This story contains graphic descriptions of sexual acts so if you don't like that sort of thing, don't read it (if you don't like that sort of thing, you probably shouldn't be on this site anyway). Also, please support Nifty with your donations.
Sorry all for the delayed chapter, life has been busy, but I'd like to think it was worth the wait. As always please feel free to let me know what you think to matterotica@hotmail.co.uk
ERROR CORRECTION – In chapter 18, while the boys were talking about cock sizes Josh stated that Liam was well hung. This was an error, it should have stated James. Apologies for any confusion.
Benny Takes Control by Matt
Chapter 19
The four boys stood naked on the shore of the lake, desperately scanning the area for any sign of Benny and Corey. Alas the two youngest boys seemed to be long gone leaving the four nude teens completely stranded.
"I'm gonna kill 'em!" Nick said angrily.
"Come on, are you actually surprised by this?" Josh asked, shrugging as he patted his brother on the back. "Especially with Corey involved. It was probably his idea!"
"Fine, I'll kill them both." Nick retorted angrily, shrugging away from his brother's hand. They all stood for a few more moments, contemplating their next move.
"Hey, I've got an idea!" Warren said, surprisingly cheerfully. "I bet they're expecting us to just come running after them, so how about we mess with their plans and do something else."
The other three all turned to face Warren. "Like what?" Nick snapped. "Go for a coffee? That'd go great wouldn't it. Oh yeah, hi, excuse our nakedness, four lattes please!"
Warren stepped closer to Nick and Put his hands on the boy's arms, staring into his eyes in the moonlight. "Actually, I was thinking... maybe we could have that date we mentioned."
Suddenly Nick's angered expression softened as he considered Warren's suggestion.
"And I'm pretty sure you two wouldn't mind some time alone together either." Warren added, looking first at his big brother, then at Josh.
"That's..." Dale started, ready to immediately dismiss his little brother's suggestion. "... Actually, that's a pretty nice idea." He looked at Josh, his smooth naked body, still wet from the lake glistened as the light of the moon caught the water beading on his chest.
Josh nodded his agreement, then all three looked to Nick who just shrugged and said, "Okay then. But can we find somewhere a little less open?"
They thought for a moment. "How about the old playground!" Josh suggested, thinking back to the secluded area he had gone to on Sunday with Dale and their friends.
After a quick explanation for the two boys who had never been there, they all agreed and headed along the lake path, the four of them pairing off into couples. Josh and Dale were chatting immediately, but Nick and Warren walked along in silence. First Nick would look at Warren, but turn away when the younger boy looked back at him, then he in turn would look away when the older boy glanced round again.
Nick wanted to say something, anything, but no words would come out. As he struggled to think what to say, he felt Warren's hand take hold of his, their fingers interlocking and the thirteen-year-old moving slightly closer to his side. Suddenly the words weren't needed, the two of them simply walked along happily hand-in-hand.
"Oh my God, they're so cute." Dale said as he saw his little brother take Nick's hand.
Josh just chuckled and said nothing. 'Should I do that? Was he hinting I should do it too? Is it just a really kiddy thing to do? I wanna hold his hand. No, screw that, I wanna feel his entire body pressed up against mine. Fuck, stop thinking like that, you're making it hurt. I really need to get this lock off my cock. That key had better arrive back tomorrow. Stop thinking about that, you've got the sexiest guy in the world walking naked next to you, think about that! I'm gonna hold his hand.'
Before Josh could act on his last thought, Dale did it for him, taking hold of his hand. Josh looked down at it, then up at Dale's face and smiled as he saw the beautiful young man grinning at him.
"Can I ask you something?" Josh asked. "When did you know? That you were gay, I mean."
"Well I've pretty much been gay all my life. I always liked other boys, but it wasn't until I was about eleven that I knew there was a word for it." Dale explained. "I guess you're not quite like that."
"No." Josh replied quietly, thinking about how much things had changed in the last week. "I... never even thought about it. Looking back, being straight wasn't a choice or a cover or anything like that, it was just normal to me. I hadn't even thought about any other possibility. Then... Benny!"
"That musta been so weird, suddenly experiencing the stuff you did."
"That's an understatement!" Josh said, laughing slightly.
Dale paused for a moment, not sure whether he should ask his next question. He decided he wanted to know. "So if you could go back to last week and stop yourself babysitting Benny... would you do it?"
Josh stopped walking, jerking Dale to a standstill too as they continued to hold hands. Josh stared at him for a moment, smiled slightly and replied, "If all this hadn't happened, I wouldn't have met you, so no. Humiliation, pain, embarrassment and tears aside, I wouldn't change a thing." He let go of Dale's hand and pulled the young man into a brief but passionate kiss.
They immediately started walking again, not wanting to get too far away from their younger brothers.
Further ahead, Nick finally found the nerve to speak, the hand-holding building his confidence. "This isn't quite how I imagined our first date would be."
"No, me neither." Warren replied. "For a start I thought we'd be wearing clothes... at least at the start of it." He winked at Nick as he said the last part.
"Fuck." Nick said with an excited smile. "You have got to be the sexiest guy in the world."
"Second sexiest maybe, after you that is." Warren said back happily.
"Stop there!" Josh called out from behind them.
The two boys stopped as their older siblings caught up. Josh stepped to the side of the path and pushed a hedge aside, stepping through with Nick and Warren right behind him, Dale at the rear. None of them spoke as they made their way down the overgrown path to the old playground, but as they approached it they heard voices, moaning.
"Fuck, I think somebody else is here!" Josh whispered as he stopped walking.
As the four of them stood motionless, listening carefully it became clear there were two different moans, both sounded male though.
"We should leave." Josh whispered.
"No way." Warren replied quickly. "If there's two guys getting off in there, I wanna see!" He pushed past Nick and Josh and out into the open area of the abandoned playground.
There, in the middle of the open space, bathed in pale moonlight were two naked well-muscled men, one down on all-fours, the other knelt behind him fucking him rapidly.
"Warren, come back here!" Dale called out, chasing his little brother. As he pushed through, Nick and Josh joined him, emerging alongside Warren.
The noise they made alerted the two men who stopped and stared at the four new arrivals. Josh squinted, then took a few steps closer. The man doing the fucking looked round at him, his face coming into focus.
"Josh?!" one of them called out as they saw him.
