some day I too would be filling out like them.
"And fill out you did!" I said as I gripped his cock loosely.
"Yeah, guess I lucked out in that department" Scott said.
I reached over Dave and ran my hand along Scott's hip and up the side of his body. As I did this I grazed Dave's abs and chest. Scott's dick began to swell again so I repositioned myself and resumed sucking Scott's cock. I pinched Dave's nipple and started stroking his cock back to a state of hardness. As I looked up at their faces, they began to kiss each other. I worked Scott's cock until it was heavily coated with my spit and his precum.
"Let's get in a circle and suck each other off" I said.
I slid between Scott's legs and Dave between mine. We adjusted to the point where we all could easily suck a dick and be sucked. I gripped Scott's cock with one hand and massaged his balls with the other. He was so smooth that he was all slicked up without much effort. Dave was working my cock and started to finger my hole with his finger. He slid his finger into me easily using spit to lube my hole.
I ran my finger between Scott's legs and approached his hole. I caressed his ass close to his hole without going in. I slowly worked my finger closer to his hole. The residual oil on his skin made it easy to massage his ass. When I touched his hole he verbally responded and lifted his leg a little which eased things for access. He seemed to enjoy the gentle stroking of his hole but I didn't push things beyond that point.
Meanwhile between a mighty blowjob and getting fingered, Dave had me ready to explode. I told him I was close but he doubled down and worked my cock faster. That is when I launched my cum down his throat. At about the same time Dave let it be known he was next. Scott pulled off of Dave's cock and began to stroke Dave's cock. Soon enough Dave erupted all over Scott's forearm and upper chest. He coated Scott really well.
Finally Scott began to cum. I swallowed the first couple of spurts and then let him finish cumming so I could see his load. He launched a few more times and his cum landed all over my cheek and hand. I licked my hand clean and slowly stroked him until his cock stopped pulsing. I wiped off my cheek and licked up as much of his load as I could.
"Dude that was fantastic" Scott exclaimed.
"I hope we can do this again" I replied.
"Oh hell yes" Dave added.
I stood up and stretched. I didn't want the moment to end but was dying of thirst. I went to the bathroom for some water and grabbed a towel. When I came back Scott was spooning Dave which was an adorable sight. I climbed in behind Scott and did my best to spoon him despite being shorter. We laid there for a little while in silence and actually fell asleep. About an hour later we were awakened by Scott's phone. His mom was texting to know where he was. She was relieved he was only next door but he had to get home ASAP.
It was an abrupt end to the evening so we said our goodbyes. It was a little late for Dave to go home so he ended up staying over, sleeping on the couch in my room (or at least that is what we told my mom). I loaned him so clothes for the next day and that hot stud wore the jockstrap to school. I had a few hot daydreams the next day thinking of what transpired and jerked off a couple of times after school.
We agreed not to say anything to Dylan so Scott could do open up when he was ready. We had another trip coming up so perhaps it would happen then.
To be continued...