Summer progressed, with Rick and I meeting frequently, and we met up with Cindy when we were able. Cindy hinted that she might be willing to go further. I met Rick one day and we went to the gas station with some quarters. We each bought a couple of condoms out of the vending machine in the rest room. We carried those things around for a few weeks. I found an old blanket that I was sure wouldn't be missed, and we picked a day when we could all get away. We met at our usual place, and I put the blanket down. We started to make out and began undressing each other. Rick sucked Cindy's right tit, and I took the left. We suckled on her brown nipples, while reaching down to feel her pussy. Rick had his finger inside her, working her up. I kissed her tight belly, and rubbed my nose in her black pubic bush. I licked her pussy. Rick moved down to join me. We alternating eating her out.
Cindy stopped us. "You guys, I think I'm ready." I threw scissors to Rick's paper, winning the chance to be first. I fumbled with the packaging of one of the condoms. Rick helped me roll it onto my dick. I got on top of Cindy, and clumsily managed to get my dickhead into her. She gasped, and winced. I asked if I hurt her. She said, "It hurt a little, but, God, don't stop!" I didn't need more encouragement. I thrust into her, hips moving back and forth. In a short time, I was cumming into the rubber. I pulled back and out. Rick wrapped his cock with another condom, and took my place. I peeled off the rubber, shining with her juices and a few streaks of blood. I lay beside Cindy and watched Rick fuck her. I caressed a small tit, listening to the sounds they were making. Cindy trembled and went limp, and Rick came about a minute later. He pulled out and lay on her other side. We tossed our used rubbers aside. I leaned over and licked his dick clean, and we kissed.
A few days later, I was at Rick's house, his mom was out, and all we could talk about was what had happened. I mean, we had actually fucked a girl! The more we talked about it, the hornier we got. We were soon naked, in his bed, stroking each other. "I want to fuck you, like I fucked Cindy," he whispered, kissing me, "Can I?" I agreed. He had me lay on my back, legs spread. He greased his pole and got on top of me, like we had lain on top of Cindy. He pushed his dick up me. I wrapped my legs around him. We kissed as he fucked me. Rick pounded me until he came. "I think I love you both," he muttered.