"Liam?" Josh said in shock. Then the bottom guy looked round too. "Ryan? What the fuck..."
THREE DAYS EARLIER. SUNDAY AFTERNOON
By the time Ryan and Liam had left the park, the alcohol they had consumed throughout the day had really started to kick in. They had been talking together loudly all the way as they staggered along, weaving from side to side and occasionally knocking into each other.
"Dude, that was... that was so funny seeing you... run round the lake." Liam laughed heavily as he spoke.
Ryan was laughing too, the embarrassment now forgotten in the drunken haze. "Yeah, I passed some old bird... and she... nearly had a heart attack. Can't believe I.. lost to Josh though." his words were slurring quite heavily.
"Fuuuuuck. Josh is gay." Liam said, suddenly remembering his friend's revelation.
"Imagine if he'd been gay in school... we woulda kicked his ass." Ryan said, the drunkenness making it impossible for Liam to tell whether he was proud of the fact, or ashamed of it.
"Whatever... doesn't matter now..." Liam shrugged, stepping aside and barely missing a lamp-post.
"Guess not. Today was fun." Ryan said. He stopped walking to lean against a tree on the side of the path.
"Yeah, except the gay bits." Liam said, stopping and turning to face his friend. "You ever tell anyone you... did what you did to me and I'll fucking kill you!"
Ryan started laughing. "I'm so scared."
"You don't think I can take you?" Liam said, moving closer to Ryan. In his drunken state he moved a little too close and fell forward against him.
Ryan's arms immediately shot up, catching his staggering friend, then without a moment's hesitation, pulled him into a kiss.
Liam's eyes opened wide as he raised his arms and pushed against Ryan's chest, breaking the kiss and sending himself flying backwards. He fell to the ground and sat looking up at Ryan in shock. "What the fuck, dude!?" he called out.
"I thought you were trying to kiss me." Ryan said, the shock of the kiss and Liam's reaction suddenly sobering him a little.
"Why would I wanna kiss you?" Liam shouted back.
"But... I just..." Ryan stuttered, then his face screwed up in anger. "Forget it, just fuck off." He stormed off down the street, leaving Liam sat on the ground, dazed and confused.
By the time Ryan got home his anger had built into an all-consuming rage. His housemate was out so the house was empty, which was probably a good thing. He made his way into his home gym and started punching at the heavy bag hanging from the ceiling in the middle of the room.
With each punch, an image popped into his head. Dale standing there naked. PUNCH. Josh winning their bet. PUNCH. Himself running naked. PUNCH. Josh sucking on his dick. PUNCH. His twitching cock emerging from Josh's mouth and shooting a load. PUNCH. Grabbing Liam's cock. PUNCH. Leaning against his naked friend post-orgasm. PUNCH. Kissing Liam. PUNCH. Kissing Liam. PUNCH. Kissing Liam. PUNCH PUNCH PUNCH PUNCH.
Ryan staggered forward and grabbed hold of the bag for support, almost hugging it. In his fury he had not even noticed that tears were streaming down his face. Now he stood there, panting heavily, his face wet, his fists and arms sore from the aggressive punches and still all he could think about was kissing Liam. Why had he done it? He had kissed his friend, not the other way round.
"Fuck fuck fuck fuck." he muttered to himself, gently tapping his fist against the bag.
He made his way into his bedroom, lay on the bed and fell asleep in moments.
SUNDAY NIGHT
Ryan awoke, still in exactly the same position as when he had flopped onto the bed. It was dark outside now so he looked at the clock and saw it was approaching ten. He went and got some water and aspirin from the kitchen, a slight hangover already starting to kick in. Heading back into his room he stripped off his clothes, lay back down and picked up his phone.
He wrote out a text message to Liam. [HEY DUDE, SORRY ABOUT THE KISS, MUSTA BEEN THE ALCOHOL. WE OK?] He read it before hitting send then deleted it in frustration.
He tried again. [HEY, YOU OK? SORRY I RAN OFF, I'M KINDA MESSED UP RIGHT NOW] Deleted again.
Another try. [I'M NOT SORRY I KISSED YOU] He stared at the message. He had meant to say 'I'm sorry I kissed you', but somehow it had come out differently. He actually considered pressing send, which only confused him more. Eventually he deleted that message too then opened up his favourite porn app on his phone.
He lay there watching his two of his favourite porn stars sucking on each other's tits. His right hand reached downwards to his rapidly engorging cock, fingers wrapping around it. He started stroking as the two girls in the video moved into a 69. He closed his eyes as he wanked, imagining himself between the two girls, their tongues on his body, working their way down to suck on his cock. Suddenly, it wasn't the two girls, it was Josh and Liam. Josh was sucking on his swollen organ while Liam kissed his way up the young man's muscled chest, up his shoulder, his neck, his jaw. Just as their lips were about to meet, he opened his eyes and the orgasm began.
He stroked his way through the orgasm, his continuing stimulation making him gasp with pleasure as he covered his stomach with thick white goo. When it died down, he let go of the softening meat. He had just wanked thinking about his two best friends and he couldn't deny the fact that it had been absolutely amazing, but then the guilt and shame crept in. He told himself over and over that it had been the two girls who had got him turned on, Josh and Liam had only appeared at the end and by then he was going to cum either way. He knew he didn't believe his own lies, but it was enough comfort to alleviate his shame and allow him to drop off to sleep.
MONDAY MORNING
As Ryan awoke, he rubbed his hand down his body, feeling the dried-on remnants of his pre-sleep orgasm on his stomach. He reached over and grabbed his phone, hoping to see a message from Liam but nothing had been received.
[MORNING] he sent quickly to his best friend. He wanted to say more, even if he didn't know what, but he figured that was a good start.
By the time he had showered and returned to his bedroom he was hoping there would be a reply, but still nothing.
MONDAY AFTERNOON
[HEY, YOU OK?] Ryan sent, getting worried that he had yet to hear nothing from Liam. The day had been dragging, everything he did seeming like nothing more than an attempt at distracting himself.
Ryan was trying so hard to focus on waiting for Liam's reply that it was almost helping him forget what else was on his mind. Almost. Every now and then a stray thought would creep in. 'You wanked him off.' 'You kissed him.' 'Have another wank thinking about it.' They kept coming coming, unlike Liam's replies which remained absent.
