Glee and its characters are the property of FOX. I do not own these characters. I welcome your comments. chubbyboyinbama@yahoo.com
Finn wasn't so sure about this. Finn had been hesitant to kiss Artie for the first time. He had definitely been nervous about doing stuff with Kurt or Mike Chang. All this guy sex stuff was still pretty new to him. Finn was incredibly turned on by the idea of sex with guys, but he didn't know what that meant. He liked girls, so he didn't think that meant he could be gay, but still, there were times that he couldn't imagine ever enjoying sex with any girl as much as he did with Artie.
Of course, the most terrifying part was the fear of someone finding out. This was high school, and as much as people like to talk about universal acceptance and Gay Straight Alliances, Finn knew that if the other kids at school knew his secret, it would be the end of his social life, the end of his football career. Simply the end.
After the second time that Finn and Artie had done what they had both taken to calling "sex stuff," the two had settled into a kind of routine. They had started doing sex stuff sometimes once or twice a week. They almost always did this in Artie's bedroom since Finn and Kurt now lived in the same house. Kurt had proved that he was totally discrete about the whole situation, but Finn still felt uneasy about doing things where Kurt might see or hear. Finn and Artie never spoke of the sex stuff outside of Artie's bedroom. Occasionally they would communicated about it via instant message, but not even by text message, as Brittany was constantly swiping Artie's phone to play angry birds and he feared she might see a message about gay sex.
Finn had his usual level of apprehension when one night, after Finn had finished riding Artie's dick until he had shot so hard that it had flown over Artie's head and struck the wall behind the bed, Artie had said, "I know who we should fuck next." The statement had first made Finn chuckle, but then he had gotten nervous. As much as Finn wanted to try new things (with new people) he was so afraid of his secret getting out.
Artie, sensing Finn's trepidation, said, "Don't worry, its Mr. Shue." Finn's jaw dropped. Artie had told Finn about both of the encounters that Artie had had with him. It had never occurred to Finn to try to do something with him. Finn thought Mr. Shue was a good looking guy, and like all of the kids in glee club, he loved Mr. Shue. But the idea of having sex with a "grown-up" had never occurred to Finn. As Finn protested slightly, Artie went on to explain all the reasons that it would work.
Artie reasoned that Mr. Shue was the most trustworthy guy that either of them knew. Mr. Shue had responded well to Artie's advances, and much to his word had not spoken a word to anyone. In a particularly devious tone, Artie even joked that, "Mr. Shue would never tell, cause then he would lose his job for fucking with students!" After several minutes, Finn finally gave it (as he often did with Artie) and it was agreed. Artie, as he had done with Mike and Kurt before, began to lay out a plan.
A few days later, Mr. Shue was grading papers on a Friday night. It was after 11pm, so he was startled by the knock at his door. He smiled when he opened it and found Artie and Finn there. Despite his confusion, Mr. Shue was always happy to see his glee kids. Coaching glee club had restored his purpose in life and made him glad once more that he was a teacher.
"Hey guys," Mr. Shue said. "What are you doing here so late?"
As he said this, he motioned them inside the apartment. Finn pushed Artie in his chair through the door, which Shue closed after them..
Artie did all the talking. "Well, Mr. Shue, Finn and I were in the neighborhood and we thought we would stop by and fuck you." Artie smiled while he said it, but Finn's face turned instantly red by the bluntness of Artie's words. Shue turned equally red. Finn hadn't known exactly what Artie was going to say, but nuance was apparently not on the list.
Mr. Shue took a moment and stammered a little bit before managing to get out, "What are you talking about Artie?"
Mr. Shue couldn't hide his nervousness. He was looking back and forth between the two boys.
"Well, Mr. Shue," Artie said, "I was telling Finn how much fun you and I had together and he thought he might like try that stuff too."
Shue looked like he was about to crawl out of his skin. Finn was just standing there, it would again be up to Artie to take control of the situation. Artie spoke, this time in his calm, reassuring voice. He adjusted his glasses on his nose as he began.
"Come on Mr. Shue. You know what I am talking about. Finn is cool, he isn't going to tell anyone about this. Just three guys trying to have a little fun."
Shue didn't know where to begin. He was about to keep denying that he even understood the situation, but instead, his brain went for, "but you are students, this just wouldn't be right."
