My name's Cody. I'm not the coolest kid at Gilbert High School, but I can fit in with the popular crowds well enough. Mostly because a lot of us did sports together growing up, mainly soccer and volleyball for me.
Halloween night, Stacy DeMerco is throwing a huge costume party, and I heard a lot of the other athlete guys I know talking about going, so I figured it must be pretty awesome. Sometimes I'm kind of the jokester. People at school don't take me too seriously, but I use humor to compensate for my slender build, lack of confidence, and to cover up the fact that I'm gay. In the locker rooms, I love messing around, whipping with towels and wrestling. Rubbing up against those other hot, hairy bodies is like my paradise, but everyone thinks I'm just messing around. I suppose that's good for me anyway. So for Stacy's party, I decide I'm going to dress up as Tinker Bell. I bought the fairy outfit with the blonde wig and everything, it was perfect. Then it turns out I can't get a ride to the party! Stacy only lives a 20 minute walk away, but by the time I get ready and make my way over there, things have already heated up & most people are pretty drunk.
When I walked in, it was really dark with loud music blasting and a few flashing lights for dance floor effect. From what I could tell, most of the other dudes didn't really dress up that much; mainly the girls did, trying to slut it up for the jocks and rich guys. I felt dumb in my big Tinker Bell costume, but it seemed like people couldn't really tell who I was anyway. After hanging out and finishing a few beers, I went to try and find the bathroom. I couldn't find Stacy to ask her, and ended up stumbling into a bedroom. It was dark and I was a little dizzy. Suddenly, two big hands grabbed my shoulder from behind and spun me around. "Cindee, where you been?? I texted you like 9 times, I thought we were gonna hang out tonight." It was Ben Hogan, a big 6'3" football player and discus thrower from my school. Ben was a junior, while I was a sophomore, and we never did any of the same sports, so I guess he wouldn't know me. Apparently he was drunk and thought I was Cindee Jensen, whom he'd hooked up with a few weekends ago. Since then, I heard she'd given Ben the cold shoulder. "You said you wanted to see me tonight, and I really wanna see you.." I opened my mouth to explain that I was Cody, not Cindee, but Ben pulled the back of my neck in and started macking on me, thinking I was this hot girl. His tongue slipped in and out of my mouth as we sucked face, and I could taste the vodka and Red Bull he'd been downing all night. I let out a little girly moan. He wasn't an amazing kisser or anything, but this was still pretty awesome. Top 3 fantasies for sure. "God Cindee, you're so hot. You know I like you, I've wanted that hot ass all year," he breathed his Red Bull breath in my ear as he reached around and squeezed my ass. You would think this might give away that I wasn't Cindee, but 1) Ben was drunk, and 2) I actually do have a really juicy butt that the guys love to slap in the locker room. I decided to play along. I slipped my left hand down Ben's nylon gym shorts and felt his semi-hard bulge. With my right hand, I slowly closed the bedroom door behind us. My hand glided into his boxers and touched the beast within. I could already tell it was thick and going to get even bigger. Ben let out a long sigh, giving my ass another good squeeze while I gently stroked his hardening cock. Then he sprung into action, grabbing me and turning me face-down onto the bed. He pulled something out his pocket and I heard the sound of a wrapper tearing. A condom? This guy came prepared. He pushed my Tinker Bell dress up over my butt and yanked the pink nylons I had underneath down so that my butt and thighs were bare, facing him, as I was bent over the edge of the bed. He must've gotten the condom on because I heard him starting to breathe deeply and felt the lubed tip of his now fully hard cock pressing up against my asshole. "You ready for this, bitch? I guess you didn't like it so much last time, but this time I'll make sure you never forget it." Uh oh.. Big Ben Hogan was about to angry revenge fuck me with his huge swollen dick. I turned around to try and get a peak in the dark and saw his monster that must have been at least 8 inches long, and his big walnuts hanging bellow it. I tried to make a high girly voice like Cindee's and squeaked, "Uh, give it to me big boy, I'm ready for you." He didn't need any second invite as he plundered all the way into my ass until his taut 8-pack abs were pressed against my cheeks. He slid his big snake out and back in, letting out a loud moan as he did. Then he started pumping in and out, fucking me on the bed. My whole body kept lurching forward with the force of his thrusts. "Damn baby, either your pussy got hella tight or I'm fuckin you in the ass! Oh god, uhhhh soo good!" he bellowed. I tried my squeaky Cindee voice again, through my grimacing teeth, "Oh yeah, fuck me!" I knew I should be enjoying it, but it fucking hurt! Not the penetration part, but how far in me his huge donkey dick went. It felt like he was jabbing my insides with that battle club. He kept fucking though, grabbing my waist with his big, strong hands, pulling my hips back into him and he pushed forward, making a loud smacking noise as they met in the middle - again and again and again. Ben threw his head back and groaned, "Ohhh yeah! C'mon baby! Fuck yeah!" He was loving fucking my warm, juicy ass. God, his dick was so big! I was so turned on by this hot jock plowing me doggystyle that I forgot about the pain and felt close to cumming all over the bed. His pace increased and he was breathing more heavily now, shoving his cock deep in me over and over. "Ah yeah, I'm gonna come inside you babe.
You like that? God I'm so close, I'm gonna fucking- ahh ahhhh!! Ah yeahhh! Uhh!" Ben bucked his hips a few solid times as he emptied his nuts in me. As soon as he was done, my own dick shot all over the bedspread and I panted like I'd been holding my breath the entire time. "Oh shit," I heard him say after withdrawing his big snake from my ass.
I felt a surge of panic. Did he realize it was me and not Cindee? "The condom broke.. good thing I came in your ass and not your vag, hahah! My bad, baby, I didn't have any magnums."