MONDAY NIGHT
[HEY, I KNOW THINGS ARE A BIT WEIRD, BUT PLEASE DON'T IGNORE ME] Ryan sent.
This time a reply came just a few minutes later. [I'M NOT IGNORING YOU, I JUST DON'T KNOW WHAT TO SAY]
[WE DON'T HAVE TO TALK ABOUT IT, WE CAN JUST PRETEND IT NEVER HAPPENED]
Liam sent no more replies that evening, leaving Ryan to fall asleep with his phone still in his hand.
TUESDAY MORNING
[PLEASE TALK TO ME] Ryan sent.
No reply
TUESDAY AFTERNOON
Ryan was beginning to get desperate. A day and a half of thinking about nothing but Liam, the dares in the park and the kiss were driving him crazy. Normally when things went wrong, Liam was there for him, but with Liam now being the problem, he had nobody else he could turn to. He considered messaging Josh, but he couldn't bring himself to do it.
[LIAM, PLEASE, JUST MESSAGE ME BACK. THIS IS KILLING ME]
[WHAT DO YOU WANT?]
[I WANT US TO BE COOL. ARE WE?]
[DUDE, NO!]
Liam's reply felt like a punch to the stomach for Ryan. Despite the things that had happened and the refusal to talk over the last two days, he was still secretly hoping that things would magically go back to normal. This was just further proof that it just wasn't going to happen.
[LOOK, I DON'T WANNA LOSE MY BEST MATE BECAUSE OF ONE STUPID NIGHT]
[I JUST NEED SOME TIME. SPEAK SOON]
WEDNESDAY MORNING
[HEY, YOU OK?] Ryan sent.
Again he got no reply.
WEDNESDAY AFTERNOON
[CAN WE MEET?]
Liam's reply took several minutes but eventually came. [I'M AT WORK. TONIGHT, IN THE PARK, 9. OK?]
[OK, SEE YOU TONIGHT]
WEDNESDAY NIGHT
Ryan was early getting to the park. He climbed over the fence and headed inside. He didn't go too far as he knew he hadn't set a specific location with Liam so he wanted to be able to see his friend when he arrived. He sat down on the grass, watching the seconds tick by on his phone. The day had seemed to drag, but this last half hour seemed almost torturously slow.
Liam eventually appeared, climbing over the fence at about five past nine. As he jumped down and looked down into the park, he saw Ryan sitting there and froze. He wanted to run away and he probably would have if Ryan hadn't already seen him. He walked slowly towards the large man, his heart feeling like it was going to pound right out of his chest.
Ryan stood and waited for Liam to reach him, but remained silent until the smaller man was stood right in front of him. "Hey." he said sheepishly, awkwardly staring down at the ground.
"Hey." Liam replied, also avoiding eye contact.
"Thanks for meeting me." Ryan said quietly.
"No problem." Liam answered even quieter.
They stood in silence, motionless for several minutes.
"Aaargh." Ryan suddenly called out in frustration. "Why's everything so fucked up?" He dropped to the floor, sitting to face down to the lake.
Liam said nothing but sat beside him.
"I don't get what you're so pissed about? Is it cos I kissed you? Or cos I jerked you off? Or... I dunno, just, why are you so fucking pissed at me?" Ryan asked angrily, his gaze fixed on the lake. The silence that followed prompted him to finally look round at Liam. The expression he saw on his friend's face was not the anger or resentment he had expected, it looked more like confusion.
"You think I'm pissed at you?" Liam asked. "I thought... you were pissed at me!"
"No!" Ryan insisted, then thought about it. "Wait, why would I be pissed at you?"
"For kissing you!" Liam said like it was the most obvious thing in the world.
"But you didn't. I kissed YOU!" Ryan said back abruptly.
Their eyes finally met as they looked at each other in confusion.
"So you're not pissed at me, and you think you kissed me?" Liam asked.
"And you think I kissed you?" Ryan replied.
"So neither of us is pissed."
"And we both tried to kiss each other."
"Yeah, I think that kinda sums it up." Liam said.
A momentary silence fell between them again.
"So... do you still wanna kiss me?" Ryan asked, slightly afraid of the answer.
"No!" Liam said back instantly. "Why, do you wanna kiss me?"
"God no!" Ryan said. His reply was a reflex, he didn't actually give it any thought.
"Sunday night was just... because of the alcohol." Liam said matter-of-factly.
"Yeah." Ryan replied eagerly. "Yeah, just the alcohol." His tone of certainty faded off towards the end of the sentence.
Liam looked round as he heard the tone of Ryan's voice change. The bigger man was still staring out at the lake. He reached over to his friend and put his hand on Ryan's knee. Ryan looked round at him, eyes wide, mouth open a little. Liam returned his gaze. He was testing Ryan, but it was testing himself just as much. He moved his hand up a little way onto the heavily-muscled thigh.
Ryan gasped as he felt the young man's hand sliding up his leg. He wanted to jump away, push Liam's hand aside, shout at him to stop but he couldn't bring himself to do it. Even worse, his cock had responded almost immediately, stiffening quickly and tenting his shorts. Liam looked at it, up at Ryan's face, then back down at the bulge. He slowly slid his hand across until his fingers grazed the shaft.
That was too much for Ryan. He smacked Liam's hand aside, rolled backwards and jumped up onto his feet. "I can't do this!"
"I'm sorry..." Liam stuttered., staring round at his best friend. He stood up and faced Ryan.
"What are you doing?" Ryan asked, starting to breathe heavily.
"I don't know." Liam replied honestly as he put a hand on Ryan's shoulder. Slowly he moved closer and closer, tilting his head upwards to the taller man. Their lips were mere inches apart, both men breathing heavily from their nervousness.
Suddenly Ryan grabbed Liam by both shoulders and just held him still, stopping the slow progression to the seemingly inevitable kiss.
"Ryan..." Liam whispered, sounding almost scared.
Ryan gasped, then threw the small man backwards, making him fall to the ground. It was like Sunday night all over again. Ryan turned and ran. He didn't know why he was running, or where he was going. He didn't know what had just happened with Liam, if he had wanted it to continue, or what might have happened if he had stayed. His entire mind was jumbled, the entire park seeming to spin as he ran.
He eventually came to a stop, realising he was now half way round the lake path. "Fuck fuck fuck!" he yelled out, kicking a nearby bench in frustration. He sat down on the bench and threw his head back and closed his eyes. Part of him hoped that when he opened his eyes, Liam would be stood there. The other part though couldn't stand the thought of even looking at him.