Artie smiled, and slipped into his deeper tone of voice, the one that could be almost sinister, "That didn't stop you in that motel room in Cincinatti."
Shue's blood stopped pumping in his veins. His face was pure terror. Artie smiled again, "Come on Mr. Shue. We all want the same thing...Isn't that right Finn." As Artie said this, he put his hand on Finn's leg, but maintained eye contact with Shue. Finn, as Artie had planned out and instructed him to do, took this as his cue to unfasten his belt, unbutton his jeans, and pull down his zipper. Artie had planned out much of the encounter, going into specific details as to when Finn should do something or say something, what positions should be sued, etc. Artie was like a nymphomaniac choreographer.
Shue's eye grew wide, but he was mute. As his mind raced, Finn pulled the two fronts of his jeans apart revealing his tighty whities. His bulge was substantial as he was already nearly hard. Finn was starting to enjoy the role he was playing, the mind games, it was a real turn on, even though Finn didn't really even understand why. As Artie had told him to do before they arrived, Finn took a step to where Mr. Shue was sitting and stood where his crotch was within a foot of Shue's face. Finn smiled and delivered the line that Artie had given him earlier to say at just this moment, "Come on Mr. Shue, "Finn said as he put his large hand down the front of his underwear and pulled out his now hard dick. Finn shook his thick cock a little before completing his sentence, "or we Artie and me will just tell everyone at school that you did it anyway."
Shue was looking Finn right in the eye. Shue was terrified and excited all at the same time. He could tell from Finn's face and tone of voice that his threat to reveal this to people at the school wasn't a real one, but part of his brain thought that maybe it really was. Shue was also wildly turned on. Finn was a sexy guy, and he had jerked off more than a couple times thinking about Finn. Then there was also Artie. The two times that he and Artie had been together were the most erotic and sexually satisfying of Shue's life. After 10 seconds that seemed like two hours, Shue didn't speak, but rather leaned forward and put his mouth on the tip of Finn's dick.
Finn exhaled sharply with pleasure and Artie almost cheered, "Yeah! That's it Mr. Shue, I told Finn you wouldn't let us down!"
Shue shifted his eye contact to Artie, but didn't take his mouth off of Finn's dick. Though it was hard to tell with Shue's mouth full of cock, he shot Artie a smile. While Shue slowly sucked his dick, Finn took off his shirt and pushed his jeans as far down as he could without bending too much. Shue pulled them the rest of the way down as he noticed out of the corner of his eye that Artie had already unfastened his pants and had his own huge dick in his hand.
Finn pushed his fingers through Shue's curly hair as Shue eagerly took all of Finn's cock into his mouth and just down the top of his throat. Finn smiled wide and moaned softly as Shue worked on his dick. While they were doing this, Artie prepped for the next step. Artie had pushed himself next to a chair in the living room and in what was almost lighting speed, he had lifted himself out of his wheelchair and swung himself into the living room chair. He positioned his legs wide apart and his huge cock stood straight up. From the backpack on the back of his wheelchair, he quickly retrieved condoms and lube. Shue saw out of the corner of his eye what Artie was doing and smiled again.
Artie slid the magnum condom down on his nine plus inches and doused himself with lube. With a smile, Artie said, "Bring him over here, Finn." Finn put his hand on Shue's arm and guided him over to Artie. Shue, thinking he knew what was next, turned away from Artie and started to back up to Artie's dick. Artie spoke softly. "Not yet Mr. Shue, this is for Finn." Shue chuckled slightly as Finn took his place and backed up to Artie dick. Finn squatted over Artie's dick and put the tip at the edge of his asshole. In what had now become a practiced move for Finn, He bent his knees and pushed down on Artie until his own hole relented and allowed Artie's dick head to pop inside of him. He grunted and Artie made an mmm sound. Shue smiled with excitement and amazement when he watched as Finn quickly slid all the way down on Artie's dick, coming to rest of Artie's lap. It was clear that Finn was in some pain, but it was mostly pleasure. Shue reasoned (and was correct) that Finn had adapted to Artie's massive dick through multiple encounters.
Once Finn was all the way down, he sighed as Artie rubbed his hands on Finn's smooth muscular chest. Shue knelt once more and was about to take Finn's dick in his mouth again when Finn pushed him away a little and said, "Get naked." Shue jumped up and quickly stripped revealing his own tight, only slightly hairy body and throbbing dick. He started to kneel again but Finn stopped him and smirked, "You don't get off that easy." Shue looked at him confused, but Finn smiled and said, "Turn around". Shue smiled and obeyed. This had been another cue, as Artie's hands appeared around front of Finn's body with an already unwrapped condom and slipped it down on Finn's cock. More lube, and he was ready. Finn put a hand on each of Shue's hips and pulled him toward him. The same familiar move, the tip of Finn's dick at Shue's ass, pressure, pain, and then bam, the head of Finn's cock was inside Shue. Shue moaned loudly, as he clearly had not had as much practice as Finn with dick in his ass.
Shue stopped short of protesting, so Finn continued to slowly but steadily pull Shue back onto his dick. Without too much effort, Finn was able to pull Shue all the way back until their bodies touched. Shue was almost crying, but he was handling it pretty well. Finn held him tight with one hand but stroked Shue's cock with the other. After a few moments, Finn pushed Shue off a little and then raised himself up off of Arties dick. It took some maneuvering but finally Finn and Shue were positioned just right over Artie and Finn began to move his own hips. They position was one that Shue and Artie stayed still. Finn would thrust his hip forward and drive his dick all the way into Shue. When Finn would pull back and out of Shue's ass, he would be impaled on Artie's big dick.
Artie made little sound as he enjoyed this thing he had planned so carefully. The turn on was amazing. It would almost seem that he could make anyone do anything! Finn was also silent. In a way he couldn't believe that he was doing this, but in another way, he felt amazing and alive and like some kind of porn star. Shue was not silent. With each stroke, Shue would make sounds of both pleasure and pain. Finn was also stroking Shue's cock furiously.
Artie had planned to do this for at least several minutes. It didn't turn out that way. Shue, who was incredibly turned on, had also not had sex in three months and hadn't jerked off in 4 days. The pleasure was simply too much for him to handle. Shue managed to pant, "I'm gonna...." Before his cock exploded in several strands of cum. His cock aimed down, he blasted his jizz all over the rug, a nearby chair, and the motion of the fucking also managed to get sticky all over his stomach . Finn didn't know that Shue was coming, but he didn't know that he would have stopped fucking even if he had known. Finn kept rocking himself into Shue and then onto Artie. As Finn's cock pounded into Shue again and again as the orgasm subsided, Shue began to shudder. Shue, having cum, couldn't take being fucked much more. Finn somehow sensed this and pushed Shue off of his dick, but kept sitting on Artie's. Shue turned around, knelt in his own jizz and wripped the condom off of Finn. He once again buried his face on Finn's dick. After several more minute of hard fucking of both Finn's ass and Shue's mouth, Finn was ready to cum too. He warned Shue, but Shue kept sucking. As Finn was about to cum, he made one last effort to push Shue's head off of his dick, but it was futile. Shue resisted and as Finn began to cum, Shue buried his face hard into Finn's pubes as Finn's dick exploded cum down the back of Shue throat. Shue caughed a little, but didn't allow a drop to leave his mouth. Shue swallowed hard and then again, taking all of Finn's cum.
Once Finn had cum, he began bobbing even faster up and down on Artie's dick. Within a couple minutes, Artie tapped Finn on the shoulder, which was the cue to get off. Finn stood and as Artie's cock came out of his ass, he felt empty and hollow from where the massive meat had been. Artie removed the condom and began stroking, but without prompting, Shue once again knelt and took dick in his mouth, only this time it was Arties.
Artie smiled as he felt Shue's throat open up to accomidate Artie's massive dick. There was some gagging, but Shue was somehow able to get it all the way in. After a few more seconds, Artie panted that he was going to cum, and much as he had with Finn, he just pushed down hard and filled his throat with Artie's cock so that Artie's cum would have no place to go but down his throat. With no further attempt from Artie to get him off of his dick, Artie likewise began to cum. It was a long orgasm that made his body shudder as shot after shot came zooming out his dick and down Shue's throat. When he had finally stopped shaking, Shue finally pulled slowly off of his dick and licked it clean.
Finn, who had watched this last encounter while standing nearby, collapsed to the floor next to Shue who were both leaning onto Artie's lap, smiling and spent, all three covered in sweat. Artie smiled again and Shue and Finn smiled back. Artie adjusted his glasses again, "If you liked that, just wait till you see what we have planned for you next."