When he eventually opened his eyes and stood up, he was still alone. He wanted to get out of there, but knew that walking back round the lake would probably lead him back to Liam so he continued going round the way he had already been heading. As he walked along he recognised the bush the concealed the entrance to the old playground. It seemed like a good place to hide out and clear his head so he pushed his way through and walked down the path. He made his way into the middle of the clearing and sat on the floor, leaning against an old climbing frame.
'Gay isn't contagious you fucktard!' he thought to himself. 'Just cos Josh sucked you off, that doesn't mean you suddenly like guys so get all this shit out of your head.' Regardless of how rational his thoughts were or how right he may have been, he couldn't deny the fact that he had got hard when Liam was touching his leg. He had wanted to kiss Liam both tonight and on Sunday. He had enjoyed wanking Liam off and getting sucked by Josh.
"What the fuck's wrong with me?" he asked himself aloud.
"No idea, but if you figure it out let me know, cos the same thing's wrong with me!" a voice called out from the path. It was Liam.
"Dude, just... leave me alone." Ryan insisted. 'Please don't leave.' he thought at the same time.
Liam ignored the demand and walked over to the sitting young man then knelt down next to him. The bigger man wasn't sure how to respond. Simultaneously he wanted to both punch and kiss Liam.
Liam reached out and placed a hand on each of Ryan's cheeks, then moved in to press their lips together. The kiss lasted just a few seconds, but this time neither of them jumped away.
"Liam." Ryan whispered, "I'm not gay!"
"Neither am I." Liam whispered back, then kissed him again. "I want to fuck you, not marry you!"
Ryan laughed slightly at the comment, then realised what he had really said. "Wait, you... wanna fuck me?"
Liam just stared straight into his eyes, then nodded. He reached down and pulled up Ryan's t-shirt, revealing the big man's muscles. Ryan lifted his arms to allow Liam to remove the clothing. As soon as the t-shirt was pulled over his head Liam was kissing him again, his hands exploring the now exposed chest. Ryan moaned into Liam's mouth as he felt his friend's hands on his body. Nervously he reached out and pulled Liam's top off too, running his hands over the smaller man's hairy chest.
"Ryan, I really wanna fuck you!" Liam said between kisses.
"Okay." Ryan gasped back.
"What the fuck are you doing here?" Ryan demanded as Josh, Dale and the two younger boys approached. "Ah!" he called out as Liam pulled out of his hole suddenly.
"What am I doing here? What the fuck are you two doing here?" Josh demanded back.
"We were just..." Liam started.
"Fucking!" Warren completed the sentence for him before he could make a poor attempt at an excuse.
"Who the fuck are you, kid?" Liam demanded angrily as he stared at the naked boy.
Dale moved to position himself between Liam and Warren. "He's my little brother, Warren."
"You often go for naked late night strolls with your brother?" Ryan demanded, now standing up to face the others. "And you?" he added to Josh as he recognised Josh's little brother too.
"Don't get pissy with me just because we interrupted you and your boyfriend!" Dale snapped, moving closer to the naked man.
"He's not my boyfriend. I'm no fag!" Ryan shouted angrily.
"What did you call me?" Dale snarled furiously.
Just in time to stop them lunging at each other, Josh and Liam grabbed Dale and Ryan, holding them back.
"Hey, let's all just calm down a bit." Josh said, attempting to calm the situation.
As the voices had raised, Warren had clung onto Nick tightly. The older boy now held Warren close, ready to pull him out of harms way if violence erupted.
Dale looked round at his little brother, almost cowering in Nick's arms. "Yeah." he said, calming a little. "No need for things to get carried away."
The anger dropped from Ryan's face too as he saw the scared boy and he nodded his agreement.
Josh turned to Nick and said, "Why don't you two go spend some time together while we talk."
In other circumstances, Nick might have been annoyed about being treated like a kid and told to walk away while the 'grown-ups' talked, but at that moment he was as keen to get away from the tension as Warren was. "C'mon, Warren, let's go."
"Okay." Warren said quietly, allowing Nick to lead him away from the four older boys. The two of them headed to the other side of the playground and settling down on a grassy patch.
Nick spread out and lay flat on the ground, staring up into the night sky. He lifted his arm and gestured for Warren to lay down with him. The younger boy complied and cuddled up to Nick, both boys enjoying the skin-on-skin contact as their bodies pressed together.
"I thought they were gonna start hitting each other." Warren said, the concern for his brother obvious from his tone.
"Forget about them, now it's just you and me." Nick reassured him. Warren laughed quietly at the comment prompting Nick to ask, "What's so funny?"
"You just seem so confident now. It's a bit of a change from three hours ago. You could barely even look at me then!" Warren explained.
Nick was glad of the position they were laying in as it meant Warren couldn't see his face and realise how much he was blushing. It really did seem strange that their first awkward moments had been mere hours before. Now he was laying naked under the stars, the beautiful boy held tightly in his arms. Thinking about it was beginning to make him revert to his earlier shyness and he struggled to speak.
Warren propped himself up on one arm and turned to face Nick. "I didn't mean to embarrass you. I actually thought it was... really sweet. It was one of the reasons I liked you right away."
Nick smiled at the comments, the boy's reassurance helping to snap him out of it. Nick pushed him so that he rolled over onto his back, then leant over so that he was looking straight down at Warren. As it usually was, his hair was hanging down over one side of his face, so the older boy brushed it aside before lowering his lips onto the younger boy's.
The kissing lasted for several minutes, their movements slow and delicate, their lips barely even touching. Nick ran his fingers through the boy's hair as they kissed, while Warren's hands found their way round onto the bigger boy's back, stroking up and down the bare flesh. As Nick moved, his now-engorged cock pressed into Warren's hip.
Warren was just about to reach down and take Nick's cock in his hand when they were disturbed by a shout from the others.
"Hey, you two, time to go." Josh called out.
Their kiss parted and they looked over in the direction of the sound. Josh was stood there with Dale and Liam, but Ryan was gone.
Nick planted another quick peck on Warren's lips then said, "I think we should come back here and continue this another time."
"Definitely!" Warren agreed as the two boys climbed up onto their feet.
The five of them headed down the path back towards the lake, then started following the main path back round the water. Liam and Josh were at the front, talking as they walked while Dale hung back with the two younger boys.
"So what happened? Where's Ryan?" Nick asked.
"Simple version, there's some stuff going on between Liam and Ryan. Ryan's solution was to get pissed and run away, Liam is just really confused so he's coming back with us to see if he can figure some stuff out." Dale explained to the two boys.
"So we're heading back to Benny's house now?" Warren asked nervously.
"Yeah." Dale replied unhappily. He could tell that his little brother was as anxious as he was about the prospect of getting there naked. While they had been wandering round in the park, it had been quite easy to get used to their nudity, but leaving the park felt like returning to the real world and it scared them both.
"Hey, at least you've only gotta do it once. This is my second time!" Nick replied, sensing the others' anxiety. "And at least you won't be on film!" He added, remembering the recording Benny and Corey had taken of him earlier.
"Oh yeah, I so need a copy of that!" Warren said, grinning.
Nick glared at him angrily as he attempted to hold back a smile. He found it impossible to actually be annoyed at the boy.
"So is Liam gay too?" Nick asked after a few moments of quiet.
Dale looked ahead at the young man walking alongside Josh, then back round at Nick. "I'm not really sure, but I don't think so."
"But he was fucking a guy!" Warren insisted.
Dale shrugged. "I dunno. Sometimes guys get so horny they'll fuck anything that moves, sometimes they experiment with new things, maybe it's something like that."
"Wait, so does this mean he'll be joining in with our games?" Nick suddenly asked happily.
Dale grinned. He hadn't thought of that, but now that Nick mentioned it, if he was coming home with them then it was definitely a possibility. "Maybe. I wonder how Benny will feel about us bringing home a new toy for him."
"He won't be feeling anything. I'm still gonna kill him for leaving us here!" Nick said angrily.
"C'mon, it hasn't all been bad!" Warren said, taking the older boy's hand. "Has it?"
Nick sighed. "I guess not."
"Hey guys, Liam's got some good news for us." Josh said, stopping and turning to face the other three before looking back to Liam.
"I drove here tonight. I can give you all a lift back to your friend's house." Liam said, smiling as he heard the sighs of relief and happy shouts from the three naked boys .
"Come on then. Let's go." Josh said happily.
The five of them made their way out of the park and piled into Liam's car. It only took a few minutes to reach Benny's house. Benny had left the door unlocked ready for their arrival so they walked straight in.
"Took ya long enough, what kept ya?" Benny called out, running into the hallway as he heard the door open. He looked inquisitively as he saw Liam stood amongst the four naked boys.
"Oh, hey Liam. What you doing here?" Corey asked as he emerged behind Benny.
"It's okay if Liam joins us, isn't it?" Josh asked, making his way to the front of the group.
Benny just shrugged. As far as he was concerned, the more guys there were the better the night would be. "Yeah, why not."
"Hey, did you come here by car?" Corey asked, catching a glimpse of Liam's car through the closing door. "That's cheating!"
"Whose idea was it to leave us there?" Nick demanded angrily.
Seeing the older boy's fury, both Benny and Corey pointed at each other instantly attempting to avoid the blame. Nick's anger disappeared as he started laughing at the two boys.
"Come on, let's go back into the lounge." Josh said, walking through the group with Liam following closely behind.
The new arrival looked quite nervous. When Josh had explained what had been happening with him and the other boys, Liam had been immediately interest, verging on outright excited. Now that he was here though, seeing the four naked guys in proper illumination and the two younger boys waiting for them, it suddenly became a lot more real and much scarier too. As he walked into the lounge behind Josh, doing his best to pretend he wasn't closely observing his friend's bare rear, he looked round and saw the various toys that had been left laying around from their earlier activities.
"Looks like you've been having a good night so far..." Liam said nervously.
"It's been... interesting!" Dale replied as he took a seat on the sofa.
The rest of the boys all sat down, leaving the newest attendee standing in the middle of the room, unsure of where he should go.
"I think the new boy needs to be initiated." Benny said with a wicked smile.
"Wait, what?" Liam asked, looking from grinning face to face. "I'm not sure about this!"
"Take your clothes off!" Benny ordered.
Liam just stared back at him, rooted to the spot.
"Okay, Josh, Dale, give him a hand." Benny added, seeing that he was not obeying.
The two older boys got up and approached Liam, Dale standing in front of him, Josh behind.
"Don't worry dude, I think you're gonna enjoy this." Josh whispered quietly in his friend's ear. "And any time you wanna stop, just say so and you can leave."
"Okay." Liam whispered back, then gulped.
Josh began pulling Liam's shirt up over his head while Dale had crouched down and started undoing his belt. Seconds later, the shirt was off and the jeans were round his ankles, leaving him in just a pair of white briefs. His cock was already showing signs of swelling, and it wasn't the only one. The four younger boys sat watching were all playing with their growing cocks as they saw Liam's body slowly get exposed. It was as hairy as Dale's, but much more muscular, a body type none of them had really seen up close so far, so their interest was most definitely piqued.
"Them too!" Benny said, pointing at the underwear.
Dale and Josh each grabbed a side and quickly yanked them down. Liam's cock popped out, almost up to its full six inches, weighed down by his large heavy balls.
"What now?" Josh asked, standing back up alongside Dale and Liam.
"Tell us Liam, have you ever sucked a cock before?" Benny asked.
Liam shook his head in response as the others watched on eagerly, anticipating what was coming next.
"Well you're luck then, you get to pick you first one. Line up everyone. Corey, get naked." Benny ordered the room.
Benny and Corey quickly pulled off their clothes and formed a line with the other four. Whether by subconscious intent or by chance, they stood in age order, starting with Corey, the Benny, Warren, Nick, Dale and Josh.
"Now, Josh obviously isn't an option, but choose one of us five to give your first blow job!" Benny instructed the trembling teen.
Liam looked at the line-up. The two eldest seemed the obvious choices, the ages of Corey, Benny and Warren putting Liam off of choosing them, but that meant he was choosing the bigger cocks. Sucking dick was something he had never really thought about. Over the last few days, he had contemplated fucking Ryan, but blow jobs had never really come into it. The only oral he had ever been involved with was getting blow jobs from girls and going down on them in return. Yet the thought of it now didn't repulse him as he thought it might, in fact, his own cock seemed to be engorging just a little more in anticipation of it.
"I think... erm... Dale." Liam said quietly.
The other boys all sounded a little disappointed as they went to sit back down. "Hold on. He's got another choice to make." Benny said, stopping them all in their tracks. "Who do you want to suck you off?"
"Josh!" Liam replied instantly.
The speed of his answer surprised them all, but Josh looked fairly happy with it.
"Okay then, have a seat." Benny said, directing Liam to the sofa where he sat down.
Dale walked up to the sofa, playing with his dick, ensuring it was fully up and ready for action. Josh approached too, kneeling down in front of Liam.
"You okay with this?" Josh asked as he placed a hand on Liam's hairy thigh. He got a nod in response so he moved his hand higher and wrapped it around the young man's swollen shaft.
As if he were being instructed by Josh, Liam did the same, sliding his hand up Dale's leg and taking hold of the rigid cock. Simultaneously, both boys took the cocks into their mouths.
"Mmmmm." Liam moaned as he felt Josh's lips around his organ. The vibration of his pleasured moan made Dale do the same.
As they watched, all four of the younger boys began wanking, Nick and Benny slowly, Warren and Corey both quite vigorously.
"Fuck that's hot." Warren growled. "Benny, are we allowed to cum?"
"No." Benny replied, his eyes remaining fixed on the older boys in action.
Warren slowed his stroking in response as he could already feel himself getting close.
"Okay, that's enough!" Benny called out. The disappointment on Dale, Liam and Josh's faces made the boy smile, but he knew they would get relief soon enough... except for Josh of course! He got up and ran into the kitchen then came back in carrying the glass they had been using earlier to cum into. "Who remembers this?"
There was a general groan of unhappiness from the boys and a look of great confusion from Liam. "What's that?" he asked gingerly.
"Cum." Dale said abruptly. "It's a glass of cum, and earlier Benny said one of us was gonna have to drink it."
"Yep, still true." Benny said with a smile.
"At least there's not loads in it!" Corey said as he looked at the relatively small puddle in the bottom of it.
"Well that's gonna change after the next game." Benny replied quickly. "We're all gonna wank. We have one hour. Whoever cums the least in that time, has to drink it. And it only counts if you do it into the glass." Some of the boys groaned unhappily, while the others just stared in shock.
"What about me?" Josh asked, gesturing towards his restrained cock.
"Well you won't cum at all and it's kinda tempting to say you'd lose by default, but I'm not feeling quite that mean. Instead, you can be in charge of the glass and keeping count of everybody's scores.
Josh thought about it for a moment. On one hand, seeing the other six guys cumming over and over, up close, would be hot, but on the other hand, it would just turn him on more and make his own need to cum even more desperate.
Benny went and grabbed a piece of paper and a pencil for Josh to write down the scores before sitting back in an armchair ready to give instructions. "Okay, sit where you like, do whatever you want to yourselves but no touching each other. This is a solo mission! Everybody ready?" He looked round the room and was greeted by a mix of happy and worried looking nods.
"Hey, what do we do if there's a tie?" Nick asked, just before Benny could tell them to start.
"Sudden death. Anyone in joint last position wanks again and the last one to cum, loses." Benny explained.
Nick thought he was catching Benny out. This was one of the games they had talked about earlier, but the subject of tie breakers never came up, so either Benny had been planning alone since then, or he was just worryingly good at thinking this stuff up on the spot.
"Okay then, the hour starts... now!" Benny said.
Without a moment's hesitation, all six of the naked boys and young men grabbed their cocks and started pumping away. Corey and were sat together on one of the armchairs again, Dale and Liam had spread out to take over the whole sofa, Nick and Warren were sat side-by-side on the floor in front of the other armchair while Josh sat alone on the other side of the room, watching the game unfold.
Josh's mind started to wander as he watched. 'Oh my God, look at them go. If I was playing this I'd have it won, I feel like I could cum about a hundred times right now! It's weird seeing Liam here, woulda been even weirder if Ryan hadn't run off. I should message him tomorrow and see if he's okay. Wow, Warren looks ready to cum already.'
Nick and Warren couldn't take their eyes off of each other as they both jerked off. Their expressions alone showed how much they just wanted to jump on top of each other and do a lot more than wank, but they both knew better than to break the rules of one of Benny's games. Warren's earlier stimulation had obviously not died down yet as they were only a few minutes into the game when he jumped up and ran over to Josh. The older boy picked up the glass and held it up as Warren stroked his cock a final few times before adding his load to the glass. "Ah yeah, yeah, yeah." he moaned breathlessly, staring straight into Josh's eyes as he unloaded.
"One for Warren." Josh said as he pulled the glass away. The younger boy returned to his seat next to Nick as Josh wrote down the point on the score sheet.
As if seeing Warren cum had pushed him over the edge, Corey jumped up too, throwing himself to the floor in front of Josh and thrusting his small cock into the glass without lifting it up. Silently, but panting Corey deposited a few squirts into the receptacle before winking at Josh and returning to his seat.
Josh's cock was aching as it remained semi-aroused, held back by the device but constantly trying to grow. It twitched just a little more as he saw Liam getting ready to stand up. At the same time, Nick also climbed onto his feet. Josh held up the glass as both of them attempted to cum into it. Their cocks pressed together making them both gasp before they simultaneously shot their loads. Nick's was just a few squirts as he had already cum a couple of times that night, but Liam's looked like he hadn't cum in a week. Shot after shot hit the side of the glass and oozed down, seeming to almost double the quantity already collected.
"Looked like you needed that!" Josh said with a grin as he lowered the glass.
Liam just smiled awkwardly before turning to head back to the sofa. Nick was still stood there having enjoyed the show. "Nice." he mouthed silently to Josh as he watched Liam walk away before doing the same.
Josh updated the score sheet. By the time he looked up again, Benny was approaching quickly. He grabbed the glass, and stuck his cock inside it, whimpering with pleasure for a few seconds before handing it to Josh. Now it was just Dale who was yet to score. Josh looked over at him, taking in the wonderful view of the beautiful young man, sat pumping away at his cock, eyes closed.
"Oh fuck." Dale called out suddenly, before opening his eyes and approaching Josh.
With another load added, Josh noticed that the glass was now starting to look a lot more intimidating as far as forfeits go. He suddenly found himself very glad of his cock cage as it had excluded him from the possibility of receiving the punishment for a change. Although as he sat there, watching the boys all do their best to recover quickly from their orgasms so they could start again, he wondered what it would be like to swallow it. He had enjoyed swallowing the loads he had taken so far, but so many at once may be a little different.
That started him thinking about who might lose the challenge. It would be fun to see Benny lose for a change, although he guessed that if that happened, he would just make someone else do it in his place anyway. Liam could be interesting too. The young man was even newer to all this stuff than the rest of them, so seeing him suddenly given such a forfeit would definitely challenge him, although it might put him off too. Josh would hate to see Liam miss out on something that he was just beginning to discover, just because of one bad experience.
The boys were gradually starting to get hard once again and the second round of wanking began. Josh sat there for the next fifty minutes keeping score and repeatedly raising the increasingly heavy glass. As the end of the hour approached, it was easily more than half full. The scores were relatively close too, except for Corey who was miles ahead of the others. It seemed the youngest McKenzie was a human spunk factory. The boy had managed to cum eight times. In second place was Warren with five, then Benny with four while Nick and Dale were tied on three. Liam had only managed to cum once more since his first orgasm, leaving him in last place, but he looked like he was almost ready to cum again.
Josh watched the clock. There was only a minute to go as Liam got up and shot a third load into the glass, bringing him equal with Nick and Dale. "Time's up!" Josh called out as the hour concluded.
Warren and Benny had stopped wanking, fairly confident that their scores had kept them out of the danger zone, while Nick and Dale had still been pumping furiously for fear of ending up at the bottom. Despite being the clear leader, Corey had still been going too, apparently wanting an even higher score than he already had.
"And the scores. Benny wins with eight, Warren has five, Benny got four, then Dale, Liam and Nick all have three." Josh announced.
"Sudden death it is!" Benny called out happily.
Liam looked distraught. He had only just managed to get the last load out while Nick and Dale both looked close to cumming their fourth. If they went again right away, he knew he was going to lose.
"Okay, you three get together in the middle. Stand facing each other." Benny instructed. The three finalists did as ordered, coming together in the middle of the room. "To help speed things along, this time you can have some help. Corey, help your brother, Warren, you too. Josh, you can join in now, why don't you lend Liam a hand!"
Liam looked round at his friend. The thought of being touched by him was both terrifying and exciting, but most of all, if it was likely to help him cum quicker and avoid the forfeit, then he was up for it. The three helpers all took their places next to the finalists, Josh handing the glass to Benny. "You'd better be good, I really don't wanna lose!" Liam whispered to Josh.
"I can make you cum quickly, but it might... be a bit weird!" Josh offered quietly.
"Do it!" Liam said instantly.
"Okay, no point wasting time. Begin!" Benny called out, raising the glass.
Liam, Nick and Dale took hold of their cocks once again, all knowing how important it was for them to cum. Corey moved round in front of Nick and started sucking on his nipples, causing his big brother to yelp excitedly. Warren reached down and fondled Warren's balls with one hand, tweaking a nipple with the other, getting a similar reaction to Nick.
Liam looked round in a panic. Instead of touching him, Josh was walking away. He picked up the bottle of lube, squeezed some onto his fingers then returned. "What are you..." Liam started, but stopped as he felt Josh's hand reach down to his arse.
Josh quickly found Liam's hole, slicked it up a little and pushed two fingers inside. Normally he would have started gently with one, but Liam had said he didn't want to lose so there was no time to take it slowly. His fingers quickly found their mark, hitting against the young man's prostate.
"Oh fuck!" Liam called out, his hand stopping in shock.
"Keep wanking!" Josh called out as he finger-fucked his friend.
Liam did as he was told, resuming his jerking while his legs trembled beneath him and his hole throbbed at the sudden invasion. Whatever Josh was doing though, it was working. It was like a really intense jerk-off session but in fast forward.
"I'm gonna cum!" he called out, partly to let Benny know he needed the glass, and partly in outright surprise.
Benny got the glass in place just in time. The orgasm was brief but violent, just a few squirts, but making Liam's entire body shake. Liam was breathing heavily and his legs felt like they were about give way. As Josh pulled his fingers out, the legs finally buckled. Josh steadied him a little and lead him to the sofa where they both sat heavily. Liam leaned against his friend as he struggled to catch his breath and regain his composure. They had both almost forgotten that the competition was still going.
Seeing what Josh had just done for Liam, both Corey and Warren slid a finger round into their respective brother's arse cracks. From the noises Dale and Nick were making, they were both close to cumming, but ultimately it was Nick who got there first, adding his last few drops to the glass mere seconds before Dale shot a few drops futilely into the air.
"Fuck it!" Dale panted angrily as he realised he had lost.
"Sorry bro." Warren said, not sounding at all sincere as he walked away to sit with Nick once again.
Corey also returned to his seat, leaving just Dale and Benny standing. The younger boy held out the glass and Dale took it from him, a queasy look on his face.
"What if I refuse to drink it?" Dale asked in the vain hope that whatever punishment Benny decided on would be preferable to half a pint of spunk.
"Erm..." Benny said, thinking as he joined Corey. "If you don't drink it, you get shaved just like Josh, and when the chastity device comes off of him, it goes on you and stays there for a month!"
"Ooh, take the punishment!" Corey said eagerly.
Dale stared at Benny open-mouthed. He clearly wanted him to drink the cum if he was making up punishments that bad as an alternative. "Fine." Dale said, raising the glass.
"Urrrgh, he's gonna do it!" Warren called out, covering his eyes, but still peeking between his fingers.
"Just think of it as a milkshake." Josh said supportively, then grinned and added, "Made of six guys' spunk!"
Dale glared at him angrily, then looked back to the glass again. Without another word, he put the glass to his lips, tipped it back and downed the entire load in a few heavy gulps. He tipped the glass completely upside down to let the last few thick drops ooze onto his tongue before he swallowed them too. As he looked round at his audience, they cheered loudly for him. He raised the empty glass in the air triumphantly and the cheering loudened.
When the cheering finally stopped, Benny stood up and took the glass of Dale, then turned to the others and said, "Okay, do what you like for now. When I decide what's next I'll let you know."
All the boys started chatting to each other, finally free of Benny's instructions and able to just talk to each other. Dale joined Liam and Josh on the sofa.
Half an hour later, Josh got up from the sofa, caught Benny's attention and lead him into the kitchen.
"What's up?" Benny asked once they were alone.
"Liam's still a bit confused over some of the stuff that's happening, so I just wanted to know if you mind if the three of us head up to the spare room so we can talk." Josh said, feeling a little embarrassed that he was essentially asking the boy for his permission.
"Sure, I was just talking to the others about playing some video games in my room anyway. We'll go do that while you guys talk." Benny agreed.
The two of them went back into the lounge then lead their respective groups upstairs into the two bedrooms. The four younger boys were noisy right from the start, so Josh closed the bedroom door behind him as Liam and Dale made their way inside. The three of them sat on the bed silently, Josh and Dale hoping Liam would just talk, while Liam had been hoping that the other two might lead the conversation.
Eventually Josh felt he had to say something. "So, what's going on with you?"
Liam opened his mouth to speak, but instead just sighed. "I wish I knew. Even without the weirdness between me and Ryan, my head's totally fucked. Despite what you've seen tonight, I'm really not gay."
Josh and Dale looked at each other, then at Liam.
"Don't look at me like that. I mean it. I'm not gay and just to be clear, I'm not saying there's anything wrong with it either, it's just that... I'm not. This was all just new and... horny and... I was thinking with my cock instead of my head." Liam tried to explain, starting to get upset.
"D'you need a hug?" Josh taunted him.
"Fuck off!" Liam snapped back angrily.
Josh had just been teasing, but as he saw the look on Liam's face, he realised he may have actually been right. He moved closer to Liam and held his arms out. Liam glared at him angrily for a moment before realising it was a genuine gesture rather than another taunt. He allowed himself to fall against Josh, his head resting against his friend's bare chest as the young man wrapped his arms around him. Dale moved forward too and placed one hand on Josh's shoulder, the other on Liam's.
They sat like that for a few minutes before Liam sat up and sheepishly said, "Thanks guys."
"No problem." Dale smiled kindly.
"So are you two, like, a couple or something, cos that's definitely the vibe I'm getting." Liam asked, suddenly turning the focus away from himself.
"Erm, well..." Josh stuttered.
"Erm, it's... still early." Dale answered eventually.
"Aww, look how shy you both got. Aren't you cute." Liam took his turn to do the teasing.
"Shut up." Dale said, grinning.
"So which one of you's the top?" Liam asked, enjoying embarrassing his two friends.
"Well at the moment, I don't think Josh is gonna be doing much fucking, is he?" Dale replied, laughing at Josh's misfortune.
"Yeah, thanks for reminding me!" Josh said back, pushing Dale so he fell over onto his back, laughing. Josh jumped after him, play fighting with the laughing teen. When they eventually stopped, they looked at Liam who appeared to be contemplating something.
"What's up?" Josh asked, sitting up again.
"I was just wondering... if you two might... let me watch you fuck?" Liam asked, sounding terrified of his own question.
Josh and Dale looked at each other. They had fucked earlier with the four younger boys watching, this wouldn't really be any different so they both shrugged and nodded. Liam quickly ran downstairs and grabbed the bottle of lube from the lounge. By the time he came back up, Dale was laying on the bed with his legs hanging over the sides, his cock rigidly reaching for the ceiling. Josh stood beside him, waiting for the lubrication to prepare himself. He keenly took it from Liam, lubed up his hold and then applied some to Dale's dick.
Josh climbed up onto the bed, straddling Dale then positioned himself so that he could sit straight down onto Dale's erection. It slid inside easily and he sat all the way down, taking in his entire length. Liam was watching closely, the other young man's eyes seeming to increase the excitement of the fucking. Josh got a steady rhythm going as he pulled himself up and down Dale's shaft. After a few minutes, he leaned down to Dale and whispered something in his ear. Dale looked at him, wide-eyed and clearly shocked, but nodding.
Josh sat back up and turned to face Liam who was now stroking his own boner. He picked up the bottle of lube and threw it over to him. "We interrupted your fuck earlier, so lube up and join in." Josh instructed.
Liam stared down at the bottle, then over to the two young men who had immediately resumed their fucking. Was he being invited to fuck Josh at the same time as Dale, or after he had finished? He had seen double penetration in porn, but that was two guys in one girl. Josh looked round again and gestured for him to come over. Liam quickly pumped a little lube onto his hand and slicked up his prick before he approached them.
Dale was showing no signs of pulling out, so Liam assumed he was supposed to just join him inside Josh. He stood with his legs either side of Dale's and pushed the head of his cock against the top of Josh's hole. It took quite a lot of pushing, and a lot of moaning from Josh, but eventually the sphincter expanded enough to allow the second cock to begin sliding inside.
All three of them were transported to another world. Liam and Dale felt the stretched tightness of Josh's arse as well as the warmth of another cock pressing against their own while Josh was amazed at how much pleasure came with so little pain.
"Holy... fucking... shit!" Josh called out. He stopped sliding up and down on dale's cock, instead relying on Liam's steadily quickening thrusting to generate the movement. He leant down and kissed Dale as he felt the two solid shafts pulsating inside him. Next he sat up, tilted his head back and looked sideways at Liam who looked back at him, their faces mere inches apart. A moment later they were kissing too.
The kiss broke with Liam pulling away, moaning excitedly as his cock began to twitch. In almost perfect unison, Dale's did the same. Josh found himself cursing the games they had played earlier. He would have loved to feel two huge loads filling his insides, but instead settled for a few quick squirts as the two young men emptied what remained in their balls inside him.
Liam was panting heavily and leaning against Josh's back as his cock slid out. Josh pulled up a little, releasing Dale's cock too. They flopped onto the bed beside Dale and lay there basking in the afterglow of yet another orgasm. A few minutes later, Josh felt his eyes getting heavy.
They closed for what only felt like a few seconds but had more likely been a few minutes. As he looked from side to side, he saw that the other two had fallen asleep as well. As he listened to see if he could hear the boys, he struggled to hear anything. He got up as gently as he could, not disturbing the other two, crept across the room and quietly opened the door. He crossed the hallway and pressed his ear against Benny's bedroom door. Still nothing.
Josh slowly opened the door and peered inside. There lay Benny, Corey, Nick and Warren, all tangled up together on the bed, fast asleep. He flicked off the light and closed the door before returning to Liam and Dale. He lay back down between them and closed his eyes.